BEEF ON WECK BURGER
8oz patty + provolone + weck sauce on weck roll
Forty Thieves
Buffalo, NY
727 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, USA42 itemsUpdated March 27, 2026
Structured menu data
HAND HELDS
BEYOND BURGER
plant based burger
BLACK-N-BLEU BURGER
blackened bleu cheese stuffed burger + crumbled bleu + provolone + bacon + cajun mayo
BLACKENED BACON CHEESEBURGER
pepperjack cheese + cajun mayo + LTO
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH
crispy or grilled chicken sauced in any of our wing sauces, LTO, mayo or bleu cheese on schiacciata
CORNED BEEF ON RYE
whole grain mustard + side of coleslaw
FISH TACOS OR SANDWICH (FRIDAY ONLY) (2)
crispy fried haddock tacos + lettuce + coleslaw + spicy aioli + pickled red onion
GRILLED CHICKEN PESTO SANDWICH
grilled chicken + roasted red pepper aioli + mozz + goat cheese + pesto on schiacciata
GRILLED SHRIMP TACOS (2)
seasoned grilled shrimp tacos + lettuce + coleslaw + spicy aioli + pickled red onion
GUINNESS STOUT BURGER
sautéed onions + bacon + cheddar + house made stout steak sauce
HOUSE BURGER
thick cut cheese + mayo + LTO on brioche
NASHVILLE HOT CHICKEN
crispy or grilled chicken sauced in nashville hot sauce + mayo + coleslaw on brioche
OPEN FACED MEATLOAF
meatloaf piled high w/ gravy + provolone on sourdough
PB&J BURGER
peanut butter + bacon + blackberry bacon jam + cheese on brioche
PORTABELLA SANDWICH
roasted portabella + cheese + fried egg + truffled aioli on brioche
REUBEN BURGER
house patty + corned beef + sauerkraut + swiss + russian dressing
STACK BURGER
thin patties + LTO + special sauce + american cheese on brioche
STEAK OR CHICKEN HOAGIE
thin sliced steak or chicken + peppers + onions + cherry peppers + cheese sauce + mayo
TENDERLOIN SANDWICH
slow roasted tenderloin + provolone + weck sauce on schiacciata
TURKEY BRIE CLUB
slow roasted turkey + brie + bacon + cranberry aioli + shaved romaine on schiacciata
WARDYNSKI FRIED BOLOGNA
peppers + onions + cheese on brioche
SNACKS
BLISTERED SHISHITO PEPPERS
CHICKEN FINGERS
CHICKEN WINGS (10)
Murph's Mild, Med, Hot, X Hot, Pit BBQ, Spicy BBQ, Southie Gold, Cajun Southie Gold, Cajun Honey, Garlic Parm, Spicy Garlic Parm, Cajun, Forty Sauce, Black 40 Gold (Hot)
FRIED DEVILED EGGS
FRIED PICKLES
FRIES (SMALL/LARGE)
GIANT SOFT PRETZEL & QUESO
LOADED NACHOS
beef, chicken, shrimp or veggie + black beans + black olives + tomatoes + onion + cherry peppers + corn + queso
MOZZARELLA STICKS (6)
PIZZA LOGS (5)
shake 'em in any wing sauce
SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP
add bread bowl
STUFFED BANANA PEPPERS
SOUPS & SALADS
CHILI (SEPT-APRIL)
make it a bread bowl
CHORIZO CORN CHOWDER
COBB SALAD
chicken + bacon + egg + tomatoes + red onion + cucumber + cheddar cheese + croutons + lemon basil vinaigrette
FISH FRY (FRIDAY ONLY)
beer battered or broiled (cajun, italian, lemon pepper, regular) served w/ fries, mac salad & coleslaw
FRENCH ONION
GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD
romaine + parmesan + garlic croutons
HOUSE SALAD
craisins + walnuts + bleu cheese + cucumbers + tomatoes + red onion + croutons + cranberry vinaigrette
SOUTHWEST CHICKEN SALAD
choice of crispy buffalo, grilled cajun chicken or taco beef + mixed greens + onion + tomato + corn + black beans + black olives + cheddar cheese served in a crispy taco shell with southwest ranch dressing
STRAWBERRY GOAT CHEESE SALAD
mixed greens + cucumber + sliced strawberries + goat cheese + walnuts + croutons