Top Shelf Cookies

For the group that can't agree on anything. Except cookies Cookies Included: 🍪 Hazel's Chocolate Chip - Traditional Chocolate Chip 🍪 Black & Gold - Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips 🍪 PB Toffee Treasures - Peanut Butter Cups & Toffee Bits 🍪 Green Monster Mint - Dark Chocolate & Green Mint Chips 🍪 Raisin Healthy - Oatmeal Raisin 🍪 Boston Lager Chocolate Chip - Less Traditional Chocolate Chip 🍪 The Flood - Molasses 🍪 Cocoverdose - Triple Chocolate 🍪 PB Supremes - Peanut Butter 🍪 BSC - Basic Sugar Cookie - Sugar 🍪 OFD - Oaty, Fudgy, Delicious - Oatmeal Chocolate Chunk 🍪 HBD2U!! - Birthday Cake The whole shelf in one box. Two packs of each flavor. All twelve. That's a lot of cookies. You're welcome. Perfect for offices, nurses stations, teams, and anyone who deserves a seriously good thank you. Sending this as a gift? You can include a gift message at checkout. Please avoid express shipping if you'd like to add a message.

Some cookies rotate. These six don't. Cookies Included: 🍪 Hazel's Chocolate Chip - Traditional Chocolate Chip 🍪 Black & Gold - Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips 🍪 PB Toffee Treasures - Peanut Butter Cups & Toffee Bits 🍪 Green Monster Mint - Dark Chocolate & Green Mint Chips 🍪 Raisin Healthy - Oatmeal Raisin 🍪 Boston Lager Chocolate Chip - Less Traditional Chocolate Chip The classics, for a reason. The Original Six box includes twelve cookies — twoa of each of our six year-round flavors. These are the ones that never rotate off the menu because they never get old. It's the perfect introduction to Top Shelf Cookies, or a reliable go-to for anyone who already knows what they love. Sending this as a gift? You can include a gift message at checkout. Please avoid express shipping if you'd like to add a message.

Six cravings. Zero regrets. Cookies Included: 🍪 Hazel's Chocolate Chip - Traditional Chocolate Chip 🍪 Black & Gold - Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips 🍪 Green Monster Mint - Dark Chocolate & Green Mint Chips 🍪 PB Toffee Treasures - Peanut Butter Cups & Toffee Bits 🍪 Boston Lager Chocolate Chip - Less Traditional Chocolate Chip 🍪 OFD - Oaty, Fudgy, Delicious - Oatmeal Chocolate Chunk Six stacks. Thirty-six cookies. All crowd-pleasers. This box pulls from the best of the shelf — classics, fan favorites, and the ones people come back for. No guesswork. No filler. Just the cookies that always go first. Sending this as a gift? You can include a gift message at checkout. Please avoid express shipping if you'd like to add a message.

Stacks

When you want the fun flavors—without the guesswork. 🍪 Cookies Included 2 dozen cookies total — 4 stacks (½-dozen each) July's Baker’s Choice Flavors: 🍪 HBD2USA!! - sprinkle cookie 🍪 Toasted Marshmallow - brown sugar marshmallow 🍪 Sam Summer - citrus made with Summer Ale 🍪 JP Peach - brown sugar peach ✨ Highlights 🎁 Packaged in a gift-ready box 💌 Add a gift message at checkout 📦 Four stacks for easy sharing (or freezing!) 👩Expertly curated by our bakers 🚫 No subscription required Let the baker decide. Our Baker’s Choice Box is filled with the current month’s rotating flavors, thoughtfully curated and packed as four half-dozen stacks. Designed for variety and surprise (the good kind), this box is ideal for gifting, sharing, or sending a little cookie joy—no customization required.

Superstition Never Tasted This Good. This is where it all started. Before Top Shelf Cookies was a business, it was a superstition. Our founder Heather used to bring these cookies to The Fours — a legendary bar near Boston Garden — before every home game. That season, Boston won the championship. Coincidence? We'll let you decide. We start with unsalted butter, dark brown sugar, and granulated sugar — creamed until fully combined. Then comes dark corn syrup for texture, egg whites, and pure Madagascar vanilla, mixed until smooth. Next we fold in our signature cocoa blend — black cocoa and Dutch processed cocoa. Black cocoa is the same cocoa that gives Oreos their iconic color and depth. It's bold, rich, and unmistakably dark. Then comes our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, and just enough salt to even things out. Finally, we load in peanut butter chips until every scoop is packed. Each cookie is hand-scooped, rolled in sugar, and baked to a crackled, chewy finish — the cookie that started it all. Duck boats optional. Cookie required. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep the winning streak going Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Peanut Butter Chips, Corn Syrup, Brown Sugar, Cocoa, Eggs, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Salt

