Bridge Sticks
$9.00Breadsticks baked with Italian herbs and cheese. Add sides of marinara or ranch.
Old Sturbridge Pizza & Restaurant
Sturbridge, MA
392 Main St, Sturbridge, MA, 01566-108379 itemsUpdated March 19, 2026
Structured menu data
Appetizers
Cauliflower
$7.00Fried cauliflower with lemon and capers
Chicken Wings
$13.00Ten wings served with carrot and celery sticks. Choice of buffalo, BBQ, teriyaki or rotating seasonal flavor. Add carrot & celery sticks and sides of ranch or bleu cheese.
Meatballs
$9.00Three housemade meatballs, marinara, parmesan, and fresh basil.
Pesto Sticks
$13.00Housemade basil pesto added to our bridge sticks. Add sides of marinara or ranch.
Create Your Own Pizza
Base Pizza - 12"
$11.00Base price includes choice of sauce and our pizza cheese blend.
Base Pizza - 16"
$15.00Base price includes choice of sauce and our pizza cheese blend.
Cheese Toppings - 12"
$2.00Gorgonzola, Goat Cheese, Feta, Ricotta, Fresh Mozzarella
Cheese Toppings - 16"
$4.00Gorgonzola, Goat Cheese, Feta, Ricotta, Fresh Mozzarella
Extras - 12"
$2.00Crushed Walnut, Sunflower Seed, Chili Oil, Spicy Wustner Brothers Honey, Balsamic Reduction, Romesco
Extras - 16"
$4.00Crushed Walnut, Sunflower Seed, Chili Oil, Spicy Wustner Brothers Honey, Balsamic Reduction, Romesco
Gluten Free Dough - 12"
$5.00Please note that these pizzas are cooked in the same kitchen and oven as our other pizzas. Therefore they may not be suitable for some individuals.
Meat Toppings - 12"
$2.50Housemade Sausage, Chicken, Prosciutto, Made-From-Scratch Meatball, Crispy Chicken, Thick Cut Bacon, Sopressata, Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Anchovy, Cupping Pepperoni
Meat Toppings - 16"
$5.00Housemade Sausage, Chicken, Prosciutto, Made-From-Scratch Meatball, Crispy Chicken, Thick Cut Bacon, Sopressata, Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Anchovy, Cupping Pepperoni
Premium Vegetable Toppings - 12"
$2.00Pineapple-Jalapeno Chutney, Pickled Pepper, Artichoke Heart, Pepperoncini, Sun-Dried Tomato, Caramelized Onion, Calabrian Chili, Garlic Confit, Caper, Kalamata Olive, Green Olive
Premium Vegetable Toppings - 16"
$4.00Pineapple-Jalapeno Chutney, Pickled Pepper, Artichoke Heart, Pepperoncini, Sun-Dried Tomato, Caramelized Onion, Calabrian Chili, Garlic Confit, Caper, Kalamata Olive, Green Olive
Desserts
Brownie with Walnut
$3.50Made from scratch
Carrot Cake with Walnut and Raisin
$4.50Made from scratch
Cookie
$2.00Oatmeal chocolate chip, peanut butter m&m, ginger molasses, and snickerdoodle.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Rice Krispies Bar
$3.50Made from scratch
Pasta
Casarecce Pesto - Large
$16.00Casarecce pasta tossed in housemade pesto with Parmesan. Try adding roasted chicken.
Casarecce Pesto - Small
$9.00Casarecce pasta tossed in housemade pesto with Parmesan. Try adding roasted chicken.
Fettuccini Alfredo - Large
$16.00Classic creamy fettuccini alfredo with parmesan and garlic. Try adding roasted chicken.
Fettuccini Alfredo - Small
$9.00Classic creamy fettuccini alfredo with parmesan and garlic. Try adding roasted chicken.
Gluten Free Pasta Substitute - Large
$4.00Substitute gluten free pasta
Gluten Free Pasta Substitute - Small
$2.00Substitute gluten free pasta
Orecchiete with Mushrooms - Large
$17.50A blend of portobello, crimini, button and oyster mushrooms with rosemary in a white wine sauce, toasted pine nut and pecorino.
Orecchiete with Mushrooms - Small
$10.00A blend of portobello, crimini, button and oyster mushrooms with rosemary in a white wine sauce, toasted pine nut and pecorino.
Orecchiette with Italian Sausage - Large
$16.00Housemade italian sausage, arugula, chopped tomato, garlic, olive oil and pecorino.
Orecchiette with Italian Sausage - Small
$9.00Housemade italian sausage, arugula, chopped tomato, garlic, olive oil and pecorino.
Spaghetti Marinara - Large
$12.50Classic tomato sauce topped with parmesan and pecorino.
Spaghetti Marinara - Small
$7.00Classic tomato sauce topped with parmesan and pecorino.
Spaghetti Meatball - Large
$17.50Our made-from-scratch meatball simmered in marinara. With fresh grated parmesan and pecorino.
Spaghetti Meatball - Small
$10.00Our made-from-scratch meatball simmered in marinara. With fresh grated parmesan and pecorino.
Spaghetti with Chicken Piccata - Large
$17.50Roasted chicken with mushroom, shallot, garlic, onion, caper, fresh basil, lemon, cream and white wine with parmesan.
