The Flaming Fish
Buffalo, NY
535 Main St, Buffalo, NY, 14203-1735125 itemsUpdated March 22, 2026
Structured menu data
A LA CARTE
5 PC. SHRIMP
$10.00CATFISH FILLET
$10.00CHICKEN FILLET
$8.00CRAB CAKE
$12.00HADDOCK FILLET
$15.00JALAPENO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFIN
$1.00LOBSTER TAIL
$14.00PERCH FILLET
$7.00TILAPIA FILLET
$8.00TOASTED GARLIC BREAD
$1.00WHITING FILLET
$7.00CUP & LEAF
CAESAR SALAD
$7.00Crisp romaine lettuce, grated parmesan cheese, and crunchy garlic croutons, served with a side of creamy Caesar dressing.
CLAM CHOWDER
GUMBO
Featuring tender chicken, succulent shrimp, and smoked sausage in a slow cooked rich broth.
HOUSE SALAD
$6.00A blend of mixed greens, juicy tomatoes, crisp carrots, tangy banana peppers, shredded cheese, and red onions topped with crunchy croutons. Served with dressing of choice.
STRAWBERRY SALAD
$8.00DESSERTS
CARROT CAKE
$7.00CHOCOLATE FUDGE CAKE
$10.00COCOA LOCO CAKE
$13.00LEMON CREME CAKE
$6.00PEACH COBBLER BREAD PUDDING
$12.00PEACH COBBLER POUND CAKE
$8.00STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
$10.00SWEET POTATO PIE
$5.00WARM PEACH COBBLER
$9.00FAMILY MEALS
COMBO TACKLE BOX
$76.503 PIECES OF PROTEIN OF CHOICE ( WHITING, CATFISH, TILAPIA OR CHICKEN TENDERS), 20 SHRIMP, 2 LARGE HOUSE SIDES, AND CHOICE OF JALAPEÑO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFINS OR HUSHPUPPIES. LEMONS AND CONDIMENTS INCLUDED.
FISH TACKLE BOX
$54.00INCLUDES: 3 PIECES OF PROTEIN OF CHOICE ( WHITING, CATFISH, TILAPIA OR CHICKEN TENDERS), 2 LARGE HOUSE SIDES, AND CHOICE OF JALAPEÑO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFINS OR HUSHPUPPIES. LEMONS AND CONDIMENTS INCLUDED.
SHRIMP TACKLE BOX
$63.00INCLUDES: BASKET OF 30 SHRIMP, 2 LARGE HOUSE SIDES, AND CHOICE OF JALAPEÑO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFINS OR HUSHPUPPIES. LEMONS AND CONDIMENTS INCLUDED.
FRIED SEAFOOD
CAPTAINS COMBO
$49.00Crispy fried haddock, 10 shrimp, and calamari perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices and fried to golden perfection. Served with a flavorful house-made crab cake, 2 sides, and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked in house.
FISH & SHRIMP COMBO
$29.00Crispy fried haddock, paired with golden-fried shrimp, both seasoned with our signature blend of spices. Served with two house-made sides crafted fresh daily, and with a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked in house.
FISH FRY
$22.00Crispy fried haddock, perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices and fried to golden perfection. Served with two house-made sides of your choice and a jalapeño.
SHRIMP FRY
$25.0010 crispy, golden-fried shrimp, perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices. Served with your choice of two house-made sides crafted fresh daily and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin baked in- house.
THE BUFFALO CLASSIC FISH FRY
$21.00Beer battered haddock served with crispy french fries, house-made coleslaw, macaroni salad and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin with all the fixings. *NO SUBSTITUTIONS*
HOUSE FLAVORS & SAUCES
BAHAMA SAUCE
$1.50BOMBAY SAUCE
$1.50BUFFALO LEMON PEPPER SAUCE
$1.50BUFFALO SAUCE
$1.50CAESAR DRESSING
$1.00CAJUN DRY RUB
$1.50CAJUN LEMON PEPPER DRY RUB
$1.50CREAMY CAJUN PASTA SAUCE
$2.50FIESTA SAUCE
$2.00FISH HOAGIE SAUCE
$1.50FLAMING HOT DRY RUB
$1.50HONEY CAJUN SAUCE
$1.50HONEY GARLIC LIME SAUCE
$1.50HONEY MUSTARD
$1.00HOT HONEY SAUCE
$1.50HOT SAUCE
$0.50HOUSE COCKTAIL SAUCE
$0.50HOUSE TARTAR SAUCE
$0.50ITALIAN DRESSING
$1.00KETCHUP
$0.50LEMON PEPPER DRY RUB
$2.00MUSTARD
$0.50PASTA LOUIE SAUCE
$2.50PO'BOY SAUCE
$1.50RANCH DRESSING
$1.00RASPBERRY VINAIGRETTE
$1.00SANDWICH SAUCE
$2.00SAUCE LEXINGTON
$2.50SAUCE REMINGTON
$4.50SEAFOOD MAGNOLIA SAUCE
$2.50SOUR CREAM
$1.50KIDS MEALS
KIDS CHEESE QUESADILLA & FRIES
$10.00KIDS CHICKEN QUESADILLA & FRIES
$10.00KIDS CHICKEN STRIPS & FRIES
$10.00KIDS FRIED FISH & FRIES
$10.00KIDS FRIED SHRIMP & FRIES
$10.00KIDS MINI CHEESEBURGERS
$10.00PASTAS
CREAMY CAJUN PASTA
$28.00Fettuccine pasta tossed in our bold Cadien cream sauce, featuring grilled salmon, smoked beef sausage, sautéed onions, peppers, and mushrooms. A deliciously spicy and creamy dish that's sure to satisfy.
