Mitchell's Ice Cream

Shaker Heights, OH

3400 Tuttle Rd, Shaker Heights, OH, 44122-1864
37 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data

Bottled Water

$2.00

Boylan Black Cherry

$2.50

Boylan Cane Cola

$2.50

Boylan Creme Soda

$2.50

Boylan Ginger Ale

$2.50

Boylan Orange

$2.50

Boylan Root Beer

$2.50

Lime Seltzer

$2.50

Raspberry Seltzer

$2.50

Brownies

$2.75

Chocolate Cake

$45.00

9" round chocolate cake topped with a layer of ice cream, topped with fudge, and iced with fresh whipped cream. Serves 10–12

Junior

$4.25

Pint

$7.75

Quart

$14.50

Taster's Duo

$5.25

Taster's Trio

$7.25

Waffle Cone

$1.35

Chocolate Graham Crust Pie

$42.00

9" round chocolate graham crust filled with ice cream, topped with fudge, and iced with fresh whipped cream. Serves 8–10

Any Ice Cream Flavor Malt

$7.65

Any Ice Cream Flavor Shake

$7.35

Includes fresh whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

Chocolate Malt

$7.65

Chocolate Shake

$7.35

Includes fresh whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

Peanut Butter Malt

$7.65

Peanut Butter Shake

$7.35

Includes fresh whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

Root Beer Float

$7.35

Bottle of Boylan Root Beer poured over two scoops of Vanilla Bean ice cream, topped with fresh whipped cream and a Bordeaux cherry.

Strawberry Malt

$7.65

Strawberry Shake

$7.35

Includes fresh whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

Vanilla Bean Malt

$7.65

Vanilla Bean Shake

$7.35

Includes fresh whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

Cleveland Brownie Mocha

$7.25

Dark Roast Coffee ice cream, hot fudge, warm brownie, chocolate shavings, fresh whipped cream, and a Bordeaux cherry on top.

Create Your Favorite Sundae - Large

$7.95

Select an ice cream flavor of your choice and add up to three toppings, fresh whipped cream and a Bordeaux cherry on top.

Create Your Favorite Sundae - Medium

$7.25

Select an ice cream flavor of your choice and add up to three toppings, fresh whipped cream and a Bordeaux cherry on top.

Create Your Favorite Sundae - Small

$6.75

Select an ice cream flavor of your choice and add up to three toppings, fresh whipped cream and a Bordeaux cherry on top.

Peanut Butter Fudge

$7.25

Your choice of ice cream, peanut butter sauce and hot fudge, chocolate shavings, fresh whipped cream, and a Bordeaux cherry on top.

Strawberry Sundae

$8.25

Warm brownie, Vanilla Bean ice cream, chocolate shavings, hot fudge, pecans, fresh whipped cream, and a Bordeaux cherry on top.

Tin Roof

$7.25

Vanilla Bean ice cream, hot fudge, salted Spanish peanuts, fresh whipped cream, and a Bordeaux cherry on top.

Turtle Sundae

$7.25

Vanilla Bean ice cream, hot fudge and caramel, pecans, fresh whipped cream, and a Bordeaux cherry on top.