All Beef Meatballs
$14.00Gluten Free Breadcrumbs, Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Ricotta, Basil, Pecorino (also available as a sandwich on our homemade focaccia)
Scarr's Pizza
New York, NY
35 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002, USA106 itemsUpdated March 17, 2026
Structured menu data
Appetizers
Caprese Salad
$12.00Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Cherry Tomatoes, Basil, Japanese Sea Salt
Chicken Parm App
$17.00Gluten Free Breaded Chicken (Contains Eggs), Fresh Mozz, Sauce, Basil, Pecorino (also available as a sandwich on our homemade focaccia)
Eggplant Parm App
$15.00Gluten Free Breaded Eggplant (Contains Eggs), Fresh Mozz, Sauce, Basil, Pecorino (also available as a sandwich on our homemade focaccia)
Focaccia
$6.00Made Fresh Daily
Focaccia with Whipped Ricotta - Mike's Extra Hot Honey
$9.00Garden Salad (LG)
$19.00Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onions, Red Peppers, Olives, Red Wine Vinaigrette
Garden Salad (SM)
$14.00Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onions, Red Peppers, Olives, Red Wine Vinaigrette
Vegan Caesar Salad (LG)
$19.00Gluten Free Bread Crumbs, Nutritional Yeast, Nori, Cashew-Based Dressing
Vegan Caesar Salad (SM)
$14.00Gluten Free Bread Crumbs, Nutritional Yeast, Nori, Cashew-Based Dressing
Vegan Garlic Knots
$6.00Fresh Garlic, Salt, Black Pepper
Vegan Garlic Knots with Fresh Mozz
$5.00Beers
Athletic Brewing Co. Run Wild IPA
$8.00Non Alcoholic - 0.4% abv, Milford, CT
Beloved Nutcracker (200 ml can)
$10.00Choice of guava basil or peach paradise 12% abv
Bronx Brewery Pilsner (10 oz)
$7.00Bronx, NY 5.4% abv
Bronx Brewery Pilsner (20 oz)
$11.00Bronx, NY 5.4% abv
Bronx Brewery Pilsner (Pitcher)
$41.00Bronx, NY 5.4% abv
Can-Vi Rose (250 ml can)
$12.00Catalonia, Spain
Dirty Water Hard Seltzer
$8.00NYC, 4.5% abv (notes of pear, lemon, malt)
Gaffel Kölsch (10 oz)
$8.00Gaffel Becker, Germany 4.8% abv
Gaffel Kölsch (20 oz)
$12.00Gaffel Becker, Germany 4.8% abv
Gaffel Kölsch (Pitcher)
$42.00Gaffel Becker, Germany 4.8% abv
Guinness Stout (16oz)
$9.00Ireland 4.2% abv
Guinness Stout (20 oz)
$14.00Ireland 4.2% abv
Kikusui Junmai Nama Genshu Sake (200 ml can)
$8.00Niigata, Japan 17% abv
Miller High Life (10 oz)
$6.00Milwaukee, WI 4.6% abv
Miller High Life (20 oz)
$10.00Milwaukee, WI 4.6% abv
Miller High Life (Pitcher)
$40.00Milwaukee, WI 4.6% abv
OtherHalf Green City IPA (10 oz)
$9.00Brooklyn, NY 6.8% abv
OtherHalf Green City IPA (20 oz)
$13.00Brooklyn, NY 6.8% abv
OtherHalf Green City IPA (Pitcher)
$43.00Brooklyn, NY 6.8% abv
OtherHalf Poetry Snaps Rice Lager (10 oz)
$8.00Brooklyn, NY 4.5% abv
OtherHalf Poetry Snaps Rice Lager (20 oz)
$12.00Brooklyn, NY 4.5% abv
OtherHalf Poetry Snaps Rice Lager (Pitcher)
$42.00Brooklyn, NY 4.5% abv
Presidente
$6.00Santiago, Dominican Republic 5% abv
Suntory Premium Malt (10 oz)
$10.00100% brewed in Japan, floral aroma and creamy foam
Suntory Premium Malt (16 oz)
$14.00100% brewed in Japan, floral aroma and creamy foam
Bubbles
Lambrusco (Bottle)
$64.00Storchi, Pozzoferrato, Italy 2019 12% abv
Lambrusco (Glass)
$16.00Storchi, Pozzoferrato, Italy 2019 12% abv
Prosecco (Bottle)
$52.00Cuvee della Contessa 1925, Italy, NV 11% abv
Prosecco (Glass)
$13.00Cuvee della Contessa 1925, Italy, NV 11% abv
Calzones
Beef Meatball Calzone
$24.00Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Beef Meatballs, Served with Side of Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce
Cheese Calzone
$20.00Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Served with Side of Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce
Vegan Cheese Calzone
$23.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, NUMU Vegan Cheese, Fresh Garlic, Roasted Red Peppers, Basil
Cocktails
Dark N' Storm
$15.00Diplomatico Reserva Rum, Coconut Water, Ginger Beer, Fresh Lemon
DJ CK Lemonade
$15.00D'Ussé Cognac, Fresh Lemon, Fresh Orange, Soda
Espresso Martini
$17.00Helix Vodka, Kafé Anmé, Bailey's Irish Cream, Colbo Espresso Beans
Lychee East Side
$16.00Sake, Vodka, Lychee, St. Germain, Lemon
Red Lambo
$17.00Iwai 45 Japanese Whisky, Uncle Waithley's Caribbean Sorrel, Lime Juice, Pineapple Juice
Spicy Guava
$17.00Catedral Mezcal, Jalapeño Liqueur, Fresh Guava Puree, Fresh Lime, Fresh Jalapeño, Agave
The SP Highball
$16.00Nikka Days Japanese Whisky, Nomina Extra Sparkling Water
Yuzu Lemon Drop
$16.00El Tequileño Tequila, Yuzu Liqueur, Fresh Lemon Juice
Desserts
Guava Calzone
$14.00Caputo Brothers Ricotta, Guava, Powdered Sugar
Scarr's Seasonal Soft-Serve
$6.00finished with single-estate evoo, and sea salt
Dips
Mike's Hot Honey Dip Cup 1oz
$2.00Organic Dinapoli Tomato Sauce 2oz
