Thief Wine Shop & Bar
Milwaukee, WI
400 N Water St, Milwaukee, WI, 53202-551347 itemsUpdated March 21, 2026
Structured menu data
Beer, N/A, Water, Soda
Single Beers - Out of State
From second cooler door from right
Single Beers - Wisconsin
From far right cooler door
Flights
Build Your Own Flight
Build your own flight by choosing any 2-ounce tastes - white, red, sparkling, rosé; whatever you'd like! Our servers will be happy to guide you through the list to help you create a flight perfectly matched to your tastes.
Food
Charcuterie
Cheese Plate
Red
Casas del Bosque 2023 Cabernet Sauvignon, Rapel Valley Chile
This cool-climate Cabernet Sauvignon is decidedly old-school in a very good way - earthy and herbal notes underpin dark red berries and a hint of spice. Smooth and deceptively rich.
Cave Robert & Michel 2023 Les Pouches Cabernet Franc, Saumur France
This delicious medium-bodied 100% Cabernet Franc from the Loire Valley has classic varietal notes of bright raspberry, violet, and a touch of graphite minerality. Well-balanced with a smooth and integrated finish.
Elouan 2023 Pinot Noir, Oregon
Juicy for an Oregon Pinot but still elegant, with low alcohol counterbalancing wild strawberry & cherry; a touch of loam on the finish.
Faustino 2023 Tempranillo, Rioja Spain
This is prototypical classically styled Rioja - vibrant cherry and wild strawberry fruit, medium-bodied, and a touch of dill and coconut notes from brief aging in American oak. Smooth, with a balanced and lingering finish.
Lapis Luna 2023 Zinfandel, North Coast California
The Lapis Luna is classic Zinfandel in that it's rich and full-bodied, but this wine has nice acidity and balance as well, with juicy red berry fruit, subtle grip, and a smooth finish.
Lulumi 2023 Pinot Noir, Pays d'Oc France
This delicious and elegant Pinot Noir from the South of France is subtle and nuanced, with bright Rainier cherry notes tinged with a hint of dusty earth.
Mad Fish 2019 Cabernet Sauvignon / Merlot, Western Australia
Australia is more than just Shiraz for reds! This Bordeaux-style blend of Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot from the continental climate of Western Australia is smooth and refined, with a mix of black currant and plum fruit flavors framed by integrated tannins and a plush mouthfeel.
Odile Delpon 2022 Malbec, Cahors France
This biodynamically grown Malbec is a clean and sophisticated example of Cahors, with grippy structure and earthiness alongside dark berry fruit.
Pasquale Pelissero 2024 Cascina Crosa Dolcetto d'Alba Italy
A beautiful Dolcetto - medium bodied, with dark cherry flavors, brisk acidity, a hint of anise, and undertones of minerality.
Rodriguez y Sanzo 2019 Nassos, Priorat Spain
This Grenache-based blend is big yet balanced, elegant yet intense, with great depth of flavor. A really nice value from this acclaimed region.
Sun & Air 2023 Cinsault, Western Cape South Africa
The Sun & Air is a great example of Cinsault - it's a lovely light- to medium-bodied varietal - red berry fruit, a hint of violets, and a refreshingly clean palate with balanced acidity.
Tenute La Padrona 2021 Montepulciano, Abruzzo Italy
Montepulciano (the grape, not to be confused with the Tuscan region) is one of the juicier Italian varietals, with bright red berry fruit and vibrant acidity – the La Padrona is an excellent representation.
Rosé
Berne 2024 Romance Rosé, Mediterranée France
Enjoy this subtle and balanced dry rosé - elegant and crisp, with a touch of floral notes to complement the raspberry and nuanced dried orange flavors.
Calvet 2024 Rosé, Rhône Valley France
This Rhône rosé is bright and refreshing with juicy raspberry, redcurrant, and a squeeze of citrus. Clean, crisp, and effortlessly drinkable with a balanced, lively finish.
Ercole 2024 Rosato, Piedmont Italy
This vibrant Rosato is a blend of classic Piedmont grape varieties of Barbera and Dolcetto. Fresh aromas of raspberry, ruby watermelon and citrus make this a great summer sipper with or without food.
Villa Wolf 2024 Rosé, Pfalz Germany
This dry rosé of Pinot Noir offers pretty strawberry and cherry fruit notes along with a deceptively rich mouthfeel - a perennial favorite!
Sparkling
Canella NV Bellini, Veneto Italy (250mL)
$12.75This classic Bellini (a mix of peach and sparkling wine) is light, sweet but not cloying, and eminently gulpable. A great Moscato alternative.
Domaine Ste. Michelle NV Brut Rosé, Columbia Valley Washington
This lovely off-dry pale rosé is made in the Champagne method, with exuberant red berry fruit and a smooth, rounded mouthfeel.
Gloria Ferrer NV Sonoma Brut, Sonoma California
The Gloria Ferrer is a fantastic methode Champenoise sparkler, with bright pear apple, and red berry fruit, excellent minerality, and a creamy mouthfeel from lees aging.
Los Monteros NV Brut, Cava Spain
The Los Monteros is a wonderfully dry Cava, with a juicy yet dry palate full of mouthwatering citrus, stone fruits, and white flowers complemented by yeasty notes from a year aging on lees.
