Cheese Bread
$10.00includes a side of Marinara
Glass Nickel Pizza Co.
Menasha, WI
217 Washington St, Menasha, WI, 54952-3352170 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
Appetizers & Sides
Cheese Bread 10"
$10.00includes a side of Marinara
Cheese Bread 14"
$16.95includes a side of Marinara
Cheese Bread 16"
$19.95includes a side of Marinara
Coleslaw
$1.25Deep River Snacks Kettle Cooked Chips
$1.85Ask for selection
French Fries - Large
$6.75French Fries - Small
$3.50Fried Mac & Cheese Bites
$9.25Fried Mushrooms
$6.95Breaded and deep-fried mushrooms, served with a side of ranch
Garlic Bread Sticks
$7.95Includes a side of Marinara
Garlic Toast
$3.502 slices
Jalapeño Poppers with Cream Cheese
$9.25Includes a side of Marinara or Ranch
Mozzarella Sticks
$8.25Includes a side of Marinara
Nickel Nuggets
$7.95Includes a side of Marinara
Onion Rings
$5.95Side Salad
$5.75House mix, carrots, cucumbers, red cabbage and tomatoes
Spinach Cheese Bread
$10.00includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread - 10 Inch
$10.00Includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread - 10"
$10.00includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread - 14 Inch
$16.95Includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread - 14"
$16.95includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread - 16 Inch
$19.95Includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread - 16"
$19.95includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread 10"
$10.00includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread 14"
$16.95includes a side of Marinara
Spinach Cheese Bread 16"
$19.95includes a side of Marinara
Tater Tots - Large
$6.751 lb.
Tater Tots - Large (1 lb.)
$6.00Tater Tots - Small
$3.501/2 lb.
Tater Tots - Small (1/2 lb.)
$3.00Tater Tots - Small (1⁄2 lb.)
$3.50Toasted Cheese Ravioli
$8.25Includes a side of Marinara
White Cheddar Cheese Curds
$9.25Wings - Dozen (12)
$19.00Includes one dipping sauce of your choice
Wings - Half Dozen (6)
$9.50Includes one dipping sauce of your choice
Baked Pasta
Baked Chicken Alfredo
$11.45A house favorite! Creamy Alfredo Sauce & Oven Roasted Chicken on a bed of Cavatappi baked with mozzarella and parmesan. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Baked Mac & Cheese
$11.45Cavatappi Noodles, Creamy Alfredo Sauce, Monterey Jack & Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Garlic Salt & Pepper. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Baked Marinara
$11.45Cavatappi noodles topped with classic italian sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni and our parmesan parsley blend. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Mix 'N Match
$9.95Choose your favorite topping and sauce combination. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Build Your Own Pizza
10 Inch Cheese Pizza
$11.00Hand Tossed Dough, Classic Italian Sauce, and real Wisconsin House Blend Cheese
10 Inch Gluten Free Pizza
$14.50Hand Tossed Dough, Classic Italian Sauce, and real Wisconsin House Blend Cheese
14 Inch Cheese Pizza
$15.00Hand Tossed Dough, Classic Italian Sauce, and real Wisconsin House Blend Cheese
16 Inch Cheese Pizza
$17.00Hand Tossed Dough, Classic Italian Sauce, and real Wisconsin House Blend Cheese
Additional Topping - 10 Inch
$1.75Additional Topping - 14 Inch
$2.25Additional Topping - 16 Inch
$2.75Additional Toppings - 10 Inch
$1.75Additional Toppings - 14 Inch
$2.25Additional Toppings - 16 Inch
$2.75Cauliflower Crust
$3.5010" only
Gluten Free Crust
$3.5010" only
Gluten Free Crust Upcharge
$3.5010" only
Hand Tossed Thick or Cracker Crusts
$1.0010" 14" or 16"
Chicken
Chicken Strip Basket - Large (6)
$12.00Chicken Strips served with Fries and choice of sauce on the side
Chicken Strip Basket - Small (4)
$10.00Chicken Strips served with Fries and choice of sauce on the side
Desserts
Big Cookie
$3.00Ask about our current flavors
Cannoli Cake
A unique take on cannoli
Cheesecake or Cakes
$8.95Drinks
Beverages
Various drink options available
Pasta
Homemade Meat Lasagna
$12.50Layers of Noodles, Ricotta, Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Yellow Onions, Ground Beef & Italian Sausage. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Homemade Mediterranean Lasagna
$12.50Layers of Noodles baked with Tomato Sauce, Pesto, Fresh Spinach & Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Ricotta, Feta & Mozzarella. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Mac & Cheese
$12.50Cavatappi Noodles, Creamy Alfredo Sauce, Monterey Jack & Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Salt & Pepper. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Mix'n Match
$9.95Choose your favorite noodle and sauce combination. Served with a slice of Garlic Toast
Mix'n Match - Cavatappi and Marinara (vegan)
$9.95Served with a slice of Garlic Toast. Add a Side Salad for $3.75, or receive a discount on a BYO or Specialty salad!