Craft Your Dream Treat Box! Introducing the Build Your Own Cookie Box, where you can select from 12 delicious flavors to create the ultimate cookie experience! Perfect as a gift or for treating yourself, this customizable box lets you mix and match your favorite Top Shelf Cookies. Opt for a subscription to receive your chosen flavors every 2, 4, or 6 weeks, and enjoy the convenience of our customer portal, which allows you to easily pause or skip your subscription whenever needed. Delight in a variety of cookies delivered right to your door! You can include a gift message on the cart screen, please do not use express checkout options if you want to include a gift message

Two delicious takes on a classic—Chocolate Chip, elevated. Cookies Included 🍪 Hazel’s Chocolate Chip – Brown butter dough with rich dark chocolate🍪 Boston Lager Chocolate Chip – A Boston twist made with Sam Adams Boston Lager Enjoy the best of our chocolate chip lineup with the Chocolate Chippy Box, featuring two stacks of each flavor. Each box includes four stacks of 1/2 dozen cookies, baked fresh and carefully packed for gifting. Perfect for chocolate chip lovers, beer fans, or anyone who appreciates a classic done right. Sending this as a gift?You can include a gift message during checkout. Please avoid express checkout if you want to add a message. Baked fresh in Boston and shipped nationwide.

Three Cocoas. Three Chocolates. Zero Regrets. We start with unsalted butter, dark brown sugar, and granulated sugar — creamed together until smooth and caramel-forward. Dark corn syrup goes in next for texture, along with egg whites and pure Madagascar vanilla, mixed until fully combined. Then we fold in our triple cocoa blend — black cocoa, Dutch processed cocoa, and natural cocoa — creating a deep, layered chocolate flavor that's bold from the first bite. A touch of espresso powder intensifies it even further. Then comes our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, and just enough kosher salt to balance the sweetness. Finally, we fold in dark, semi-sweet, and milk chocolate chips — three kinds, because one was never going to be enough. Each cookie is hand-scooped, rolled in sugar, and baked to a soft, chewy finish. Three cocoas. Three chocolates. Zero regrets. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and feed the obsession 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep the chocolate coming Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Chocolate Chips, Corn Syrup, Brown Sugar, Cocoa, Eggs, Vanilla, Espresso, Baking Soda, Salt

Hit a flavor home run with every minty bite! A tribute to Boston's most iconic landmark — in cookie form. We start with unsalted butter, dark brown sugar, and granulated sugar — creamed until fully combined. Then comes dark corn syrup for texture and egg whites and pure Madagascar vanilla, mixed until smooth. Next we fold in our signature cocoa blend — black cocoa and Dutch processed cocoa — bold, rich, and unmistakably dark. Then comes our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, and just enough kosher salt to even things out. Finally, we load in green mint chips until every scoop is packed with color and cool, minty flavor. Each cookie is hand-scooped, rolled in sugar, and baked to a crackled, chewy finish — dark chocolate and mint, Boston style. Every bite, a home run. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep the home runs coming Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Green Mint Chips, Dark Corn Syrup, Dark Brown Sugar, Sugar, Egg Whites, Black Cocoa, Dutch Process Cocoa, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Kosher Salt

Chocolate Chip, Elevated. This one's personal. Hazel was our founder Heather's grandmother — the woman who first put a wooden spoon in her hand and taught her that baking is about so much more than the recipe. It's about the person standing next to you. We start by browning our butter until it's rich, nutty, and deeply fragrant — then cream it together with light brown sugar and a touch of granulated sugar until thoroughly combined. Cage-free eggs, egg yolks, and pure Madagascar vanilla go in next, mixed until silky smooth and caramel-forward. Then comes our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, and just enough kosher salt to round it all out. And finally, dark Belgian Callebaut chocolate — because Hazel deserves nothing less. Each cookie is hand-scooped and baked to golden perfection. A classic, elevated. Just like she always knew we could be. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep the tradition going Ingredients: Flour, Brown Sugar, Chocolate Chips, Butter, Sugar, Eggs, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Salt

A cookie gift box that turns any day into a birthday celebration! Cookies Included 🍪 HBD2U!!! – Birthday Cake🍪 Hazel's Chocolate Chip – Chocolate Chip🍪 Black & Gold – Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips Celebrate birthdays the sweet way.The HBD2U!! Box includes two dozen cookies: two stacks of our festive Birthday Cake flavor, plus stacks of Hazel’s Chocolate Chip and Black & Gold. It’s the perfect cookie gift for birthdays, celebrations, and surprise treats. Sending this as a gift?You can include a gift message during checkout. Please avoid express checkout if you'd like to add a message.