$2.00Vegan Caesar Dressing 2oz
$3.00contains cashew
Vegan Ranch Dressing 2oz
$3.00contains cashew
Pizzas - Round
Hotboi (12")
$29.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Cheese, Ezzo's Beef Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Mike's Extra Hot Honey
Hotboi (20")
$37.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Cheese, Ezzo's Beef Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Mike's Extra Hot Honey
Hotboi (Slice)
$6.50Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Cheese, Ezzo's Beef Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Mike's Extra Hot Honey
Margherita (12")
$27.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Basil, EVOO
Margherita (20")
$35.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Basil, EVOO
Margherita (Slice)
$6.50Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Basil, EVOO
Original (12")
$24.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese
Original (20")
$32.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese
Original (Slice)
$4.50Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese
Vegan (12")
$28.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, NUMU Vegan Cheese, Fresh Basil, EVOO
Vegan (20")
$36.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, NUMU Vegan Cheese, Fresh Basil, EVOO
Vegan (Slice)
$6.50Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, NUMU Vegan Cheese, Fresh Basil, EVOO
Vodka Pesto (12")
$29.00Vegan Vodka Sauce (Contains Coconut Milk), Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese, Vegan Pesto
Vodka Pesto (20")
$37.00Vegan Vodka Sauce (Contains Coconut Milk), Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese, Vegan Pesto
Vodka Pesto (Slice)
$6.50Vegan Vodka Sauce (Contains Coconut Milk), Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese, Vegan Pesto
White (12")
$27.00Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese, Fresh Mozz, Ricotta, Fresh Garlic, Black Pepper, EVOO
White (20")
$35.00Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese, Fresh Mozz, Ricotta, Fresh Garlic, Black Pepper, EVOO
Pizzas - Sicilian
Cheese (10" x 12" gluten-free)
$32.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese
Cheese (Slice)
$6.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese
DJ Clark Kent (10" x 12" gluten-free)
$36.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese, Chicken Sausage, Fresh Garlic
DJ Clark Kent (Slice)
$6.50Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fior di Pizza Cheese, Chicken Sausage, Fresh Garlic
Hotboi (10" x 12" gluten-free)
$37.00Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Cheese, Beef Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Mike's Extra Hot Honey
Lemon Pepper Chicken (10" x 12" gluten-free)
$36.00Caputo Brothers Fior Di Pizza Cheese & Fresh Mozzarella, Chicken Sausage, Lemon, EVOO
Red Wine
Gamay (Bottle)
$60.00Laurent Lebled, "Ça C'est Bon!" Touraine, France 2024 12% abv
Gamay (Glass)
$15.00Laurent Lebled, "Ça C'est Bon!" Touraine, France 2024 12% abv
Pinot Noir Blend (Bottle)
$68.00Jumbo Time X Scarr's "The Gift", California 2023 11.8% abv
Pinot Noir Blend (Glass)
$17.00Jumbo Time X Scarr's "The Gift", California 2023 11.8% abv
Sangiovese (Bottle)
$64.00Stolpman, Love You Bunches, California 2021 12.5% abv
Sangiovese (Glass)
$16.00Stolpman, Love You Bunches, California 2021 12.5% abv
Skin Contact Wine
Espadeiro (Bottle)
$56.00Bojo do Luar, Pet Nat "Luiza", Lixa, Portugal 11% abv
Espadeiro (Glass)
$14.00Bojo do Luar, Pet Nat "Luiza", Lixa, Portugal 11% abv
Pinot Gris (Bottle)
$68.00Jumbo Time X Scarr's "THE GIFT", California 2023 11.5% abv
Pinot Gris (Glass)
$17.00Jumbo Time X Scarr's "THE GIFT", California 2023 11.5% abv
Reisling (Bottle)
$60.00Weingut Strub, "Riesling RAW", Germany, 2024 11.5% abv
Reisling (Glass)
$15.00Weingut Strub, "Riesling RAW", Germany, 2024 11.5% abv
Soft Drinks
Diet Coke
$3.00Mexican Coke
$5.00Palestine Cola
$5.00Palestine Orange Soda
$5.00Sparkling Water
$7.00Still Water
$7.00White Wine
Chenin Blanc (Bottle)
$68.00Domaine de L'Oubliée, "Le Bruit Des Glaçons, Bourgueil, France 2024 12.5% abv
Chenin Blanc (Glass)
$17.00Domaine de L'Oubliée, "Le Bruit Des Glaçons, Bourgueil, France 2024 12.5% abv
Verdicchio (Bottle)
$56.00Bisci Verdicchio di Matelica, Italy 2022 13% abv
Verdicchio (Glass)
$14.00Bisci Verdicchio di Matelica, Italy 2022 13% abv
Whole Pizza Toppings
Cheese Toppings
$5.00Extra Cheese, Extra Vegan Cheese, Ricotta
Meat Toppings
$6.00Cured Anchovies, Beef Pepperoni, Beef Meatballs, Chicken Sausage
Vegetable Toppings
$4.00Basil, Cherry Tomatoes, Crimini Mushroom, Fresh Garlic, Jalapeños, Olives, Red Onions, Roasted Red Pepper