12x15 Ice Cream Sheet-cake
$98.99Serves 40-50
Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe
Evanston, IL
2909 Central St, Evanston, IL, 60201-1223151 itemsUpdated March 19, 2026
Structured menu data
All Ice Cream Cakes
9x12 Ice Cream Sheet-cake
$78.99Serves 24-30
Large All Ice Cream
$60.99Serves 18-20, 2-3 flavors ice cream
Large Cookies n' Cream Round
$48.99Serves 12-14
Large Fudge Round
$40.99Serves 12-14
Small All Ice Cream
$54.99Serves 12-14, 2 flavors ice cream
Small Fudge Round
$29.99Serves 6-8, 1 flavor of ice cream
Bakery Case Treats
Chocolate chip cookies
Chocolate dipped graham crackers
Chocolate dipped marshmallow
Chocolate dipped oreos
Chocolate dipped pretzels
Cinnamon rolls
Cone cupcakes
Cubs & Sox cookies
Lemon chiffon bites
M&M cookies
Pumpkin bites
Sugar cookies
Beverages
Arizona ice tea
Blueberry cream soda
Bottle water
Coke
Cream soda
Diet Coke
Fresh-squeezed lemonade
Grape Crush
Green river
IBC rootbeer
Lacroix water
Orange cream soda
Strawberry Crush
Cake & Ice Cream Cakes
12 x 15 Sheetcake
$98.99Serves 40-50, 2-3 flavors + ice cream or buttercream icing
9 x 12 Sheetcake
$78.99Serves 24-30, 2-3 flavors + ice cream or buttercream icing
Cake Roll
$36.99Serves 6-8, 1-2 flavors + chocolate cake
Large Cake N' Ice Cream Cake
$54.99Serves 16-18, 1-2 flavors + ice cream or buttercream icing
Large Fudge Cake
$51.99Your choice of chocolate or yellow cake, serves 14-16, 1-2 flavors
Small Fudge Cake
$41.99Your choice of chocolate or yellow cake, serves 8-10, 1 flavor
Candy
Airheads
Bubble gum
Cowtails
Fireballs
Fizzie skittles
Laffy taffy
Lemonheads
Mini M&Ms
Tootsie pops
Candy Toppings
Butterfingers
Chocolate chips
Chocolate sprinkles
Cookies n' cream
Gummi bears
Gummi worms
Heath bars
Jelly Belly's
Kit Kats
M&Ms
Mike n' Ikes
Nestle Crunch
Oreos
Peanut M&Ms
Pecans
Rainbow sprinkles
Reeses peanut butter cups
Reeses pieces
Skittles
Snickers
Sour patch kids
Swedish fish
Twix
Coffee
Americano
Caffe latte
Cappucinno
Espresso
Mocha latte
White mocha
Cones
Home-made cones
Sugar or cake cones dipped in white or milk chocolate
Waffle bowl
Waffle cones
Waffle cones dipped in chocolate & sprinkled with a candy topping
Waffle cones dipped in white or milk chocolate
Hand-Packed Take Home
Cut Gallon
Half Gallon
Pint
Quart
Hot Chocolate
Hot chocolate
Hot chocolate with added syrups
White hot chocolate
Ice Cream Pies
Cookies n' Cream Pie
$27.99Oreo crust, cookies n' cream ice cream, buttercream topping, oreo cookies & whipped cream. Serves 6-8
Create your own Pie
$27.99Your choice of ice cream, pie crust, & 2 toppings. Serves 6-8
Grasshopper Pie
$27.99Oreo crust, mint chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate drizzle & whipped cream. Serves 6-8
Mud Pie
$27.99Graham cracker crust, mocha almond fudge ice cream, fudge topping, whipped cream & crushed nuts. Serves 6-8
Peanut Butter Cup Pie
$27.99Oreo crust, elephant tracks ice cream, reeses peanut butter cups & butter cream border. Serves 6-8
Turtle Pie
$27.99Chocolate oreo crust, praline pecan ice cream, caramel topping, fudge border, whipped cream & pecans. Serves 6-8