Pumpkin Ale
Pumpkin cake, pumpkin ale filling, topped with cream cheese frosting and candied pumpkin seeds
Kittie's Cakes
Columbus, OH
495 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH, 43215-570131 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
Fall Flavors
Rum Kissed Cranberry
Orange cake mixed with rum soaked cranberries, ginger buttercream, garnished with a sugar coated rum soaked cranberry
Thanksgiving Stout
Chocolate stout cake, topped with espresso buttercream & a chocolate covered espresso bean & graham cracker
Filled Sheet Cakes
Half Sheet
$140.00Quarter sheet
$80.00Layer Cakes
4-inch, 2 layers
$24.005-inch 2 layer
$25.007-inch 2 layer
$60.007-inch, 3 layers
$80.00Mini Cupcakes
Mini Cupcakes
$2.50Minimum of 6 mini cupcakes/flavor
Signature Flavors
Candy Bar
Pretzel crust, chocolate cake, salted caramel ganache center, topped with vanilla malt buttercream and crushed pretzels
Carrot
Spiced carrot cake with cream cheese frosting & crushed candy pecans
Classic Buckeye
Chocolate cake with a peanut butter filling, topped with dark chocolate buttercream & peanut butter
Classic White
White cake with vanilla buttercream, simple and classic
Coconut Cream
Coconut cake filled with coconut pudding topped with marshmallow icing & shredded coconut
Coffee Toffee Crunch
Heath pieces in yellow butter cake, topped with coffee pastry cream, topped with salted caramel buttercream
Cookies & Cream
An Oreo baked inside white cake, filled with crushed Oreo buttercream
German Chocolate
Chocolate cake topped with toasted coconut, almonds and pecans
Old Fashioned
Yellow butter cake with vanilla pastry cream center, topped with milk chocolate buttercream & sprinkles
Ooey Gooey Chocolate
Chocolate cake filled with chocolate ganache topped with dark chocolate buttercream & chocolate sprinkles
S'More
Graham cracker crust, chocolate cake, topped with toasted marshmallow icing
White Lavender
White cake made with Ohio lavender topped with vanilla buttercream and garnished with lavender sugar
Small Cake
3-inch Small Cake
$8.00Spring Flavors
Lemon Meringue
Graham Cracker Crust, lemon cake, filled with lemon curd, topped with toasted marshmallow icing
Summer Flavors
Orange Creamsicle
A callback to our favorite summertime popsicle, orange cake filled with orange cream filling, topped with vanilla buttercream
Strawberries & Cream
Oven-roasted strawberries in buttermilk cake, topped with cream cheese frosting
Two-Tier Cake
Two-Tier Cake
$80.005-inch base tier with 7-inch top tier
Winter Flavors
Aunt Patty Throwback
Sweet potato cake topped with toasted marshmallow icing & pecan crumble garnish
Jack Frost
Eggnog cake, eggnog pudding filling, topped with nutmeg garnish (based on eggnog availability)
Mocha
Chocolate cake filled with chocolate ganache, topped with espresso buttercream
Peppermint
Chocolate cake filled with chocolate ganache, topped with peppermint buttercream & crushed peppermint candy