Sauce on the Side

Carmel, IN

12751 N Pennsylvania St, Carmel, IN, 46032-9181
32 itemsUpdated August 7, 2026
Structured menu data

Featured Drafts and Local Beers

Ask about our featured drafts and local beers

Red and White Wines

Check out our selection of red and white wines

Buffalo Chicken

$8.29

Chipotle Garlic Ranch

Pepperoni Basil

$8.29

House Red

Spinach Artichoke

$8.29

Queso Pesto

14 Gyro Anniversary

Greek Meatballs (Lamb and Beef, no Pork), Fontina, Feta, Cucumber, Red Onion, Roma Tomato and Green Olives. Served with Tzatziki sauce.

Bull's Eye

$12.79

Marinated Steak, Spinach, Garlic Mushrooms, Balsamic Onions, Garlic Herb Cheese, Fontina, Garlic Oil

Carmen

$11.79

Prosciutto, Capicola, Spinach, Parmesan, Fontina, Ricotta, Garlic Oil

Cock-A-Doodle Noodle

$12.29

As seen on the Travel Channel's Food Paradise! Mac 'n Cheese, Roasted Chicken, Applewood Bacon, STL Style Cheese, Mozzarella, Green Onion, Garlic Oil

Costanza

$11.79

Pepperoni, Eggplant, Roasted Garlic Puree, Basil, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Garlic Honey Oil

Duke

$12.29

BBQ Chicken, Applewood Bacon, Corn Salsa, Smoked Cheddar, Mozzarella, Smoked Chili Oil

Fatty B

$11.79

Pepperoni, Meatballs, White Onion, Provolone, Roasted Garlic Puree, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Garlic Oil

Figgy Piggy

$12.29

Applewood Bacon, Figs, Balsamic Onions, Garlic Herb Cheese, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Garlic Honey Oil

Five-O

$11.79

Prosciutto, Pineapple, Red Peppers, Smoked Cheddar, Mozzarella, Mascarpone-Ricotta Blend, Smoked Chili Oil

Gonzo

$11.79

Salami, Dates, Spinach, Garlic Herb Cheese, Mozzarella, Mascarpone-Ricotta Blend, Garlic Oil

Hot Mother Clucker

$12.29

Buffalo Chicken, Applewood Bacon, Red Onions, Fontina, Bleu Cheese, Mozzarella, Smoked Chili Oil

Magic Carpet Ride

$11.79

Crimini, Button, Portabella & Shiitake Mushrooms, Roasted Garlic Puree, Parmesan, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Garlic Honey Oil

Meat Me in St. Louie

$11.79

Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, STL Style Cheese, Mascarpone-Ricotta Blend, Garlic Oil

Pancho Villa

$11.79

Chorizo, Fresh Jalapeños, Red Peppers, Smoked Cheddar, Mozzarella, Smoked Chili Oil

Roasty Toasty

$11.79

Pesto Chicken, Arugula, Red Onion, Pine Nuts, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Garlic Oil

Skinny V (Vegan!)

$12.79

Vegan Pepperoni, Green Peppers, White Onions, Roasted Garlic Puree, Vegan Mozzarella, Garlic Oil

The Fold (Create Your Own)

$8.29

Start with: Mozzarella, Ricotta, Garlic Oil. Add fillers and your choice of sauce. Protein $1.99 ea, Fillers $1.39 ea, Cheese $1.79 ea, Sauce $1.39 ea

Which Came First...?

$12.29

Roasted Chicken, Applewood Bacon, Fresh Jalapeños, Egg Yolk, White Onion, Mozzarella, Smoked Chili Oil

Caramel Apple Pie

$10.89

Hot Cinnamon Apples with Crunchy Graham Crackers and a Crumbly Cinnamon Crust, Finished with a Caramel Sauce

Mini Caramel Apple Pie

$7.89

Hot Cinnamon Apples with Crunchy Graham Crackers and a Crumbly Cinnamon Crust, Finished with a Caramel Sauce

Mini S'mores

$7.89

Crunchy Graham Crackers with Marshmallows and Chocolate Chips, Finished with Chocolate Syrup, Marshmallows and Chocolate Chips

S'mores

$10.89

Crunchy Graham Crackers with Marshmallows and Chocolate Chips, Finished with Chocolate Syrup, Marshmallows and Chocolate Chips

Beets Me!

Arugula, Spring Mix, Toasted Walnuts, Mandarin Oranges, Golden Beets, Red Onions, Parmesan Cheese, Citrus Vinaigrette

Caesar

Romaine Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese, Pesto Croutons, Red Onions, Caesar Dressing

Smokehouse

Butter Lettuce, Corn Salsa, Applewood Bacon, Smoked Cheddar, Pear Tomatoes, Basil, BBQ Ranch Dressing

Strawberry Fields

Spring Mix, Strawberries, Feta, Red Onion, Sage, Mint, Candied Walnuts, White Balsamic Vinaigrette

The Italian

Romaine Lettuce, Salami, Artichoke Hearts, Mozzarella, Green Olives, Roasted Red Peppers, Basil, Pear Tomatoes, Rosemary Vinaigrette