Cheese Bites
Single serving of protein
Long John Silver's
New Castle, IN
520 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN, 47362-491013 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
Add-a Piece & Extras
Baskets For 1
Battered Shrimp Basket
Your seafood favorite, complete with one side
Combos W/Drinks
2pc Fish Combo
Choice of Individual Side, 20oz Drink
Desserts
Oreo Cheesecake
Slices from Cheesecake Factory Bakery®
Drinks
Pepsi
A selection of sodas, iced tea, and other thirst-quenching beverages
Family & Group Meals
4 Sandwich Bundle
Excellent for crews of 4 or more
Featured Items
Battered Shrimp
Explore our specials and online exclusives!
Kids Meals
Kids Fish Meal
Meals for small pirates
Meals For 1
2pc Fish Meal
Choice of 2 Individual Sides and 2 hushpuppies
Platters For 1
Variety Platter
A mix of seafood favorites, complete with sides
Sauces
Tartar Sauce
Topping and dipping Sauces
Sides
Macaroni and Cheese with Crumblies
Choose from a variety of sides in individual or large sizes
Wraps, Tacos, Sandwiches & Bowls
Baja Chicken Wrap
Perfectly portable seafood favorites