hello.food

The Pie Guy Pizza Menu — New York, New York | hello.food

hello.food
/Restaurants
/New York
/New York
/The Pie Guy Pizza

New York, NY

The Pie Guy Pizza

83-85 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013, USA

14 itemsUpdated March 17, 2026

Menu powered by hello.food

WheatIdentified by hello.food

Get personalized guidance in hello.food

Check any menu item against your dietary profile. Free for iOS.

Safer food choices for dietary restrictions

Download for iOS Restaurant Owners Privacy Terms

© 2026 hello.food. All rights reserved. A production of FRNTR, LLC.

Menu

Beef Patties

$3.00

EggsWheat

Buffalo Chicken

$4.50

EggsDairyWheat

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$3.50

EggsDairySoyWheat

Garlic Knots:

$3.00

EggsDairyWheat

Grandma

$4.00

EggsDairyWheat

Italian Sausage

$3.50

EggsDairyWheat

Margherita

$3.50

EggsDairyWheat

Mushroom

$3.50

EggsDairyWheat

Pepperoni

$3.50

EggsDairyWheat

Spicy Rigatoni

$5.00

EggsDairyWheat

The Classic

$2.50

EggsDairyWheat

The New Yorker

$4.00

EggsDairyWheat

Vodka Sauce

$3.50

EggsDairyWheat

White Pizza

$3.50

EggsDairyWheat

Get personalized guidance in hello.food

Check any menu item against your dietary profile. Free for iOS.

Own this restaurant?

Manage your menu, review allergen data, and control your public presence on hello.food.

Claim this restaurant

Allergen information is provided as a guide and is not medical advice. Always confirm with your healthcare provider and inform restaurant staff about dietary restrictions before ordering.