PASTA LOUIE
$25.00Fettuccine pasta smothered in a rich creamy Alfredo sauce with spinach, perfectly seasoned. Topped with grilled salmon for a bold flavorful twist on a classic favorite.
PASTA LOUIE - NO PROTEIN
$17.00SEAFOOD MAGNOLIA
$36.00A mouthwatering medley of shrimp, crawfish tails, mussels, lump crab and lobster claw, sautéed with bell peppers and onions. All tossed in a rich, creamy scampi sauce. Served over fettuccine pasta for a dish that's full of seafood goodness.
SANDWICHES
CAJUN SALMON SLIDERS
$18.00TWO GRILLED SLIDERS SERVED ON SOFT BUNS WITH CRISP LETTUCE, JUICY TOMATO, RED ONION, AND OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE.
FISH HOAGIE
$18.00Choice of Haddock, Catfish, Tilapia, or Whiting with sautéed onions and peppers, melted American cheese, and drizzled with our signature sauce.
FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH
$16.00CRISPY FRIED CHICKEN BREAST TOPPED WITH LETTUCE, TOMATO, RED ONION, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE AND OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE.
PORTSIDE
$24.00Succulent lobster tossed in our magnolia sauce and a blend of melted cheeses, grilled to perfection between 2 slices of sourdough bread.
SHORELINE
$16.00A double patty smash burger sucked with a crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, sautéed onions and mushrooms, pickles, melted American cheese and our signature sauce.
SHRIMP POBOY
$18.00Crispy shrimp piled on a toasted roll, topped with lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese and drizzled with our special sauce.
THE CLASSIC FISH SANDWICH
$16.00Choice of Haddock, Catfish, Tilapia, or Whiting, shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion, melted American cheese served on a toasted roll.
THE CRAB ATTACK
$24.00Two crab cake sliders topped with grilled shrimp, crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, melted cheese and our signature sauce.
SHAREABLES
BOMBAY SHRIMP
$16.00A pile of our specially seasoned fried shrimp tossed in our original Bombay sauce served on top of a bed of lettuce and topped with shredded carrots, red cabbage and green onions.
CRISPY CALAMARI
$12.00CRISPY CALAMARI RINGS SERVED WITH CREAMY SAVORY DIPPING SAUCE.
CRISPY MOZZERELLA
$10.00Golden, crunchy perfection on the outside, warm gooey mozzarella on the inside. Served with marinara.
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES
$14.00FRESH GREEN-TOMATOES, PERFECTLY FRIED TO A GOLDEN PERFECTION. TOPPED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE.
QUESADILLA
$17.00A 12" tortilla toasted to perfection and filled with a blend of cheeses, sautéed bell pepper and onions, corn & beans and signature sauce with choice protein.
SEAFOOD FRIES
$18.00CRISPY SEASONED FRIES SMOTHERED IN MELTED CHEESE AND CROWNED WITH A SEAFOOD MEDLEY. DRIZZLED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCES AND FINISHED WITH FRESH PICO WE GALLO, AND SHREDDED CHEESE AND SOUR CREAM.
SIDES
ASPARAGUS
$7.00BAKED MACARONI & CHEESE
$7.00BROCCOLI
$4.50CAJUN RICE
$7.00CANDIED YAMS
$4.50COLESLAW
$4.50COLLARD GREENS (With Turkey)
$4.50FRENCH FRIES
$4.50FRIED OKRA
$7.00GARLIC MASHED POTATOES
$4.50GREEN BEANS
$4.50HUSHPUPPIES
$4.50MACARONI SALAD
$4.50POTATO SALAD
$4.50RED BEANS & RICE
$4.50SEAFOOD PASTA SALAD
$7.00SPECIALS
CRISPY NUGGETS
$15.00CRISPY BEER BATTERED FISH NUGGETS SERVED WITH CHOICE OF FRENCH FRIES OR HUSHPUPPIES.
