Siena Cafe
New York, NY
1580 3rd Ave, New York, NY, 10128-2244138 itemsUpdated August 7, 2026
Structured menu data
Allergen terms are identified from menu descriptions.
Aperitivo
Limoncello
$6.00Montenegro
$8.00Sambuca
$6.00Beer - Bottled
Corona
$6.00Frost
$6.00Heineken
$6.00Heineken 0.0
$6.00Non-alcoholic
Moretti
$6.00Sam Adams Seasonal
$6.00Stella Artois
$6.00Beer - Draft
Allagash White
$8.00Krombacher
$8.00Lagunitas
$8.00Modelo Especial
$8.00Peroni
$8.00Sierra Nevada
$8.00Cocktails
All the Way Up
$18.00Brewed lavazza espresso, boleti coffee liquor, with choice of vodka or reposada tequila
Death by Lychee
$14.00Pineapple vodka, lychee, lemon, elderflower
Diavolo Piccante
$14.00Jalapeño infused tequila blanco, pineapple, agave, cucumber slice, lime, rocks
Espresso Negroni
$14.00Espresso ice cube, dry gin, campari, sweet vermouth, cherry and lemon peel
Fig-Tini
$14.00Figenza fig vodka, triple sec, splash of cranberry served up
Mamasita
$12.00Mi Campo 100% agave tequila, agave, fresh lime, fresh cucumber, strawberry or classic lime
Meet the Spritzers
$14.00Aperol, Limoncello or Hugo with prosecco, orange wheel and mint
Now Yuz Can't Leave
$14.00Hendricks gin, St.Germain, lemon juice, simple, sparkling, lime zest
Old Fashioned
$15.00Forester bourbon, angostura bitter, orange, lemon peel, brown sugar
Part-Time Lover
$13.00Cachaca, passion fruit, muddled lime juice, brown sugar served in a tall glass
Porn Star
$14.00Vanilla vodka, lime, passion fruit, sparkling rose
Smash N' Grab
$14.00Muddled cherries & basil, Gordon's gin, lemon juice simple, topped with sparkling water, rimmed with basil sugar
Coffee
Cappuccino
$5.00Hot or cold
Dairy
Espresso
$3.00Irish Coffee
$12.00Dairy
Lavazza Coffee
$3.00Hot or cold
Macchiato
$4.00Dairy
Mexican Coffee
$12.00Dairy
Create Your Own Pasta
Pasta Choice
Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Linguini, Fusilli, Gnocchi, Lumache, Caserecce
EggsWheat
Sauce Choice
Pesto Basil Sauce, Vodka Sauce, Tomato Sauce, Bolognese, Roasted Garlic and Oil, Spicy Tomato Sauce
SoyTree Nuts
Toppings Choice
Beef Meatballs, Sausage, Mushrooms, Broccoli Rabe, Meat Sauce, Vegetables, Chicken, Shrimp
Shellfish
Dessert
Assorted Dessert
EggsDairy
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Eggs
Frutti Di Bosco
EggsDairy
Miniature Cannoli
EggsDairyWheat
New York Cheesecake
EggsDairy
Tiramisu
EggsDairy
Insalata (Salads)
Avocado Salad
$5080.00Pear, pecan, red grape, mixed greens, champagne dressing
Tree Nuts
Caesar Siena
$4070.00Kale, romaine, croutons, parmesan, Caesar dressing
EggsFishDairyWheat
Crispy Artichoke
$5080.00Roasted red peppers, tomato, arugula, parmesan dressing
Dairy
Farmers Salad
$4070.00Cherry tomato, red onion, greens, carrots, balsamic vinaigrette
Hanger Steak
$120200.00Roasted red peppers, avocado, crumbled gorgonzola cheese, tomato, red onion, vinaigrette dressing
Dairy
Mozzarella Caprese
$4070.00Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, cherry tomatoes, with fresh basil, EVOO, and balsamic glaze
Dairy
Tri Colore
$4070.00Arugula, endive, radicchio, shaved parmesan, vinaigrette dressing
Dairy
Panini Sandwiches
Assorted Wrap
$60100.00Wheat
Chicken Caesar
$60100.00Romaine lettuce, croutons, Caesar dressing
FishWheat
Hanger Steak and Mushrooms
$80140.00Sautéed mushrooms, onions, peppers
Wheat
Prosciutto and Fresh Mozzarella
$60100.00Pesto and balsamic dressing
DairyTree NutsWheat
Shrimp Caesar
$60100.00Romaine lettuce, croutons, Caesar dressing
FishShellfishWheat
Vegetarian
$5080.00Assorted vegetables
Wheat
Pasta Fresca (Hand Made Pasta)
Black Fettuccini
$110190.00Shrimp and calamari fra diavolo over squid ink fettuccini
EggsShellfishWheat
Cacio E Pepe
$80140.00Spaghetti, pecorino, black peppers, butter
EggsDairyWheat
Casarecce All Vodka
$100180.00Shrimp, spicy sausage, vodka sauce
EggsShellfishWheat
Fussili Fontina
$80140.00Wild mushrooms, asparagus, tomatoes, truffle fontina sauce
