Anderson's Gift Cards
Gift cards for Anderson's.
Anderson's Tavern
Frewsburg, NY
2 E Main St, Frewsburg, NY, 14738-965135 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
Apparel & Gifts
Anderson’s Classic Sheridan Drive Replica Tee
A classic t-shirt celebrating the Sheridan Drive location.
Anderson’s “Let’s Go Buffalo” Sweatshirt
$35.00A comfy sweatshirt with Buffalo spirit & cheers!
Baby Bib
$11.99A cute bib for little ones.
Ice Cream Cone Tokens
Tokens for redeeming ice cream cones.
Catering
Party Food
Catering & Party Options
Classic Bagged Lunches
Pre-made bagged lunch option
Classic Make at Home Sundae Kit
DIY sundae kit for home preparation
Customized Bagged Lunches
Custom bagged lunch option
Ready to Serve Ice Cream Dishes
Pre-prepared ice cream dishes for events
Ready to Serve Sundae Bar
Pre-prepared sundae bar for events
Catering - Party Food
Make At Home Sundae Kits
Party2Go Featuring All Natural Roast Beef
Sundae Bar
Frozen Custard
Flavor of the Day
Signature frozen custard flavor that varies by location and day
Handmade Ice Cream Cones
Malts
Shakes
Sundaes
Frozen Custard Flavors
Mint
Available everyday
Frozen Custard Flavors of the Day
Chocolate Mint
Latte
Pistachio
Frozen Desserts
Ice Cream Dishes
Ice Cream & Desserts
Plant-Based Frozen Dessert
Vegan frozen dessert option
Reese's Pieces Deluxe Sundae
Sundae with Reese's Pieces
Signature Chocolate & Vanilla Twist
Signature frozen custard twist on a sugar cone
Strawberry Handmade Hard Ice Cream
Award-winning strawberry ice cream
Sandwiches & Entrees
Buffalo Style Chicken Tender Sandwich
Chicken tenders smothered in hot sauce and topped with blue cheese
Veggie Burger
Vegan sandwich option
Veggie Sandwich
Vegan sandwich option
Sides
Curly-Que Fries
Signature fries