Tommy's Pizza

New York, NY

915 Cross Bay Blvd, New York, NY, 11693-1125
75 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data

Appetizer Basket

$12.50

Choose any 3 of the following: Mushrooms, Cauliflower, Zucchini, Cheeseballs, Broccoli Bacon & Cheese Bites, Jalapeno Poppers

Broccoli Bites

$5.00

Chopped broccoli mixed with cheddar cheese and bacon, breaded and deep fried served with ranch dipping sauce

Cauliflower / Zucchini / Mushroom

$4.75

Choice of one battered and deep fried served with ranch dipping sauce

Cauliflower / Zucchini / Mushrooms

$4.75

Choice of one battered and deep fried served with ranch dipping sauce

Cheeseballs

$5.00

Deep fried cheddar cheese balls served with ranch dipping sauce

French Fries - Basket

$6.25

French Fries - Single Serving

$4.00

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$3.50

Garlic Bread with Cheese - Basket

$5.25

Garlic Bread with Cheese - Large

$4.25

Garlic Bread with Cheese - Single

$3.50

Garlic Bread without Cheese

$3.00

Garlic Bread without Cheese - Basket

$4.25

Garlic Bread without Cheese - Large

$5.25

Garlic Bread without Cheese - Single

$3.00

Homemade Meatball

$2.00

Jalapeno Poppers

$5.00

Breaded jalapeno stuffed with cream cheese served with spaghetti dipping sauce

Onion Rings - Basket

$6.25

Onion Rings - Single Serving

$4.00

2-Liters

$3.50

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt Dew, Dr. Pepper, Mug Root Beer, Starry. Carryout Only

20 oz Drinks

$2.50

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Starry, Starry Zero, Mt. Dew, Diet Mt Dew, Dr Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper, Cherry Pepsi

Beer On Tap

Dine In Only. Ask Server for Current Selection

Bottled Water - 20 oz

$2.00

Bottled Water - 20 oz.

$2.00

Fountain Drinks

$2.75

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt Dew, Dr. Pepper, Mug Root Beer, Starry, Pink Lemonade, Iced Tea

Hard Seltzer

Black Cherry, Lime, Mango

Wine

Dine In Only. Ask Server for Current Selection

Cheese Cake

$3.50

Cheese Cake - with Toppings

$4.40

Cheese Cake - Cookies and Cream

$3.50

Topping add $.90

Cheese Cake - Plain

$3.50

Topping add $.90

Chicken Basket

$10.50

Deep fried chicken fingers with a side of fries served with barbecue sauce. Served with hard rolls or 1/2 garlic bread and choice of side salad, french fries or onion rings

Chicken Basket - Child Size

$6.25

Deep fried chicken fingers with a side of fries served with barbecue sauce

Chicken Parmesan

$14.25

Deep fried chicken breast topped with melted provolone cheese and sauce served over spaghetti. Served with hard rolls or 1/2 garlic bread and choice of side salad, french fries or onion rings

Chicken Strip Dinner

$13.25

Chicken strips served with french fries or onion rings. Served with hard rolls or 1/2 garlic bread and choice of side salad, french fries or onion rings

Family Spaghetti

$30.00

Four servings of spaghetti with sauce, eight meatballs, large side salad and a garlic bread. Carryout Only

Spaghetti

$12.25

Homestyle egg noodle with sauce and two meatballs. Served with hard rolls or 1/2 garlic bread and choice of side salad, french fries or onion rings

Spaghetti - A-La-Carte

$8.50

Homestyle egg noodle with sauce and two meatballs (No Salad or Rolls)

Spaghetti - Child's Portion

$8.75

Homestyle egg noodle with sauce and two meatballs

All-the-Way Pizza

Pepperoni, Mushroom, Sausage, Green Pepper and Onion

Cheese Pizza - Large

$17.50

15 inch

Cheese Pizza - Large (15")

$17.50

Cheese Pizza - Medium

$15.50

13 inch

Cheese Pizza - Medium (13")

$15.50

Cheese Pizza - Mini

$8.50

8 inch

Cheese Pizza - Mini (8")

$8.50

Cheese Pizza - Small

$13.50

11 inch

Cheese Pizza - Small (11")

$13.50

Extra Cheese - Large

$2.90

Extra Cheese - Medium

$2.60

Extra Cheese - Mini

$1.60

Extra Cheese - Small

$2.30

Protein Toppings - Large

$2.50

Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Salami, Meatball, Bacon, Beef, Anchovy

Protein Toppings - Medium

$2.20

Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Salami, Meatball, Bacon, Beef, Anchovy

Protein Toppings - Mini

$1.30

Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Salami, Meatball, Bacon, Beef, Anchovy

Protein Toppings - Small

$1.90

Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Salami, Meatball, Bacon, Beef, Anchovy

Regular Toppings - Large

$2.00

Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Banana Pepper, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Green Olive, Pineapple, Tomato, Extra Sauce

Regular Toppings - Medium

$1.70

Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Banana Pepper, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Green Olive, Pineapple, Tomato, Extra Sauce

Regular Toppings - Mini

$1.00

Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Banana Pepper, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Green Olive, Pineapple, Tomato, Extra Sauce

Regular Toppings - Small

$1.40

Mushroom, Green Pepper, Onion, Banana Pepper, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Green Olive, Pineapple, Tomato, Extra Sauce

Vegetarian Pizza

Mushroom, Green Pepper and Onion

Chef Salad

$11.75

Lettuce mix, tomato, cucumber, green pepper, black olive, cucumber, onion, hot pepper, mushroom, provolone cheese and choice of traditional chef meat (pepperoni, salami, ham), turkey or chicken fingers

Party Salad

$55.00

Dine in Only

Toss Salad - Bucket

$17.25

Lettuce mix, tomato, cucumber, green pepper and provolone cheese

Toss Salad - Large

$8.25

Lettuce mix, tomato, cucumber, green pepper and provolone cheese

Toss Salad - Small

$5.25

Lettuce mix, tomato, cucumber, green pepper and provolone cheese

Cheese Sub

$7.50

Melted provolone cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, hot banana pepper and Italian dressing

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

$7.50

Deep fried chicken breast on a toasted kaiser roll with melted provolone cheese topped with spaghetti sauce

Ham & Cheese Sub

$8.50

Sliced ham and provolone cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and Italian dressing

Meatball Sub

$8.75

Homemade meatballs, spaghetti sauce and provolone cheese

Regular Italian Sub

$8.50

Ham, salami, pepperoni and provolone cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, banana pepper and Italian dressing. Double Meat add $1.50, Extra Cheese/Dressing add $.85, Extra Topping add $.70

Sausage Sandwich

$7.50

Sausage patty on a toasted kaiser roll with melted provolone cheese grilled and topped with spaghetti sauce

Tommy's Steak Sandwich

$7.50

8 ounce ground beef patty on a toasted kaiser roll with melted provolone topped with red sauce cooked with mushroom, sausage, and onion

Turkey Sub

$8.50

Sliced turkey and provolone cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, banana pepper and Italian Dressing

Vegetarian Sub

$8.50

Mushroom, green pepper, onion and provolone cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, banana pepper and Italian dressing