Old City Barbeque
Williamsburg, VA
700 York St, Williamsburg, VA 23185, USA80 itemsUpdated March 11, 2026
Structured menu data
A La Carte Smoked Meats
1/4 lb Pulled Pork
$4.991/4 lb Smoked Brisket
$10.991/4lb Seared Pork Belly
$6.49St. Louis Ribs (two bone section)
$7.49Dessert
Banana Pudding
$9.99Caramelized bananas, crumble top
Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan Pie
$8.49served w/ whipped cream
Mrs. Geddy's Chocolate Pie
$7.99served w/ whipped cream
Roasted Peanut Bread Pudding
$9.49Served w/ whipped cream & bourbon salted caramel
Kid's Menu
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Tenders
$8.99Chopped Brisket Slider
$9.99Corn Dog Bites
$8.49Kids "Dirt" Dessert
$3.00Chocolate pudding, Oreo crumble, gummi worm
Kids Garlic Queso Mac N' Cheese
$10.49Kids Poblano Mac N' Cheese
$10.99Pulled Chicken Slider
$7.99Pulled Pork Slider
$7.49Platters
Four Smoked Meats
$28.99Fried Flounder Platter
$22.99Fried flounder, citrus dill aioli OR pickled remoulade, corn hushpuppies w/ honey butter. choice of two sides
Smoked Meat Sampler
$30.99Three Smoked Meats
$26.99Two Smoked Meats
$24.99Sandwiches
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Thigh
$14.49Pimento cheese, bread & butter pickles, or buffalo & bleu cheese
Crab Cake Sandwich
$20.99Pan seared w/ pickled fresno remoulade, seasoned tomato, iceberg lettuce, brioche potato roll
Cubano
$19.99smoked mojo pork, applewood honey ham, swiss cheese, garlic & dill pickles, roasted garlic dijonnaise, cuban loaf
Fried Flounder Sandwich
$15.99Fried flounder, citrus dill aioli, seasoned tomato, iceberg lettuce, brioche potato roll
Fried Oyster Po'boy
$20.99Fried VA oysters, pickled fresno remoulade, seasoned tomato, iceberg lettuce, sub roll
Fried Shrimp Po'Boy
$19.99Fried jumbo shrimp, pickled fresno remoulade, seasoned tomato, iceberg lettuce, sub roll
Hot Brown
$17.99Open faced on sourdough w/ smoked turkey, sage mornay sauce, grilled tomato, bacon, green onion
Portobello Sandwich
$12.99Swiss cheese, chimichurri aioli, pickled red onion, arugula, brioche potato roll
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
$14.99House coleslaw, brioche potato roll
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$13.99House coleslaw, pickled red onions, brioche potato roll
Seared Pork Belly BLT
$17.49Seared Pork Belly, tomatoes, bibb lettuce, basil garlic aioli, toasted sourdough.
