Oatmeal Cream Pie
$4.99Oatmeal cookies with vanilla ice cream.
Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe
Salem, MA
181 Fort Ave, Salem, MA, 01970-574112 itemsUpdated March 19, 2026
Structured menu data
Homemade Treats
Ice Cream
Brown Sugar Cookie Dough
$12.99Brown sugar ice cream with cookie dough and chocolate chips.
Caramel Pretzel
$12.99Caramel ice cream with chocolate-covered pretzels.
Chocolate
$12.99Rich chocolate ice cream.
Chocolate Orange Flambé
$12.99Chocolate ice cream with orange swirl and chocolate flakes.
Coffee Toffee
$12.99Coffee ice cream with toffee pieces.
Holy Cow
$12.99Vanilla ice cream with caramel swirl and chocolate chips.
Mint Chip
$12.99Mint ice cream with chocolate chips.
Salty Malty
$12.99Malted vanilla ice cream with chocolate-covered pretzels.
Vanilla
$12.99Classic vanilla ice cream.
Non-Dairy
Dark Chocolate Sorbet
$12.99Rich dark chocolate sorbet.
Gluten-Free
$12.99Non-dairy vanilla ice cream.