EggsDairyWheat
Gnocchi Pesto
$80140.00Basil pesto, toasted pignoli nuts
EggsTree NutsWheat
Linguini White Clam Sauce
$100180.00Roasted garlic, parsley, white wine, butter, manilla clams
EggsDairyShellfishWheat
Lumache Di Casa
$90160.00Broccoli rabe, chicken or sausage, roasted garlic and oil
EggsWheat
Potato Gnocchi
$80140.00Braised beef short rib ragu
EggsWheat
Rigatoni Bolognese
$90160.00Home made beef Bolognese sauce
EggsWheat
Piatti Grandi - Chicken (Entrees)
Francese
$80140.00EggsWheat
Marsala
$80140.00Dairy
Parmigiana
$80140.00EggsDairyWheat
Piccata
$80140.00EggsDairy
Scarpiello
$80140.00Dairy
Sorrentino
$80140.00EggsDairy
Piatti Grandi - Italian Classics (Entrees)
Eggplant Parmigiana
$60100.00EggsDairy
Eggplant Rollatini
$60100.00EggsDairy
Meatballs (All Beef)
$60100.00Eggs
Sausage and Peppers
$60100.00Wheat
Piatti Grandi - Seafood (Entrees)
Salmon Di Casa
$100180.00Fish
Shrimp Parmigiana
$100180.00EggsDairyShellfish
Shrimp Scampi
$100180.00Shellfish
Piatti Piccoli (Appetizers)
Arancini
$4070.00Sicilian rice balls, mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce
DairyWheat
Baked Clams
$60110.00Little neck clams, lemon, white wine, oreganata
Shellfish
Burrata Plate
$5090.00Pistachio, arugula, honey balsamic, cherry tomatoes, crostini
DairyTree NutsWheat
Calamari Fritti
$76140.00Cherry peppers, marinara sauce
Wheat
Carciofi Fritto
$4070.00Crispy artichoke with lemon zest, garlic aioli to dip
EggsWheat
Char Grilled Octopus
$80150.00Arugula, tomato, fava beans, lemon, EVOO
Coconut Shrimp
$90170.00Lightly battered shrimp with coco flakes with Thai chili sauce to dip
ShellfishWheat
Fresh Mozzarella Sticks
$4070.00Battered fresh mozzarella served with tomato sauce
EggsDairyWheat
Marinated Olives
$3560.00Garlic, rosemary, crostini, EVOO
Parmesan Truffle Fries
$5090.00Aioli sauce to dip
EggsDairy
Polpette
$5090.00Pat Lafreida beef meatballs, ricotta crostini, tomato sauce
DairyWheat
Prince Edward Mussels
$60110.00Classic garlic & oil or spicy marinara
Shellfish
Rollatini Di Melanzane
$5090.00Baked, thin sliced eggplant, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, basil, tomato sauce
Dairy
Shrimp Cocktail
$80150.00Jumbo shrimp, lemon, cocktail sauce
Shellfish
Siena Wings
$4070.00Served in buffalo or hot sauce with celery and blue cheese
Dairy
Zucchine Fritte
$4070.00Crispy zucchini, tomato sauce to dip
Wheat
Rosè
Rosè
Aimme, Cote De Provence
Salad Add-Ons
Grilled or Crispy Chicken
$2040.00Salmon
$90160.00Fish
Shrimp
$80140.00Shellfish
Soft Drinks
Club Soda
$2.00Coke
$2.00Cranberry
$2.00Diet Coke
$2.00Ginger Ale
$2.00Ginger Beer Fever Tree
$3.00Grapefruit Fever Tree
$3.00Lemonade
$2.00Panna
$6.00Pelligrino
$6.00Pineapple Juice
$2.00Shirley Temple
$3.00Sprite
$2.00Tea
$2.00Assorted
Tonic Fever Tree
$3.00Sparkling
Champagne
$140.00Veuve Cliqout
Moscato
Gemma Di Luna, Italy DOCG
Prosecco
Voga, Italy DOCG
Rose Sparkling
$40.00Voga, Italy DOCG
Vini Bianchi (White Wine)
Chardonnay
Chalk Hill, Sonoma
Gavi Di Gavi
Villa Rosa, Italy DOCG
Greco Di Tufo
Vinosia, L'ariella
Pinot Grigio
Banfi, Italy
Reisling
Eroica, Columbia Valley
Sancerre
Comte Jean Maréchal
Sauvignon Blanc
Kim Crawford, NZ
Vermintino
Pagliatura, Tuscany
Vini Rossi (Red Wine)
Amorone
Buglioini, Valpolicella DOCG
Barbaresco
$75.00Beni di Batasiolo, Italy 2019
Barbera D'alba
$42.00La Gemella, Italy 2021
Barolo
Villa Rosa, Fondatore DOCG
Brunello di Montalcino
$150.00Banfi, Tuscany 2017
Cabernet Sauvignon
Coppola, California
Chianti Classico
Banfi, Toscana, DOCG
Malbec Reserva
Luigi Bosca, Mendoza
Montpulciano
Borgo Reale, Italy DOCG
Pinot Noir
L'umami, Oregon
Sangiovesse
Il Poggio, Rubicone DOCG
Super Tuscan
Yantra, Tuscany DOCG
Allergen information is provided as a guide and is not medical advice. Always confirm with your healthcare provider and inform restaurant staff about dietary restrictions before ordering.