Mix'n Match - Cheese Ravioli with Pesto (vegetarian)
$9.95Served with a slice of Garlic Toast. Add a Side Salad for $3.75, or receive a discount on a BYO or Specialty salad!
Mix'n Match - Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
$9.95Served with a slice of Garlic Toast. Add a Side Salad for $3.75, or receive a discount on a BYO or Specialty salad!
Pocket Pizzas
Calzone
$14.00A generously portioned pocket pizza filled with Ricotta, House Blend Cheese & your choice of 2 toppings. Served with a side of Classic Italian Sauce
Stromboli
$14.00A generously portioned pocket pizza filled with Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese & your choice of 2 toppings. Served with a side of Classic Italian Sauce
Specialty Pizza Sizes
Large 16 Inch Specialty Pizza
$25.50Medium 14 Inch Specialty Pizza
$22.50Small 10 Inch Gluten Free Specialty Pizza
$18.50Small 10 Inch Specialty Pizza
$15.00Specialty Pizzas
A Pesto Story
Pesto, House Blend Cheese, Chicken, Red Bell Pepper, Yellow Onion and Provolone
Bacon Cheeseburger
Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Beef, Bacon, Yellow Onions & Sharp Cheddar
Boaris Karloff
Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Capicola Ham with Banana Peppers, Tomatoes, Five Blend Cheese, Herbs & Spices on a base of Garlic & Olive Oil
Border-to-Border
Hot & Spicy Classic Sauce with House Blend Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Fresh Diced Tomatoes, Pineapple, and Hot Jalapeño Peppers
Border–to–border
Spicy Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Tomato, Pineapple, Canadian Bacon & Jalapeño
Breakfast Pie
Fresh Scrambled Eggs, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Breakfast Sausage, Bacon, Green Peppers, Yellow Onions & Tater Tots
Buffalo Nickel
Choose your sauce: Blue Cheese or Ranch. Topped with House Blend Cheese, Chicken Strips, Cilantro, Celery, Garlic, Sharp Cheddar & Frank's Red Hot®
Caraway Reuben Burger
1000 Island, Sauerkraut, Beef, House Blend Cheese, Sliced Pickles and Swiss
Cardiac Arrest
Classic Italian Sauce, extra House Blend Cheese, Bacon, Ham, Pepperoni & Sausage
Cheeseasaurus
No sauce, no problem. Make up this SAUCELESS Pizza anyway you want it. Choose up to four toppings and we'll finish it off with Extra House Blend Cheese and Spices
Chicken Alfredo
Creamy Alfredo Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Chicken, Spinach, Garlic & Mushroom
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Honey Mustard Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Chicken Strips, Ham & Swiss
Chicky Chicky Parm Parm
Alfredo Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Chicken Strips, Basil, Garlic topped off with Classic Sauce, Oregano & Parmesan Cheese
Couch Potato
Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Broccoli, Bacon, Tater Tots & Sharp Cheddar Cheese. Served with a side of Sour Cream
Deluxe
Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Peppers, Yellow Onions & Mushrooms
Fetalicious®
Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Red Onions, Spinach & Feta
Hawaii Pie-O
Classic Italian Sauce, Canadian Bacon, Yellow Onions, Pineapple, Red Peppers & Banana Peppers with crispy Bacon and House Blend Cheese
Mac Daddy
Alfredo Sauce, Special Five Cheese Blend & Cavatappi Noodles topped with our Crispy Parsley Shake
Margherita
Ricotta Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Tomatoes, Basil & Garlic
Mediterranean
Pesto, House Blend Cheese, Black Olives, Tomatoes & Feta
Nacho Mama
Nacho Cheese Sauce Topped with Taco Seasoned Beef, Black Olives, Green Onions, Tomatoes, Cilantro, Jalapenos, House Blend and Cheddar Cheeses. Finished with Crunchy Tortilla Chips!
Nacho Mamma
Nacho Cheese Sauce Topped with Taco Seasoned Beef, Black Olives, Green Onions, Tomatoes, Cilantro, Jalapenos, House Blend and Cheddar Cheeses. Finished with Crunchy Tortilla Chips!
