Calzone
$12.95Turnover-shaped pizza dough filled with ricotta, romano, & mozzarella, and a side of sauce
Captain Tony's Pizza
Cleveland, OH
13202 Shaker Sq, Cleveland, OH, 44120-2315133 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
CALZONES
Calzone Fillings
$1.25Sicilian Style Calzone
$12.95Turnover-shaped pizza dough filled with ricotta, romano, & mozzarella, and a side of sauce
CHICKEN
Baked & Breaded Tenders
$14.95½ lb. specially breaded chicken tenders
Baked & Breaded Tenders
$14.95½ lb. specially breaded chicken tenders
Jumbo or Boneless Wings
$14.95Jumbo or Boneless Wings
$14.95CHICKEN SAUCES
Buffalo Style (House Specialty)
Cajun
Garlic Butter
Sweet & Sour
COMBOS
Large Chicago Style Party Pack
$52.9932 Pc. Sheet Cheese Pizza (18"x26"), 20 Jumbo Wings, & 2 Liter Soda
Large Chicago Style Party Pack Special
$52.9932 Pc. Sheet Cheese Pizza (18"x26"), with Xtra Mozzarella + 1 FREE Topping, 20 Jumbo Wings, & 2 Liter Soda
Pizza & Wing Combo
$28.99Large Cheese Pizza + 10 Jumbo Wings
Pizza & Wing Combo
$28.99Large Cheese Pizza + 10 Jumbo Wings
XL Pizza & Wing Combo
$31.99XL Large Cheese Pizza + 10 Jumbo Wings
XL Pizza & Wing Combo
$31.99XL Large Cheese Pizza + 10 Jumbo Wings
DELI STYLE SUBS
Captain's Supreme
A combination of 3 meats w/lettuce, tomato, & dressing
Captain's Supreme
A combination of 3 meats w/lettuce, tomato, & dressing
Chicken Breast Sub
Choice of tomato sauce w/mozzarella, cajun spices, BBQ or Buffalo sauce
Chicken Breast Sub
Choice of tomato sauce w/mozzarella, cajun spices, BBQ or Buffalo sauce
Eggplant Parm Sub
Tender, breaded slices of eggplant w/sauce & mozzarella
Eggplant Parm Sub
Tender, breaded slices of eggplant w/sauce & mozzarella
Ham or Turkey Breast
Ham or Turkey Breast
Meatball Sub
Hot, spicy Italian meatball w/sauce & mozzarella
Meatball Sub
Hot, spicy Italian meatball w/sauce & mozzarella
Pizza Sub
$14.50Our special pizza sauce, mozzarella, & 1 topping
Pizza Sub
$14.50Our special pizza sauce, mozzarella, & 1 topping
Sausage Sub
Fresh ground sausage w/mozzarella cheese
Sausage Sub
Fresh ground sausage w/mozzarella cheese
Steak Sub
Tender shaved ribeye steak w/mozzarella. Choice of cajun spices, BBQ, or Buffalo sauce
Steak Sub
Tender shaved ribeye steak w/mozzarella. Choice of cajun spices, BBQ, or Buffalo sauce
PIZZA
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Extra Large
$19.4916 Slices
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Extra Large
$19.4916 Slices
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Large
$16.4910 Slices
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Large
$16.4910 Slices
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Medium
$15.498 Slices
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Medium
$15.498 Slices
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Small
$9.994 Slices
Authentic NY Crust Pizza - Small
$9.994 Slices
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza - Large
$22.498 Slices
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza - Large
$22.498 Slices
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza - Medium
$15.996 Slices
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza - Medium
$15.996 Slices
Garlic Pizza
$9.99White pizza with chopped garlic, oil, grated romano, & mozzarella
Garlic Pizza
$15.49White pizza with chopped garlic, oil, grated romano, & mozzarella
GF or Cauliflower Crust Stuffed Pizza
$15.49On gluten-free or cauliflower crust with mozzarella. 10" Thin Crust
GF or Cauliflower Crust Stuffed Pizza - 10" Thin Crust
$15.49On gluten-free or cauliflower crust with mozzarella
GF or Cauliflower Crust Stuffed Pizza - Large
$22.498 Slices
GF or Cauliflower Crust Stuffed Pizza - Medium
$15.996 Slices
Large Cheese Pizza
$15.49NY Style Thin Crust
Large Cheese Pizza
$15.49NY Style Thin Crust
Medium NY Style Cheese Pizza
$8.99NY Style Thin Crust
Medium NY Style Cheese Pizza
$8.99NY Style Thin Crust
NY Super Slice - Double Cheese or Pepperoni
$5.95Large
NY Super Slice - Double Cheese or Pepperoni
$5.95Pan Pizza - Large
$16.4910 Slices
Pan Pizza - Large
$16.4910 Slices
Pan Pizza - Medium
$15.498 Slices
Pan Pizza - Medium
$15.498 Slices
Pan Pizza - Small
$9.994 Slices
Pan Pizza - Small
$9.994 Slices
Party Sheet Pizza
$28.4518"x26" - 32 Slices
Party Sheet Pizza
$28.4518"x26" - 32 Slices
Stuffed Pizza
$15.49White pizza with double crust filled with mozzarella & served with zesty Italian sauce on the side. 10" Thin Crust
Stuffed Pizza - Large
$22.498 Slices
Stuffed Pizza - Large
$22.49White pizza with double crust filled with mozzarella & served with zesty Italian sauce on the side. 8 Slices
Stuffed Pizza - Medium
$15.99White pizza with double crust filled with mozzarella & served with zesty Italian sauce on the side. 6 Slices
Stuffed Pizza - Medium
$15.996 Slices
Take & Bake Pizza - Large
$15.49Take & Bake Pizza - Large
$15.49Made to order for you to bake at home
The Big Tony
$11.9516" XL NY Style Thin Crust Cheese Pizza + 1 FREE Topping
The Big Tony
$11.9516" XL NY Style Thin Crust Cheese Pizza + 1 FREE Topping
PIZZA TOPPINGS
Anchovies
Artichokes
Bacon
Black Olives
Broccoli
Cheddar Cheese
Chicken
Cup'n'Char Pepperoni
Eggplant
Garlic
Green Olives
Green Peppers
Ham
Hot Peppers
Meatballs
Mushrooms
Onions
Pepperoni
Pineapple
Provolone Cheese
Ricotta Cheese
Salami
Sausage
Sliced Tomatoes
Spinach
Sweet Red Peppers
SALADS & SIDES
Garden Salad
Garden Salad
SAUCES
Buffalo Style
House Specialty
Cajun
Garlic Butter
Sweet & Sour
SPECIALTY ITEMS
Sin Stix or Brownie Chunks
$13.99Strips of fresh dough covered w/butter, sugar, cinnamon & a drizzle of white chocolate w/a side of dipping sauce