Bottled Soda
$3.25Nothing like a cold soda to wash down your pizza.
Made In New York Pizza
New York, NY
421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY, 10024-581372 itemsUpdated March 21, 2026
Structured menu data
Beverages
Bottled Water
$2.50An artisan blend of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom.
Soda
$3.25Nothing like a cold soda to wash down your pizza.
Water
$2.50An artisan blend of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom.
Desserts
Cannolis
$7.00Chocolate Cheesecake
$7.00New York Cheesecake
$7.00Tiramisu
$7.00House Favorites
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$37.00Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$37.00Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese
Fresh Mozzarella Margherita Pizza
$32.00Fresh mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce and basil.
Grandma Pizza
$32.00Cooked in olive oil-coated pan topped with classic cheese and tomato sauce.
House Salad
$10.00Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, onions and carrots.
Knots
Garlic Knots with Marinara
$4.00A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley. Served with a side of sauce.
Pies
Cheese Pizza
$24.30Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
$33.30Mozzarella, breaded chicken, bacon cuts, ranch.
Classic Margherita Pizza
$30.60Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, fresh garlic, basil and EVOO.
Mushroom Pizza
$28.80Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, fresh mushrooms.
Pepperoni Pizza
$28.80California tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, pepperoni.
Sausage Pizza
$28.80Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, sweet italian sausage.
Street Fair Pizza
$33.30Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, sweet italian sausage, white onion, hot cherry peppers.
White Pizza
$30.60A four cheese blend, basil, EVOO.
Yo Paulie Pizza
$33.30Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino romano, oregano, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers, honey drizzle.
Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
$19.00Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Margherita (Stracciatella)
$40.00California crushed tomato, post oven Stracciatella, oregano, chopped basil and E.V.O.O
Plain Cheese Pizza
$27.00Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Sausage & Jalapenos Pizza
$37.00Fresh mozzarella cheese, sausage, and jalapenos.
Vodka Pizza
$32.00Fresh mozzarella with Vodka sauce and basil
White Spinach Pizza
$37.00A sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.
Pizza By The Slice
BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice
$5.17Mozzarella cheese, breaded chicken marinated in sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice
$5.17Mozzarella cheese, breaded chicken marinated in frank's red hot sauce, ranch drizzle.
Cheese Pizza Slice
$3.60Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice
$5.17Mozzarella, breaded chicken, bacon cuts, ranch.
Classic Margherita Pizza Slice
$4.73Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, fresh garlic, basil and EVOO.
Classic Sicilian Pizza Slice
$4.50Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, sicilian oregano, pecorino romano.
Drunken Grandma Pizza Slice
$4.73Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, vodka sauce, basil, EVOO.
Eggplant Sicilain Pizza Slice
$5.17Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, charred eggplant, basil, EVOO.
Mushroom Pizza Slice
$5.00Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, fresh mushrooms.
Original Grandma Pizza Slice
$4.50Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned plum tomatoes and fresh garlic topped with basil, EVOO.
Pepperoni Grandma Pizza Slice
$4.73Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, pepperoni, basil, EVOO.
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
$4.50California tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, pepperoni.
Sausage Pizza Slice
$4.50Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, sweet italian sausage.
Spicy Pepperoni Pizza Slice
$5.17Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, pecorino romano, spicy pepperoni cups.
Street Fair Pizza Slice
$5.17Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, sweet italian sausage, white onion, hot cherry peppers.
Upside Down Sicilian Pizza Slice
$4.50Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, sicilian oregano, pecorino romano.
Vodka Pizza Slice
$4.73Vodka sauce, pecorino, fresh mozzarella, basil, EVOO.
White Pizza Slice
$5.17A four cheese blend, basil, EVOO.
White Sicilian Pizza Slice
$5.17A four cheese blend, basil, EVOO.
Yo Paulie Pizza Slice
$5.17Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino romano, oregano, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers, honey drizzle.
Pizza Squares
Classic Sicilian Pizza
$32.00Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Eggplant Pizza
$37.00Eggplant, sauce & cheese.
Spicy Pepperoni Pizza
$37.00Fresh mozzarella cheese and spicy pepperoni.
Upside Down Pizza
$32.00Sauce over cheese.
Veggie Pizza
$37.00With sauteed peppers, mushroom and onions.
White Pie
$37.00A sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.
Salads
Caesar Salad
$9.00With a choice of Caesar, ranch, or golden Italian dressing.
Sauces
Balsamic Dressing
$1.00Caesar Dressing
$1.00Golden Italian Dressing
$1.00Marinara Sauce
$1.00Ranch Dressing
$1.00Sides
Chicken Roll
$8.10Breaded chicken, sauce, mozzarella, pecorino and sicilian oregano with a side of marinara.
Garlic Knots
$3.60Tied knots, tossed in pecorino, garlic, oregano, salt, black pepper, basil, oil with a side of marinara.
Soft Drinks
Mexican Soda
$3.38Squares Pizza
Drunken Grandma Pizza
$30.60Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, vodka sauce, basil, EVOO.
Eggplant Sicilian Pizza
$33.30Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, charred eggplant, basil, EVOO.
Original Grandma Pizza
$28.80Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned plum tomatoes and fresh garlic topped with basil, EVOO.
Pepperoni Grandma Pizza
$30.60Fresh mozzarella, pecorino, seasoned, plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, pepperoni, basil, EVOO.
Upside Down Sicilian Pizza
$28.80Slow cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, sicilian oregano, pecorino romano.
White Sicilian Pizza
$33.30A four cheese blend, basil, EVOO.
Vegan Pizza
Vegan Cheese Pizza
$25.20Tomatoes, basil, Violife vegan cheese, Sicilian oregano and EVOO.
Vegan Pizza
$21.60Tomatoes, basil, sicilian oregano and EVOO.