Olympian
Extra virgin olive oil, balsamic glaze chicken, spinach, kalamata olives, red onions and oregano topped with feta and house-blend cheeses
Pollo Diablo
Spicy Ranch Sriracha Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Chicken, Bacon, Jalapeños & Red Onions
Portabella Lugosi
Classic Marinara, Portabella Mushrooms, Sausage, Red Onions, Basil, Garlic and Mozzarella topped with our Cheese & Herb Shake
Sacre Bleu
Classic Italian Sauce topped with House Blend Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Yellow Onions, Hard Salami, fresh diced Tomatoes and crumbled Bleu Cheese. Walnuts Available Upon Request
Sacré Blue
Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Canadian Bacon, Salami, Tomatoes, Yellow Onions, Bleu Cheese, & Walnuts upon request
Santa Fe
BBQ Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Chicken, Red Onions, Red Peppers & Cilantro
Superoni
Pepperoni, Boar's Head pepperoni, cup pepperoni, classic sauce, fresh basil & house blend cheese topped with cheese & herb shake
Thai Pie
Thai Peanut Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Chicken, Broccoli, Red Peppers, Yellow Onions & Cilantro
The Big Eddie
Classic Italian Sauce, topped with Meatballs, Green Peppers, Yellow Onions and our House Blend and Parmesan Cheeses
The Luau
Barbecue sauce on hand-tossed crust with Canadian bacon, ham, red onions, green peppers and pineapple, topped with our house-blend cheese
The Ranch
Ranch Dressing, House Blend Cheese, Bacon, Chicken, Red Onions & Tomatoes
Vegan Cheez Delight
BBQ Sauce, Vegan "Cheese", Broccoli, Pineapple, Red Pepper, Red Onion and Garlic
Vegan Pad Thai Pie
Peanut Sauce with Cilantro, Vegan Cheese, Tofu, Broccoli, Carrots, Red Peppers, & Yellow Onions
Vegg–out
Classic Italian Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Black Olives, Broccoli, Green Peppers, Red Onions, Mushrooms & Tomatoes
Specialty Salads
Acropolis Individual
$8.00Romaine, Feta, Black Olives, Red Onions, Red Peppers & Tomatoes
Acropolis Shareable
$12.00Romaine, Feta, Black Olives, Red Onions, Red Peppers & Tomatoes
Bac–n–bleu Individual
$9.00Spinach, Bacon, Bleu Cheese, Red Onions & Walnuts
Bac–n–bleu Shareable
$15.95Spinach, Bacon, Bleu Cheese, Red Onions & Walnuts
Caesar Salad Individual
$8.00Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons & add your choice of Chicken or Anchovies
Caesar Salad Shareable
$12.00Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons & add your choice of Chicken or Anchovies
Chef Individual
$10.50House Mix Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Sharp Cheddar, Carrots, Eggs & Tomatoes
Chef Shareable
$17.50House Mix Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Sharp Cheddar, Carrots, Eggs & Tomatoes
Club Individual
$10.50House Mix Lettuce, Bacon, Turkey, Sharp Cheddar & Tomatoes
Club Shareable
$17.50House Mix Lettuce, Bacon, Turkey, Sharp Cheddar & Tomatoes
Cobb Salad Individual
$10.50Romaine, Chicken, Bacon, Eggs, Sharp Cheddar, Tomatoes & Avocados
Cobb Salad Shareable
$17.50Romaine, Chicken, Bacon, Eggs, Sharp Cheddar, Tomatoes & Avocados
Garden Individual
$8.00House Mix Lettuce, Carrots, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, Red Cabbage, Red Onions & Tomatoes
Garden Shareable
$12.00House Mix Lettuce, Carrots, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, Red Cabbage, Red Onions & Tomatoes
Popeye Individual
$8.00Spinach, Eggs, Mushrooms & Red Onions
Popeye Shareable
$12.00Spinach, Eggs, Mushrooms & Red Onions
Subs
BLT
$8.95Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Mayo
Bomber
$8.95Meatballs, Marinara, Mozzarella & Parmesan Cheese
Carolina Club
$9.95Chicken, Bacon, Romaine, Swiss, Tomatoes, Thousand Island.