CRISPY NUGGETS PARTY BASKET
$50.00CRISPY BEER BATTERED FISH NUGGETS SERVES 5 - 10 PEOPLE.
FISH TACO PLATTER
$50.00ORDER ONE OF OUR TACO PLATTERS PERFECT FOR YOUR SUPER BOWL PARTY! INCLUDES 10 TACOS
JAMBALAYA PARTY PAN
$65.00OUR TAKE ON A CREOLE CLASSIC FEATURING SAVORY RICE LOADED WITH ONIONS. PEPPERS, AND CELERY. TOSSED WITH TENDER CHICKEN, JUICY SHRIMP, AND SMOKED BEEF SAUSAGE. SERVES 8 - 12 PEOPLE
MINI SHRIMP PO'BOY PLATTER
$62.00ORDER OUR MINI SHRIMP PERFECT FOR YOUR SUPER BOWL PARTY! INCLUDES 12 MINI PO'BOYS.
QUEEN CITY GRITS
$23.00CHOICE OF CRISPY FRIED HADDOCK, CATFISH, OR SHRIMP(+2) SERVED OVER CREAMY STONE GROUND GRITS TOPPED WITH SAUTEED ONIONS AND BELL PEPPERS IN A GOLDEN GRAVY.
SHRIMP PARTY BASKET
$62.50ORDER OUR JUICY SHRIMP BASKET PERFECT FOR YOUR SUPER BOWL PARTY! INCLUDES 50 SHRIMP
TACOS
FIESTA TACO
$15.00Fried or grilled tilapia topped with crisp lettuce, corn salsa, shredded cheese and drizzled with our signature sauce.
HADDOCK ALL - IN
$20.00SEABREEZE
$16.00FRIED OR GRILLED TILAPIA TOPPED WITH CRISP LETTUCE MANGO SALSA AND DRIZZLED WITH OUR MILD SIGNATURE SAUCE.
THE BAHAMA MAMA
$15.00Fried or grilled tilapia topped with crisp lettuce, pico de gallo, and drizzled with our mild signature sauce.
THE MAINS
JAMBALAYA
$24.00Our take on a creole classic featuring savory rice loaded with onions. peppers, and celery. Tossed with tender chicken, juicy shrimp, and smoked beef sausage.
SKIPPERS HERB CRUSTED DINNER
$24.00Herb crusted haddock, perfectly seasoned and served over a bed of creamy garlic mashed potatoes. Paired with tender char-grilled asparagus.
THE BELTWAY
$23.00Grilled tilapia topped with succulent grilled shrimp and topped with our signature Sauce Remington. Served alongside our red beans and rice.
THE CRAB SHACK
$34.00Two golden 4oz house-made crab cakes served alongside creamy garlic mashed potatoes and char-grilled asparagus. Finished with our signature Sauce Remington.
THE HARBOURSIDE
$46.00HERB CRUSTED SALMON WITH SUCCULENT SHRIMP AND A TENDER LOBSTER TAIL. SERVED OVER CREMAY GARLIC MASHED POTATOES, ACCOMPANIED BY COLLARD GREENS. FINISHED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE REMINGTON.
THE LEXINGTON
$28.00GRILLED HADDOCK PAIRED WITH SUCCULENT GRILLED SHRIMP, SERVED WITH CAJUN RICE AND BROCCOLI. FINISHED WITH A CREAMY SPINACH PARMESAN SAUCE.
THE MAIDEN VOYAGE
$62.00CRAB CAKE STUFFED SALMON, SUCCULENT SHRIMP, AND A TENDER LOBSTER TAIL. SERVED OVER CREAMY GARLIC MASHED POTATOES, ACCOMPANIED BY COLLARD GREENS. FINISHED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE REMINGTON. A DISH FIT FOR A TRUE SEAFOOD LOVER.
THE REMINGTON
$34.007oz HERB-CRUSTED SALMON PAIRED WITH GRILLED SHRIMP, SERVED OVER A BED OF CREAMY GARLIC MASHED POTATOES AND SERVED WITH COLLARD GREENS. FINISHED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE REMINGTON.
THE WHOLE FRIED SNAPPER AND SHRIMP
$42.00Crispy fried Red Snapper & Shrimp served with our collard greens, red beans and cajun rice. *Red Beans are made with smoked turkey and beef sausage. *Collard Greens are made with smoked turkey.