Spaghetti with Chicken Piccata - Small
$10.00Roasted chicken with mushroom, shallot, garlic, onion, caper, fresh basil, lemon, cream and white wine with parmesan.
Pizza
York - 12"
$15.00Housemade tomato jam, baby kale, pickled red onion, and goat cheese on red.
York - 16"
$22.00Housemade tomato jam, baby kale, pickled red onion, and goat cheese on red.
Pizza by The Slice
Pizza by The Slice
Pepperoni, plain cheese, and two other daily slices.
Salads
Arugula Salad - Large
$13.50Arugula, goat cheese, pickled pepper, roasted garlic, pumpkin seed and Italian.
Arugula Salad - Small
$9.00Arugula, goat cheese, pickled pepper, roasted garlic, pumpkin seed and Italian.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
$15.00Romaine, buffalo chicken tender, celery, carrot, gorgonzola, green onion, and ranch.
Caesar Salad - Large
$11.00Romaine, freshly grated parmesan, housemade crouton, and caesar.
Caesar Salad - Small
$7.00Romaine, freshly grated parmesan, housemade crouton, and caesar.
Greek Salad - Large
$12.00Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olive, feta, green onion and Italian.
Greek Salad - Small
$8.00Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olive, feta, green onion and Italian.
House Salad - Large
$11.00Mixed greens, tomato, carrot, cucumber, and sunflower seed. Choice of Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, poppy seed, caesar or lemon vinaigrette.
House Salad - Small
$7.00Mixed greens, tomato, carrot, cucumber, and sunflower seed. Choice of Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, poppy seed, caesar or lemon vinaigrette.
Kale Salad - Large
$12.00Baby kale, roasted beet, pickled red onion, pecorino, pumpkin seed, and lemon vinaigrette.
Kale Salad - Small
$8.00Baby kale, roasted beet, pickled red onion, pecorino, pumpkin seed, and lemon vinaigrette.
Roasted or Crispy Chicken Add-On
$5.00Add roasted or crispy chicken to any salad
Spinach Salad - Large
$12.00Baby spinach, sun-dried tomato, gorgonzola, apple, candied walnut, and poppy seed.
Spinach Salad - Small
$8.00Baby spinach, sun-dried tomato, gorgonzola, apple, candied walnut, and poppy seed.
Sandwiches
Chicken & Bacon
$10.00Chicken, thick-cut bacon, arugula, fresh mozzarella, lemon aioli, tomato, and red onion.
Meatball & Basil
$10.00Made-from-scratch meatball, pepperoni, tomato, basil, provolone, red onion, and marinara.
Open-Faced Meatball
$9.50Housemade meatballs, marinara and provolone baked in the oven.
Signature Pizzas
Buckhouse - 12"
$17.00Pepperoni, housemade sausage, red onion, black olive and bell pepper on red.
Buckhouse - 16"
$24.00Pepperoni, housemade sausage, red onion, black olive and bell pepper on red.
Diavolo - 12"
$17.00Chicken, green olive, calabrian chili and fresh mozzarella on red.
Diavolo - 16"
$24.00Chicken, green olive, calabrian chili and fresh mozzarella on red.
Higgins Ave. - 12"
$14.00Crushed walnut, gorgonzola and red onion on white.
Higgins Ave. - 16"
$21.00Crushed walnut, gorgonzola and red onion on white.
London - 12"
$17.00Portobello, crimini, button and oyster mushroom. Roasted with fresh rosemary on white.
London - 16"
$24.00Portobello, crimini, button and oyster mushroom. Roasted with fresh rosemary on white.
Maclay - 12"
$16.00Crispy chicken, red onion, gorgonzola, celery and buffalo sauce on bbq.
Maclay - 16"
$23.00Crispy chicken, red onion, gorgonzola, celery and buffalo sauce on bbq.
Madison - 12"
$13.00Prosciutto and housemade pineapple-jalapeño chutney on white.
Madison - 16"
$20.00Prosciutto and housemade pineapple-jalapeño chutney on white.
Messina - 12"
$16.00Pickled pepper, ricotta, sopressata and fresh basil on organic crushed tomato.
Messina - 16"
$23.00Pickled pepper, ricotta, sopressata and fresh basil on organic crushed tomato.
Orange St. - 12"
$15.00Feta, romesco, artichoke heart and fresh basil on white.
Orange St. - 16"
$22.00Feta, romesco, artichoke heart and fresh basil on white.
Rialto - 12"
$16.00Housemade sausage, caramelized onion and goat cheese on organic crushed tomato.
Rialto - 16"
$23.00Housemade sausage, caramelized onion and goat cheese on organic crushed tomato.
Russell St. - 12"
$16.00Thick cut bacon, chicken, red onion, and pineapple on bbq.
Russell St. - 16"
$23.00Thick cut bacon, chicken, red onion, and pineapple on bbq.
Whitaker - 12"
$17.00Pesto cream, garlic confit, cauliflower and goat cheese
Whitaker - 16"
$24.00Pesto cream, garlic confit, cauliflower and goat cheese
Soup
Soup
$8.0014 oz bowl made from scratch by Team Bridge.