Sexton's Pizza
Hilliard, OH
5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH, 4302639 itemsUpdated May 25, 2026
Structured menu data
12" Cauliflower Crust
Specialty 12” Cauliflower
$18.00Build Your Own Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
$20.00NY style = 16 inch, 8 large slices (triangle) Motown= deep dish, 8 slices (square)
CupCakes
Chocolate
$5.00Chocolate Peanut Butter
$5.00Cookies n Creme
$5.00Strawberry
$5.00Vanilla
$5.00Extra Sauces
BBQ
$1.00GALAXY pickle Jar
$9.99Garlic Sauce
$1.25Homemade Ranch
$1.25Italian Dressing
$1.25Jar of Sexton's Ranch
$9.00Nashville Hot
$1.00Pizza Sauce
$1.25Side Of Mikes Hot
$2.00Specialty Pizza
614
$25.00Pepperoni, bacon, banana peppers
Bee Bee Q
$25.00Garlic Sauce Base, Fried Chicken, Onion, with a Hot Honey BBQ and Ranch Drizzle.
Cheese Pizza
$20.00yep: 50% poolish crust, red sauce, whole milk mozzarella
Dairy Air
$25.00Ezzo pepperoni, cream cheese, Mike's hot honey
East Village Pepperoni
$25.00fresh sliced mozz, Ezzo pepperoni, fresh basil OWNER FAVORITE
Girl Like You
$25.00Garlic base, fried chicken, bacon, ranch drizzle
Hakuna Ricotta
$25.00Ezzo sausage crumble, fresh whipped ricotta, whole milk mozz, fresh mozz, fresh basil
I'M VEGAN
$25.00Follow Your Heart Mozzarella Cheese, Beyond Vegan Sausage Crumble, Tomato, Garlic Oil , Fresh Basil
In QUESO Emergency
$25.00Queso, Candied Bacon, Jalapenos, Cayenne Pepper and Fried Chicken
Kevin Bacon
$25.00Candied bacon and pepperoni.
Margherita Pizza
$22.00Fresh sliced mozzarella, a dash of olive oil, sea salt and fresh basil
MIKE!
$25.007/11 ground tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, cup and burn pepperoni, mikes hot honey
Nashville Hot Chic
$25.00Garlic base, fried chicken, pickles, Nashville hot & ranch drizzle
never alone with CHEEZUS
$25.00Garlic base, whole milk mozzarella, red sauce drizzle, fresh mozzarella, cream cheese, fresh basil
Paisano Pepper Pizza
$25.00Red Sauce, shredded mozz, Ezzo sausage crumble, NEW! Paisano Peppers
Pepperoni Pizza
$23.50yes sir: 50% poolish crust, red sauce, whole milk mozzarella, EZZO cup and burn pepperoni
Pesto Pie
$25.00Fresh mozz, pepperoni, pesto drizzle, fresh basil
Sausage Great Guy
$25.00Smokey Robinson
$25.00Ezzo cup and burn pepperoni, fresh jalapeño, whole milk mozzarella, parmesan cheese, mikes hot honey
Tomato Pie
$12.007/11 tomatoes, parmesan cheese, Italian seasoning
What The Dilly Yo!?
$24.00Garlic base, cheese, pickles, parmesan cheese, Italian seasoning
White Pizza
$22.00garlic base, whole milk mozz, fresh sliced mozz, fresh whipped ricotta, parmesan