Smoked Brisket Dip
$21.99Smoked brisket, caramelized onions, swiss cheese, horseradish aioli, baguette, brisket au jus
Smoked Brisket Sandwich
$20.99Tobacco onions, soy pickled jalapeño, sticky patches bbq sauce
The "Big Hal"
$22.99A larger than life sandwich for a larger than life man. Sliced Beef Brisket, Pulled Pork BBQ, Seared Pork Belly, Bread & Butter Pickles, Pickled Red Onions, Soy Pickled Jalapenos, House Coleslaw, Sticky Patches BBQ sauce Brioche Bun
Sauces
Old City Vinegar
Vinegar, spices
Sticky Patches
VBC elbow patches, molasses, spices
Tidewater
Tomato, mustard, vinegar, spices
Sides
Applesauce
Coleslaw
Collard Greens (+1.50 w/ entrée)
Cornbread w/ Honey Butter
$2.99Price per slice
French Fries
Half Arugula (+5.69 w/ entrée)
$8.99Half salad, apple, pickled fennel, cambozola blue cheese, candied peanuts, mustard apple cider vinaigrette
Half Romaine (+3.30 w/ entrée)
$6.49Half salad, pickled red onions, cornbread croutons, cotija cheese, roasted garlic dressing
Poblano Mac N' Cheese (+1.50 w/ entrée)
Smoked Stout Beans
Sweet Potato Fries (+1.50 w/ entrée)
Smoked Meats
Pork Belly Bite Platter
$22.99Pulled Chicken Platter
$18.99Pulled Pork Platter
$17.99Seared Pork Belly Platter
$21.99Smoked Brisket Platter
$26.99Snacks
Cheese Fries
$15.99Cheddar & American, pickled jalapeno, pickled red onions, scallion, add bacon (+4.49), pulled pork (+4.99), chicken tenders (+5.99), pulled chicken (+5.99), portobello (+4.09), fried pork belly (+6.59), chopped brisket (+9.99), green chili brisket (+7.99), pork & brisket chili (+7.99)
Fried Brussels Sprouts
$11.99Housemade cilantro lime vinaigrette, cotija cheese, candied peanuts
Fried Buffalo Shrimp
$13.99Six jumbo shrimp, O.C buffalo sauce, green onions. choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing
Fried Green Tomatoes
$13.49Cornmeal breaded green tomatoes, bacon & roasted red onion jam, pimento cheese, sorghum, scallions
Fried Pork Belly Bites
$16.49Sweet & spicy sauce, Virginia peanuts, scallions
Fried Virginia Oysters
$15.99Fresno pepper remoulade, pickled fennel & pepper salad, scallions
Pickle Plate
$11.99Assorted seasonal pickled items
Smoked Pimento Cheese
$13.99Ritz crackers, shaved Edward's Country Ham, O.C. hot sauce, bread & butter pickles
x12 Smoked & Fried Wings
$23.9912 wings, bleu cheese or ranch, celery & sauce: tidewater, sticky patches, buffalo, sweet & spicy, bourbon honey mustard, dry rub, naked
x6 Smoked & Fried Wings
$12.496 wings, bleu cheese or ranch, celery & sauce: tidewater, sticky patches, buffalo, sweet & spicy, bourbon honey mustard, dry rub, naked
Soups / Salads
add-ons w/ salads
Arugula Salad
arugula, apple, pickled fennel, crumbled bleu cheese, candied peanuts, mustard apple cider vinaigrette
Brunswick Stew
$9.99Smoked pork & chicken, okra, onions, limas, sweet corn, tomatoes, potatoes, served w/ cornbread and honey butter
Romaine Salad
romaine, pickled red onions, cornbread croutons, cotija cheese, roasted garlic dressing
Smoked Brisket & Pork Chili
$14.99Smoked beef brisket, ground pork, great northern beans, smoked cheddar, crème fraiche, scallions, served with cornbread and honey butter
Smoked Turkey Pot Pie
$12.99Smoked turkey, potatoes, peas, carrots, onions, garlic, herbs, puff pastry
St. Louis Ribs
12 Ribs
$41.994 Ribs
$21.996 Ribs
$26.99Tacos
Chopped Smoked Brisket Tacos
$20.99Soy pickled jalapeno, house coleslaw
Fried Pork Belly Tacos
$18.49Sweet & Spicy sauce, kimchi slaw, cilantro
Green Chili Brisket
$19.99jalapeno cilantro slaw, cotija cheese, crema, pickled red onions
Pulled Chicken Tacos
$16.99Cilantro Jalapeno Slaw, Cotija Cheese
Pulled Pork Tacos
$15.99House Coleslaw, Smoked Bean Puree, Bread & Butter Pickles
Shrimp Tacos
Blackened or fried w/ salsa roja, shredded napa cabbage, diced tomato, green onions, flour tortillas. cilantro lime crema or chipotle honey crema
Taco Sampler
$20.99Pick three