Mimosa
$9.50Enjoy a great glass of delicious sparkling rosé wine mixed with a bit of premium orange juice - the perfect way to start your day!
Risata NV Moscato, Italy (187ml)
$11.50This classic Italian sparkling Moscato is everything you'd expect - sweet but not cloying, with lovely peach and floral notes. In a single-serve bottle; guaranteed fresh!
Risata Prosecco, Veneto Italy (187mL)
$9.50This crisp, fruit-driven Prosecco delivers bright apple and stone fruit flavors in a convenient single-serve bottle.
Scarpetta NV Frico Lambrusco, Italy (250mL)
$11.00Lambrusco? And from a can!?! Yes, and it's dangerously delicious. This is adult Kool-Aid - and you know you want to drink the Kool-Aid. Oooh yeahhhh!!!
Zaha NV Calcaire Brut Rosé, Mendoza Argentina
This methode Champenoise sparkling rosé is bright and crisp, with floral and red berry fruits on the nose balanced by rich stone fruit flavors on the palate. Bone dry, so the vibrant acidity shines through to create a long & lingering finish.
Sweet / Fortified
Chateau Laribotte 2022 Cuvée Sahuc Sauternes, Bordeaux France
$11.50A decadent libation from the world's most renowned sweet-wine region. Apricots, peach, a hint of citrus, honey, and undertones of truffle.
Maynard's NV Ruby Port, Douro Portugal
$9.00Textbook Port from a great producer – smooth dark fruit, licorice, rich & and lush, notes of spicy oak, packs a punch.
Maynard's NV Tawny Port, Douro Portugal
$9.00This Tawny really overdelivers for the price. Nutty caramel and hazelnuts, with a bit of butterscotch and toffee underneath.
Ramborn NV Meadow Orchard Ice Cider, Luxembourg
$11.50Ice wine? So delicious, but also so expensive, So, how about an ice cider?! Sweet, rich, and decadent, but with lovely freshness and acidity. Notes of ripe baked apples, fall spices, and a lingering, mouthcoating finish. An ideal winter dram.
White
Allendorf 2020 Save Water Drink Riesling Dry Riesling, Rheingau Germany
Not all German Riesling is sweet! We've got the Dr. Hermann on the list for a sweeter offering, but this Allendorf showcase what the grape can offer when made in a dry style, with zesty peach, lime, yellow plum, and racy acidity.
Aquamarine 2024 Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough New Zealand
Zippy and expressive, this lovely Sauvignon Blanc bursts with grapefruit, gooseberry, and fresh herbs. Clean, crisp, and classically Marlborough.
Bonny Doon 2024 Picpoul, Central Coast California
The grape Picpoul is grown primarily in southwestern France, but Bonny Doon - known for their enthusiasm for esoteric varietals - does a fantastic job with this California rendition! The name Picpoul translates loosely to "lip stinger", and with crisp and ripe Meyer lemon flavors and refreshing acidity, this delicious wine shows why.
d'Arenberg 2024 Viognier / Marsanne, McLaren Vale Australia
The "Hermit Crab" has abundant tropical fruit without being sweet, with a rich, full body, flavors of apricot and dried hay, and nuanced notes of spice.
Kumeu Village 2024 Chardonnay, Kumeu New Zealand
This outstanding Burgundian-style Chardonnay blends New World fruit with Old World restraint, balance, and nuance. A mix of stainless steel and barrel fermentation and aging creates complexity and savory notes while retaining acidity, complemented by a palate of creamy lemon curd, white peach, and a hint of baking spices. Simply lovely (as evidenced by the fact that Phil chose to serve it at his wedding this past year!).
Lucchetti 2024 Birbacció Verdicchio, Castelli di Jesi Italy
Good Verdicchio is all about minerality, complemented by stone fruit, savory notes and a smooth and mouthcoating texture on the palate. A new favorite for us!
Meyer-Fonné 2023 Edelzwicker, Alsace France
This delicious organically grown blend of Pinot Blanc, Sylvaner, Riesling, Gewurztraminer, and Muscat is floral but dry, with abundant stone and citrus fruit complemented by lychee and exotic spice notes.
Muga 2023 Blanco, Rioja Spain
This delicious organically farmed blend of 70% Viura, 20% Malvasia & 10% Garnacha Blanca features notes of ripe lime, white flowers, and a lovely mouthfeel. Barrel fermentation and lees aging provide a subtle spice note and wonderful texture.
Philipp Horn 2023 Kabinett Riesling, Rheinhessen Germany
The Philipp Horn is on the sweeter side for a Kabinett, with juicy stone fruit, citrus, and lovely white floral aromatics, all balanced by vibrant acidity so it's refreshing rather than cloying. Classic for the style, and a wonderful contrast to the bone-dry Allendorf Riesling on the list!
Pierpaolo Pecorari 2024 Pinot Grigio, Friuli Italy
A lot of Pinot Grigio can be insipid, but the Pecorari delivers the goods with this offering that features white peach, preserved lemon notes, and fall spices.
Storm Point 2024 Chenin Blanc, Swartland South Africa
This lovely Chenin Blanc has great texture and length, with flavors of dried honey and stone fruit along with a bit of spiciness and a hint of orange blossom.
Zolo 2024 Chardonnay, Mendoza Argentina
This exuberantly fruit-forward unoaked offering shows what Chardonnay tastes like without all the wood – pure pears, lemon & Golden Delicious apples.