Underground Tavern
Milwaukee, WI
1239 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA32 itemsUpdated March 27, 2026
Structured menu data
Cheese Choices
Coop's Sharp White American
Fresh Mozzarella
Habanero Pepper Jack
Mains
Caprese Pesto Bagel
$13.95Baked everything bagel filled with pesto cream cheese, tomato, fresh sliced mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, and seasoned with balsamic glaze.
Chicken Sandwich
$14.95Your choice of grilled or fried chicken breast, with sweet and spicy pickles, leaf lettuce, tomato, zesty red sauce, and habanero jack cheese, on a sesame seed bun.
Chicken Smash Burger
$14.95Ground chicken smashed on the griddle and topped with lettuce, tomato, roasted red peppers, habanero jack cheese, and zesty red sauce, on a sesame seed bun.
Grilled Burger
$13.95Two beef patties grilled to order and topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, sweet and spicy pickles, and your choice of cheese, served on a sesame seed bun.
Pulled Pork Melt
$14.95House-pulled pork tossed in your choice of sauce, topped with pickled jalapeños, cheddar cheese, habanero jack cheese, and coleslaw, sandwiched between a thick-cut brioche bun.
Smoked Chicken Salad BLT
$13.95House-smoked chicken salad with crisp lettuce, tomato, peppered thick-cut bacon strips, and dill mayo, served on thick-cut brioche bread.
Stuffed Butter Burger
$14.95Our house burger, stuffed with garlic butter and Coop's Sharp White American Cheese, lettuce, tomato, and red onion, on a sesame seed bun. Served medium/medium well.
The Philly
$15.95South Philly baked hoagie stuffed with shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, and Coop's Sharp White American Cheese.
Sauce & Rub Choices
Alabama White BBQ
Black Garlic BBQ
Buffalo Lemon Pepper
(rub)
Carolina Gold
Hawaiian Teriyaki
(rub)
House Buffalo
Sweet & Spicy Thai
Shareables
Basket of Fries
$5.95Order them regular style or salt and vinegar seasoned.
Cheese Curds
$11.95Batter infused cheese curds, served with ranch.
Chicken Tenders
$12.95Potato chip-encrusted chicken strips, served with house fries and a choice of sauce.
Featured Soup
Ask your bartender or server.
Fried Pickles
$9.95House-battered sweet and spicy pickles.
Pretzel Bites
$10.95Deep fried and sprinkled with coarse salt, served with a side of aged cheddar cheese.
Smoked Wings
$14.95One pound of in-house smoked wings tossed with your choice of sauce.