Chef's Club
$9.95Turkey, Ham, Swiss, Cheddar, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Mayo & French Dressing
Chicken Club
$8.95Chicken, Bacon, Romaine, Swiss, Tomatoes, Thousand Island
Chicken Parmesan
$8.95Chicken Strips, Marinara, Mozzarella & Parmesan Cheese
Cod Sub
$10.95Beer Battered Fish Fillets, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Tartar Sauce
Hot Veggie
$8.95Broccoli, Red Peppers, Black Olives, Mushrooms, Marinara & Mozzarella
Hot Wing Hoagie
$8.95Chicken Strips, Cheddar, Lettuce & Hot Buffalo Sauce
Italian
$8.95Capicola Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo & Italian Dressing
Italian (Hot or Cold)
$8.95Capicola Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo & Italian Dressing
Pepperoni Pile-On
$8.95Pepperoni, Mozzarella, Marinara & Banana Peppers
Smothered Chicken
$8.95Chicken, Spinach, Mushrooms, Red Onions, Mozzarella, Tomatoes & Mayo
Turkey Club
$10.95Turkey, Cheddar, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Mayo
Turkey Club (Hot or Cold)
$10.95Turkey, Cheddar, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Mayo
The Salad Bar
Acropolis
$8.00Romaine, Feta, Black Olives, Red Onions, Red Peppers & Tomatoes
Acropolis - Individual
$8.00Romaine, Feta, Black Olives, Red Onions, Red Peppers & Tomatoes
Acropolis - Shareable
$12.00Romaine, Feta, Black Olives, Red Onions, Red Peppers & Tomatoes
Additional Toppings - Individual
$1.50Additional Toppings - Shareable
$2.50Bac-N-Bleu
$9.00A taste sensation starting with fresh Spinach, crispy Bacon and Bleu Cheese crumbles with the perfect mix of Red Onions and Walnuts
Bac-N-Bleu - Individual
$9.00A taste sensation starting with fresh Spinach, crispy Bacon and Bleu Cheese crumbles with the perfect mix of Red Onions and Walnuts
Bac-N-Bleu - Shareable
$15.95A taste sensation starting with fresh Spinach, crispy Bacon and Bleu Cheese crumbles with the perfect mix of Red Onions and Walnuts
Build Your Own Salad - Individual
$8.00Your choice of greens plus 4 toppings. All salads come with croutons and your choice of dressing
Build Your Own Salad - Shareable
$12.00Your choice of greens plus 4 toppings. All salads come with croutons and your choice of dressing
Caesar Salad
$8.00Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons & add your choice of Chicken or Anchovies
Caesar Salad - Individual
$8.00Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons & add your choice of Chicken or Anchovies
Caesar Salad - Shareable
$12.00Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons & add your choice of Chicken or Anchovies
Chef
$10.50House Mix Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Sharp Cheddar, Carrots, Eggs & Tomatoes
Chef - Individual
$10.50House Mix Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Sharp Cheddar, Carrots, Eggs & Tomatoes
Chef - Shareable
$17.50House Mix Lettuce, Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Sharp Cheddar, Carrots, Eggs & Tomatoes
Club
$10.50House Mix Lettuce, Bacon, Turkey, Sharp Cheddar & Tomatoes
Club - Individual
$10.50House Mix Lettuce, Bacon, Turkey, Sharp Cheddar & Tomatoes
Club - Shareable
$17.50House Mix Lettuce, Bacon, Turkey, Sharp Cheddar & Tomatoes
Cobb Salad
$10.50Romaine, Chicken, Bacon, Eggs, Sharp Cheddar, Tomatoes & Avocados
Cobb Salad - Individual
$10.50Romaine, Chicken, Bacon, Eggs, Sharp Cheddar, Tomatoes & Avocados
Cobb Salad - Shareable
$17.50Romaine, Chicken, Bacon, Eggs, Sharp Cheddar, Tomatoes & Avocados
Garden
$8.00House Mix Lettuce, Carrots, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, Red Cabbage, Red Onions & Tomatoes
Garden - Individual
$8.00House Mix Lettuce, Carrots, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, Red Cabbage, Red Onions & Tomatoes
Garden - Shareable
$12.00House Mix Lettuce, Carrots, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, Red Cabbage, Red Onions & Tomatoes
Individual Salad
$8.00Your choice of greens plus 4 toppings. All salads come with croutons and your choice of dressing
Popeye
$812.00Fresh whole leaves of Baby Spinach topped with fresh sliced Wisconsin Mushrooms, diced sweet Red Onion and sliced Hard-Boiled Eggs. Served with your choice of Dressing and our Garlic Croutons.
Popeye - Individual
$8.00Fresh whole leaves of Baby Spinach topped with fresh sliced Wisconsin Mushrooms, diced sweet Red Onion and sliced Hard-Boiled Eggs. Served with your choice of Dressing and our Garlic Croutons
Popeye - Shareable
$12.00Fresh whole leaves of Baby Spinach topped with fresh sliced Wisconsin Mushrooms, diced sweet Red Onion and sliced Hard-Boiled Eggs. Served with your choice of Dressing and our Garlic Croutons
Shareable Salad
$12.00Your choice of greens plus 4 toppings. All salads come with croutons and your choice of dressing