Original Pizza

New York, NY

2351 Ralph Ave, New York, NY, 11234-5516
50 itemsUpdated August 8, 2026
Structured menu data

Allergen terms are identified from menu descriptions.

Chicken Wings

$12.75
EggsWheat

Mozzarella Sticks

$10.75
EggsDairyWheat

Buffalo Chicken Pie - Round

$34.00

Mozzarella & Diced Chicken Marinated in our Signature Buffalo Sauce

EggsDairyWheat

Caesar Salad - Grilled Chicken Large

$21.75
EggsFishDairy

Caesar Salad - Grilled Chicken Small

$15.50
EggsFishDairy

Caesar Salad - Plain Large

$10.75
EggsFishDairy

Caesar Salad - Plain Small

$8.75
EggsFishDairy

Calzone - Large

$28.50
EggsDairyWheat

Calzone - Small

$9.50
EggsDairyWheat

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie - Round

$38.50

Chicken & Crispy Bacon

EggsDairyWheat

Grandma Pie

$32.00

Thin Crust Sicilian – Fresh Mozzarella, Plum Tomatoes, Touch of Fresh Garlic, Grated Romano Cheese, Fresh Basil & Drizzle of Olive Oil

EggsDairyWheat

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pie - Round

$37.50

Garlic and Oregano crust & topped with Romaine Lettuce, Seasoned Grilled Chicken and Caesar Dressing

EggsFishDairyWheat

MVP Pie

$36.75

Classic Marinara, Creamy Vodka Sauce & Fresh Basil Pesto

EggsDairyTree NutsWheat

Original Classic Pie - Large Sicilian

$27.00
EggsDairyWheat

Original Classic Pie - Round

$23.00
EggsDairyWheat

Original Classic Pie - Small Sicilian

$23.50
EggsDairyWheat

Original Special Pie - Round

$36.00

Italian Sausage, Roasted Peppers, Onions, Anchovies, Pepperoni, Black Olives, Fresh Mushrooms & Garlic

EggsFishDairyWheat

Original Supreme Pie - Round

$32.00

Homemade Fresh Mozzarella, Romano Cheese, Fresh Basil & Crushed Tomatoes

EggsDairyWheat

Penne ala Vodka Pie - Round

$36.00

Penne Pasta & Creamy Pink Vodka Sauce

EggsDairyWheat

Buffalo Chicken Roll

$9.50
EggsWheat

Chicken Roll

$9.50
EggsDairyWheat

Sausage Roll

$9.50
EggsDairySoyWheat

Spinach Roll

$9.50
EggsDairyWheat

Sicilian Roni Cup Pie

$37.75

Mozzarella, Classic Marinara, "Cup and Char" Pepperoni, & Mike's Hot Honey

EggsDairyWheat

Buffalo Chicken Slice

$6.50
EggsFishDairyWheat

Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

$7.50
EggsFishDairyWheat

Chicken Slice

$6.50
EggsDairyWheat

Grandma Slice

$5.50
EggsDairyWheat

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Slice

$7.75
EggsFishDairyWheat

Marinara Slice

$5.75
EggsWheat

MVP Slice

$6.75
EggsDairyWheat

Penne ala Vodka Slice

$7.50
EggsDairySoyWheat

Primavera Slice

$7.00
EggsWheat

Round Slice

$4.00
EggsDairyWheat

Sicilian Roni Cup Slice

$6.75
EggsDairySoyWheat

Sicilian Slice

$4.00
EggsDairyWheat

Supreme Sicilian Slice

$6.00
EggsDairyWheat

Supreme Slice

$6.00
EggsDairyWheat

White Slice

$6.00
EggsDairyWheat

Garlic Twists - 12 pieces

$7.00
EggsDairyWheat

Garlic Twists - 6 pieces

$3.50
EggsDairyWheat

Pepperoni Twist

$1.00
EggsDairyWheat

Rice Ball

$6.25
EggsDairyWheat

Rice Ball Parmigiana

$8.25
EggsDairy

Toppings - Half

$4.00

Italian Sausage, Meatball, Roasted Peppers, Onions, Anchovies, Pepperoni, Black Olives, Extra Cheese, Spinach, Fresh Mushrooms, Fresh Garlic & Broccoli

EggsFishDairy

Toppings - Large Sicilian Half

$5.00

Italian Sausage, Meatball, Roasted Peppers, Onions, Anchovies, Pepperoni, Black Olives, Extra Cheese, Spinach, Fresh Mushrooms, Fresh Garlic & Broccoli

EggsFishDairy

Toppings - Large Sicilian Whole

$6.00

Italian Sausage, Meatball, Roasted Peppers, Onions, Anchovies, Pepperoni, Black Olives, Extra Cheese, Spinach, Fresh Mushrooms, Fresh Garlic & Broccoli

EggsFishDairy

Toppings - Whole

$5.00

Italian Sausage, Meatball, Roasted Peppers, Onions, Anchovies, Pepperoni, Black Olives, Extra Cheese, Spinach, Fresh Mushrooms, Fresh Garlic & Broccoli

EggsFishDairy

Vegetable Pie - Round

$36.00

Roasted Peppers, Onions, Black Olives, Fresh Mushrooms, Spinach & Garlic

EggsWheat

White Pie - Round

$33.00

Mozzarella & Ricotta Cheese

EggsDairyWheat

Allergen information is provided as a guide and is not medical advice. Always confirm with your healthcare provider and inform restaurant staff about dietary restrictions before ordering.