Beer Battered Onion Rings
Petal Dipping Sauce Half $5.99 | Full $8.99
New Bethel Ordinary
Indianapolis, IN
8838 E Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis, IN, 46239-134163 itemsUpdated March 19, 2026
Structured menu data
Appetizers
Breaded Mushrooms
$8.99Ranch
Breadsticks
Nacho Cheese, Pizza Sauce, Garlic Butter Half $3.99 | Full $6.99
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Garlic Toast, Mozzarella, Pizza Sauce Half $4.99 | Full $7.99
Chicken Strips
$9.99Hand Breaded or Grilled, Choice of Sauce
Fried Cauliflower
$8.99Ranch
Fried Ravioli
$10.99Marinara
Loaded Fries
$11.99Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream
Mozzarella Sticks
$8.99Marinara
New Bethel Nachos
$10.99Tortilla Chips, White Queso, BBQ Sauce, Pico, Guacamole, Sour Cream Pulled Pork or Grilled Chicken - add $3.00 Brisket - add $4.00
Potato Skins
$11.99Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream
Pretzel Bites
$9.99Nacho Cheese
Quesadilla
$8.99Traditional, BBQ, Buffalo Pico, Jalapeno, Lettuce, Salsa Pulled Pork or Grilled Chicken - add $3.00 Brisket or Chipotle Beef - add $4.00
Tenderloin Strips
$10.99Hand-Breaded or Grilled, Horseradish Sauce, Ranch
Beverages
Coffee
$1.99Iced Tea
$3.49Milk
$3.4916oz
O.J.
$3.4916oz
Pepsi Products
$3.49Burgers
Bacon Bleu Burger
$12.99Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles
Build Your Own Burger
$10.99Cheeses: $0.99 each American | Swiss | Cheddar | Pepper Jack Toppings: $1.25 each Jalapeno | Grilled Onions | Grilled Mushrooms Bacon | Bleu Cheese Crumbles
Patty Melt
$12.99Marble Rye, Sautéed Onions, Swiss, 1000 Island
Shroom Burger
$12.99Sautéed Mushrooms, Swiss
Texas BBQ Burger
$12.99Cheddar, Bacon, BBQ Sauce, Onion Ring
Desserts
Bread Pudding
$4.99Cinnamon Sauce
Brownie Ala Mode
$5.99Brownie, Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Syrup
Kids Menu
7-Inch Cheese Pizza
$6.99Additional Toppings $0.25
Chicken Fingers
$6.99With fries
Grilled Cheese
$6.99With fries
Mini Corn Dogs
$6.99With fries
Pizza
BBQ Chicken
Grilled Chicken, Red Onion, BBQ Sauce 10 inch $15.99 | 12 inch $17.99 | 16 inch $21.99
Cheese Pizza
Build Your Own 10 inch $13.99 | 12 inch $14.99 | 16 inch $18.99
Deluxe
Pepperoni,, Sausage, Ham, Mushroom, Black Olives, Green Pepper, Onion 10 inch $17.99 | 12 inch $20.99 | 16 inch $26.99
Hawaiian
Ham, Pineapple, BBQ Sauce 10 inch $15.99 | 12 inch $17.99 | 16 inch $21.99
Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Italian Sausage, Bacon 10 inch $17.99 | 12 inch $20.99 | 16 inch $26.99
Sandwiches
Beef Brisket Sandwich
$12.99House-Smoked Brisket. Side of BBQ Sauce
Chicken Sandwich
$11.99Hand Breaded or Grilled
Chicken Wrap
$12.99Hand Breaded or Grilled, Pico, Lettuce, Cheese, Chipotle Sauce
Cuban Sandwich
$14.99Ham, Pulled Pork, Mustard, Pickle, Hoagie Bun
Fish Sandwich
$10.99Hand-Breaded Haddock
Grilled Ham & Cheese
$10.99Smoked Pit Ham. Choice of Cheese And Bread
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$11.99House-Smoked Pork, Side of BBQ Sauce
Tenderloin
$11.99Pork Loin, Hand Breaded or Grilled
Texas Toast BLT
$10.99Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Texas Toast
Sides
Apple Sauce
$2.99Cole Slaw
$2.99Cottage Cheese
$2.99Fries
$2.99Green Beans
$2.99Potato Salad
$2.99Soups & Salads
Chef Salad
$12.99Ham, Turkey, Egg, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomato, Croutons
Chicken Caesar Salad
$12.99Grilled Chicken, Parmesan, Croutons
Chicken Salad
$12.99Hand Breaded or Grilled, Cheddar, Bacon, Tomato, Croutons
Chili
Cup $2.99 | Bowl $5.99
Ham & Bean Soup
Cup $2.50 | Bowl $4.99
Side Salad
$4.99House or Caesar
Wedge Salad
$9.99Iceberg Wedge, Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Red Onion, Tomato, Bleu Cheese Dressing
Tacos
BBQ Pulled Pork
$9.99House Smoked Pork, BBQ Rub, Cheese, Pico, BBQ Sauce
Boom Boom Shrimp
$10.99Breaded Popcorn Shrimp, Lettuce, Pico, Boom Boom Sauce
Bourbon Cola Brisket
$10.99House Smoked Brisket, Shredded Pepper Jack Pickled Red Onion, Bourbon Cola Sauce
Spicy Chicken
$9.99Hand Breaded or Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Pico, Chipotle Sauce, Bonfire Rub
Wings
Boneless Wings
10 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery. 1/2 Lb. $8.99 | Full Lb. $15.99
Traditional Bone in Wings
$12.9910 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery.