The Bagel Bin

Staten Island, NY

486 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY, 10310-2501
64 itemsUpdated March 22, 2026
Structured menu data

Apple Butter

$4.50

Butter

$3.75

Butter & CC

$5.25

Butter, Cinnamon & Sugar

$4.50

Cream Cheese & Jelly

$5.00

Crunchy Peanut Butter

$5.25

Flavored CC

$4.75

Flavored Cream Cheese

$5.25

Honey Crunch Peanut Butter

$6.00

Lox Spread

$7.75

Plain CC

$4.50

Plain Cream Cheese

$4.75

Tuna / Egg Salad

$4.25

Challah & Pan Challah

Knot Rolls

$5.75

½ Dozen Challah Rolls

$4.25

California Delight

$8.25

Hummus Club Sandwich

$8.50

hummus spread, lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber, & sprouts on wheat bread only

Lox both sides

$13.00

Lox, Onion, Tomato & CC

$10.00

Taco Salad

$9.25

Bottled Soda

$2.50

Bottled Water

$2.50

Chia Tea

Coffee

$5.25

Fountain Drinks

Hot Chocolate & Cappuccino

Hot Tea

$2.50

Juice

$2.50

Lattes & Mochas

Milk

$1.75

Bagel Chips

$5.75

Baker's Dozen (13 Bagels)

$13.00

Brownies

$2.25

Cinnamon Roll

$2.50

Cookies

$1.50

Doughnuts (Cake & Raised)

$2.25

Long Johns/Jelly Bismarks

$2.50

Pecan Roll

$3.00

Turnovers (Apple/Cherry)

$2.50

Bialy

$2.50

Chips

$1.75

Cream Cheese Spread (8oz)

$4.50

Crunch Bagels

$1.50

Deviled Egg

$2.50

Egg/Tuna Salad

$7.50

Hummas

$4.00

Hummus Spread

$6.00

Noodle Kugel

$6.00

Potato Salad & Cole Slaw

$2.50

Sweet Kugel

$6.50

Bowl of Soup w/ bagel chips

$6.75

Cheese Melt w/ Tomato

$6.00

Denver Omelet

$6.75

Egg Florentine

$7.00

Egg Mitt Bagel

$6.50

Egg/Tuna Salad Melt

$8.50

Extra Enchilada Casserole

$8.25

Fresh Mushroom Melt

$7.25

Mac & Cheese

$7.50

Pizza Bagel

$7.00

Salmon Patty Platter

$9.50

Sproutness

$6.50

Sue's from Scratch Platters

$9.00