Pie, Pie My Darling
Chicago, IL
2636 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL, 6062273 itemsUpdated August 5, 2026
Structured menu data
Allergen terms are identified from menu descriptions.
Beverages
Cake Slices
Cookies & Cream
August cake slice flavor of the month
EggsDairyWheat
Cookies & Cream Cake Slice
$11.00DairyWheat
Ghostess Cake Slice
$12.00DairyWheat
Ghostess Cake Slices
EggsDairyWheat
Key Lime Cake Slice
$11.00July cake slice flavor of the month, available through 8-1
DairyWheat
Cakes
All Black Everything Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
All Black Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake available in 6" babycake or 8" full size
Wheat
Banana Split Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Birthday Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Biscoff Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Black & Orange Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake available in 6" babycake or 8" full size
Wheat
Black & Red Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake available in 6" babycake or 8" full size
Wheat
Black Coffin Cake
Vegan coffin-shaped cake
Wheat
Brown Sugar Peach Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
PeanutsWheat
Chocolate Pistachio Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Tree NutsWheat
Chocolate Rainbow Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Chocolate Sprinkle Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Coconut Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Cookie Monster Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Double Chocolate Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Fauxstess Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Goth Rainbow Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Goth Rainbow Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake
Wheat
Goth Rainbow Sprinkle Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Key Lime Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Lemon Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Lemon Strawberry Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Nutter Butter Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
PeanutsWheat
Pink Coffin Cake
Vegan coffin-shaped cake
Wheat
Pink Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake available in 6" babycake or 8" full size
Wheat
Rainbow Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Rainbow Sprinkle Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake
Wheat
Raspberry Pistachio Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Tree NutsWheat
Red Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake available in 6" babycake or 8" full size
Wheat
Red Velvet Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
S'mores Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Spider Web Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake available in 6" babycake or 8" full size
Wheat
Strawberry Streusel Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Trans is Beautiful Sprinkle Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
Vanilla Sprinkle Cake
Vegan cake available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen
Wheat
White Heart Cake
Vegan heart-shaped cake available in 6" babycake or 8" full size
Wheat
Cookies & Treats
Oatmeal Cream Pie
$8.00EggsDairyWheat
Oatmeal Cream Pies
EggsDairyWheat
Raspberry Bat Linzer Cookie
$7.00EggsDairyWheat
Raspberry Linzer Cookies
EggsDairyWheat
Salted Chocolate Chip Cookie
$5.00DairyWheat
Salted Chocolate Chip Cookies
EggsDairyWheat
Sprinkle Rice Crispy Treat
$7.00EggsWheat
Sprinkle Rice Crispy Treats
DairyWheat
Strawberry Rice Crispy Treat
$8.00EggsWheat
Strawberry Rice Crispy Treats
DairyWheat
Cupcakes
Banana Split Cupcake
$9.00EggsDairyWheat
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cupcake
$9.00EggsDairyWheat
Cookie Monster Cupcake
$9.00Available year round
EggsDairyWheat
Key Lime Cupcake
$9.00EggsDairyWheat
Lemon Boo-Berry Cupcake
$9.00EggsDairyWheat
Ice Cream
Vaca's Creamery Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pint
$12.00EggsDairyWheat
Vaca's Creamery Millionaire's Shortbread Ice Cream Pint
$12.00EggsDairyWheat
Vaca's Creamery Strawberry Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint
$12.00Dairy
Vaca's Creamery Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint
$12.00Sold out
Dairy
Vacas Creamery Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pint
$12.00Sold out
Dairy
Signature Cup-Cakes
Banana Split
16oz cup filled with scratch baked cake crumbs and frosting
EggsDairyWheat
Chocolate Strawberry
16oz cup filled with scratch baked cake crumbs and frosting
EggsDairyWheat
Cookie Monster
16oz cup filled with scratch baked cake crumbs and frosting. Available year round
EggsDairyWheat
Key Lime
16oz cup filled with scratch baked cake crumbs and frosting
EggsDairyWheat
Lemon Boo-Berry
16oz cup filled with scratch baked cake crumbs and frosting
EggsDairyWheat
Vegan Ice Cream Pints
Cookie Dough
Vaca's Creamery vegan ice cream pint
Tree Nuts
Millionare's Shortbread
Vaca's Creamery vegan ice cream pint
Wheat
Strawberry Olive Oil
Vaca's Creamery vegan ice cream pint
Vanilla Bean
Vaca's Creamery vegan ice cream pint
Allergen information is provided as a guide and is not medical advice. Always confirm with your healthcare provider and inform restaurant staff about dietary restrictions before ordering.