hello.food

Bagel Jay's Menu — Amherst, New York | hello.food

hello.food

hello.food
/Restaurants
/New York
/Amherst
/Bagel Jay's

Amherst, NY

Bagel Jay's

Name: Bagel Jay's
Address: 4498 Main St, Amherst, NY, 14226-3808, Amherst, NY, US

4498 Main St, Amherst, NY, 14226-3808

28 itemsUpdated March 19, 2026

Menu powered by hello.food

WheatIdentified by hello.food

Get personalized guidance in hello.food

Check any menu item against your dietary profile. Free for iOS.

Download App

hello.food

Safer food choices for dietary restrictions

Download for iOS Restaurant Owners Privacy Terms

Bagels & Cream Cheese

Baker's Dozen

DairyWheat

Baker's Dozen & Cream Cheese Bundle

DairyWheat

Brunch Box

EggsDairyWheat

Half Dozen

DairyWheat

Half Dozen & Cream Cheese Bundle

DairyWheat

Two Dozen Bagel with Cream Cheese Bundle

DairyWheat

Hot Beverages

Hot Coffee

Hot Tea

House Blend for the Group

Sides & Sweets

Blueberry Muffin

EggsDairyWheat

Chocolate Chip Cookie

EggsDairyWheat

NEW! Fruity Cereal Pop

DairyWheat

NEW! White Chocolate Egg Sugar Cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Sea Salt Kettle Chips

Twice-Baked Hash Browns

Dairy

Signature Egg Sandwiches

Bacon, Avocado, Tomato Egg White

EggsDairyWheat

Double-Stack

EggsDairyWheat

Farmhouse

EggsDairyWheat

Smokehouse Brisket

EggsDairyWheat

Sriracha Honey Sunrise

EggsDairy

Signature Lunch Sandwiches

Herby Turkey

DairyWheat

Hot Pastrami

DairyWheat

Leonardo Da Veggie

DairyWheat

Smoked Salmon

FishDairyWheat

Turkey Chipotle

DairySoyWheat

Western Brisket

Get personalized guidance in hello.food

Check any menu item against your dietary profile. Free for iOS.

Download App

Own this restaurant?

Manage your menu, review allergen data, and control your public presence on hello.food.

Claim this restaurant

Allergen information is provided as a guide and is not medical advice. Always confirm with your healthcare provider and inform restaurant staff about dietary restrictions before ordering.

Soy

Wheat

Vermonter

EggsDairyWheat

Western

EggsDairyWheat

Dairy

Wheat