Cookie Plug

Indianapolis, IN

646 E Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN, 46204-1607
24 itemsUpdated October 6, 2026
Structured menu data

Allergen terms are identified from menu descriptions.

Purple Drank

Purple lemonade

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Stacks of thick, warm chocolate chip cookies

EggsDairyWheat

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

A thick stack of oatmeal raisin cookies that are sliced open

EggsDairyWheat

Smores Cookie

Firecracker Cookie - Smores cookie recipe

EggsDairyWheat

Sugar Cookie

Bomb sugar cookie recipe

EggsDairyWheat

Iced Up

Try All 12 Flavors Iced up

EggsDairyWheat

Caked Up Custom Cookie Cakes

Decorated or plain custom cookie cakes for birthdays

EggsDairyWheat

Bart Keto Cookie

Keto Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie

EggsDairyPeanutsWheat

Black Magic Keto Cookie

Keto Chocolate Cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Calvin Keto Cookie

Keto Snickerdoodle Cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Kitt Keto Cookie

Keto Chocolate Chip Cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Plug Poppers Mini Cookies

Try All 12 Flavors With Our Plug Cookie Poppers

EggsDairyPeanutsWheat

Azucar Blanca Cookie

Mexican Sugar Cookie - Thick stacks of pink and brown cookies with sugar crystallization

EggsDairyWheat

Choc Rock Cookie

A thick stack of four chocolate cookies with nuts

EggsDairyTree NutsWheat

Cookie Cookie Cream Cookie

Chocolate marshmallow cream cookie stack of three cookies

EggsDairyWheat

Crunch Nugget Cookie

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie - Thick Cookie Plug Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies

EggsDairyPeanutsWheat

Good Luv Cookie

Red Velvet Cake Cookie - Thick stack of four red velvet cake cookies with white chocolate chips

EggsDairyWheat

O.G. Cookie

Original chocolate chip cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Oh Snap Cookie

Apple Pie Cookie - Thick stacks of 4 cookies cut in half with oatmeal and apple pieces

EggsDairyWheat

Pink Elephant Cookie

Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Pixie Junkie Cookie

Sugar cookie recipe specialty

EggsDairyWheat

Purple Haze Cookie

Purple Cookie With White Chocolate Chips

EggsDairyWheat

Snooperdoodle Cookie

Cinnamon Snickerdoodle Cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Wheat Roller Cookie

Wheat-based cookie

EggsDairyWheat

Allergen information is provided as a guide and is not medical advice. Always confirm with your healthcare provider and inform restaurant staff about dietary restrictions before ordering.