Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market
Key West, FL
917 Simonton St, Key West, FL, 33040-745047 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
Drink Add-ons
Aloe
$0.50Chia Seeds
$1.00Flax Meal
$0.50Flax Seed Oil
$1.50Ginger or Garlic
$1.00Green Magma
$2.75Greens+
$2.75Oat Bran
$0.50Peanut Butter
$1.50Protein or Spirulina
$2.50Spinach
$1.50Synergy
$2.75Salads
Fresh Garden Salad
$9.50Mixed greens & fresh vegetables. Dressings: miso, Key Lime vinaigrette or sesame tahini.
Grilled Tempeh Salad (or tofu)
$13.50Savory tofu, hearts of palm, avocado & vegetables on greens with whole grain bread.
Hummus Salad
$12.99Hummus on a bed of mixed greens with tomato & lettuce with whole grain bread.
Marinated Sundried Tomato Salad
$13.50Artichoke hearts, tofu, sundried tomato & vegetables on greens with whole grain bread.
Pesto Salad
$13.50Baby greens, green leaf lettuce & vegetables with vegan pesto, grilled tofu, and whole grain bread.
Sandwiches & Entrees
Creamy Hummus
$13.50Chickpea pate with tahini on multi-grain bread with mixed greens and tomato.
FLT
$11.50Fakin bacon (soy), lettuce, and tomato on whole grain bread with soy mayo.
Grilled Tofu (or Tempeh)
$13.50Served on organic rice or whole grain roll with tahini sauce and a salad.
Italian Veggie Sausage
$13.50Sundried tomato, soy sausage on a multi-grain roll or on rice with tomato sauce, served with a salad.
Marinated Tempeh Sandwich
$13.50Savory tempeh on whole grain bakery bread with vegan tartar sauce and a salad.
Organic Peanut Butter
$7.50With organic jelly on whole grain bread.
Peaceful Tempeh
$13.50Tempeh, avocado, and cranberry sauce on multi-grain bread, with soy mayo, mixed greens and fresh veggies, served with a salad.
Pesto Rice
$12.99Brown rice with vegan pesto, grilled tofu slices, and a salad.
Smokey Tempeh Sandwich
$13.50Smokey tempeh strips on whole grain bread with vegan tartar sauce and a salad.
Tempeh Reuben
$13.50Tempeh on bakery bread with organic sauerkraut and vegan thousand island dressing and a salad.
Vegetarian Italian Sub
$11.50Soy deli slices, soy pepperoni, on a multi-grain bread with mixed greens, dill pickle, and soy mayo.
Veggie Burger
$12.25On a whole grain roll with savory soy mayo, tomato, and mixed greens served with a salad.
Veggie Hot Dog
$6.50On whole grain bun with stone ground mustard.