Born in Dorchester, baked with love We start with unsalted butter, light brown sugar, and granulated sugar — creamed together until perfectly smooth, building a deep, caramel-forward base. Cage-free eggs, egg yolks, and pure Madagascar vanilla go in next, mixed until fully combined and rich. Then we fold in organic rolled oats, followed by our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, and just enough kosher salt to balance the sweetness. Finally, we load in dark chocolate chunks until every scoop is packed. Each cookie is hand-scooped, chilled, and soft-baked to a chewy, hearty finish — inspired by Dorchester and rooted in comfort. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep a little Dorchester coming Ingredients: Dark Chocolate Chunks, Light Brown Sugar, Flour, Butter, Rolled Oats, Sugar, Eggs, Egg Yolks, Vanilla, Kosher Salt, Baking Soda

Brown Butter, Peanut Butter Cups & Toffee Walk Into a Cookie. We start by browning our butter until it's rich, nutty, and deeply fragrant — then cream it together with light brown sugar and granulated sugar until smooth and caramel-forward. Cage-free eggs, egg yolks, and pure Madagascar vanilla go in next, mixed until fully combined. Then comes our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, and just enough salt to even things out. Finally, we fold in mini peanut butter cups and crushed toffee until every scoop is loaded with both. Each cookie is hand-scooped and baked to a chewy, golden finish — one of our most popular flavors, and for good reason. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep the treasures coming Ingredients: Flour, Brown Sugar, Butter, Sugar, Eggs Peanut Butter Cups, Toffee, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Salt

Raisin the Bar on Healthy-ish We start with unsalted butter, light brown sugar, and granulated sugar — creamed together until perfectly smooth. Cage-free eggs go in next, mixed until fully combined. Then we fold in organic rolled oats, followed by our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, a touch of ground nutmeg, and just enough kosher salt to round it all out. Finally, plump, fresh raisins get mixed in until every scoop is loaded. Each cookie is hand-scooped and soft-baked to a chewy, golden finish. The healthiest cookie we make. Don't tell the others. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep raisin the bar Ingredients: Rolled Oats, Butter, Flour, Raisin, Brown Sugar, Sugar, Eggs, Baking Powder, Nutmeg, Salt

Boston's Stickiest Story — Now in Cookie Form. In 1919, a wave of molasses flooded the streets of Boston's North End. It was, by all accounts, a disaster. We turned it into a cookie. We start with unsalted butter and granulated sugar — creamed together until perfectly smooth. Cage-free eggs and rich molasses go in next, mixed together until fully combined and deeply fragrant. Then comes our dry mix — Vermont's own King Arthur flour, our custom blend of leaveners, and just enough salt to even things out — along with a warm blend of ground cinnamon, cloves, ginger, and nutmeg that gives this cookie its signature spice. Each cookie is hand-scooped and baked to a soft, chewy finish — rich, spiced, and unmistakably Boston. Boston's Stickiest Story — Now in Cookie Form. 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks ✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep the story going 🍪 Sold in ½ dozen stacks✨ Always in our jar—subscribe and keep it coming Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Molasses, Eggs, Baking Soda, Cinnamon, Cloves, Ginger, Salt, Nutmeg

Send someone the ultimate cookie gift. Perfect for birthdays, thank-yous, celebrations, or just because. The Top Shelf Cookies Sampler features a delicious variety of our most popular cookies, baked fresh in Boston and shipped nationwide. It’s the perfect way to celebrate birthdays, say thank you, or send a sweet surprise. Small1 dozen cookies • minimum 6 flavors Medium2 dozen cookies • minimum 8 flavors Large3 dozen cookies • minimum 12 flavors Sending this as a gift?You can include a gift message during checkout. Please avoid express checkout if you want to add a message. Baked fresh in Boston and shipped nationwide.

Top Shelf’s most beloved cookie flavors, all in one easy-to-send gift box. Cookies Included 🍪 Hazel’s Chocolate Chip – Chocolate Chip🍪 Black & Gold – Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips🍪 PB Toffee Treasures – Peanut Butter Cups & Toffee Bits🍪 Green Monster Mint – Dark Chocolate & Green Mint Chips Enjoy the best of our bakery with the Year Round Faves Box, featuring four of our most beloved cookies. Each box includes four stacks of 1/2 dozen cookies, carefully selected to satisfy any sweet tooth. Sending this as a gift?You can include a gift message during checkout. Please avoid express checkout if you want to add a message. Baked fresh in Boston and shipped nationwide.