Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden
Key West, FL
900 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040, USA97 itemsUpdated March 28, 2026
Structured menu data
Beverages
20oz Coke Bottle
$3.5020oz Coke Zero Bottle
$3.5020oz Dasani Water
$2.50Cold Brew Coffee Can
$6.00Ginger Beer
$4.50Red Bull
$5.50Sparkling Water
$5.50Sugar Free Red Bull
$5.50Tonic Water Zero Sugar 10oz Bottle
$2.00Flatbreads To Go
To Go BBQ Chicken Flatbread
$18.00roasted chicken breast, bbq sauce, red onion, mozzarella, smoked gouda, cilantro
To Go Cheese Flatbread
$10.00marinara, mozzarella
To Go Mac Daddy Flatbread
$18.00seasoned ground beef, burger sauce, pickles, white onion, jack cheeses, sesame seeds, iceberg
To Go Meatball Ricotta Flatbread
$19.00house meatballs, ricotta, marinara, mozzarella, basil, red pepper flakes
To Go Pig N' Pickle Flatbread
$18.00spiced ground pork, pickles, seeded mustard bbq sauce, mozzarella
To Go Shrimp Scampi Flatbread
$19.00shrimp, roasted garlic puree, tomato, mozzarella, pepperjack, lemon zest
To Go Summer Garden Flatbread
$18.00marinara, spinach, tomatoes, zucchini, mozzarella, parmesan
Greens
Burrata Salad
$16.00mixed greens, tomato, basil pesto, burrata cheese,balsamic reduction, extra virgin olive oil
Cheese Burger Salad
$20.00ground angus burger, cheddar, romaine, tomatoes, red onion, thousand island dressing, crumbled bacon, matchstick potatoes
Grilled Greek Salad
$16.00grilled romaine, feta, red onion, kalamata olives, cucumber, tomato, citrus vinaigrette
Mixed Greens
$14.00tomato, cucumber, red onions, red cabbage, carrots, citrus vinaigrette
Superfood Salad
$16.00mixed greens, quinoa, beets, almonds, citrus, sprouts, orangebeet vinaigrette
Tavern Wedge
$14.00iceburg, tomato, bacon, red onion, blue cheese, house blue cheese dressing
Hands
Blackened Cauliflower Wrap
$18.00blackened florets, black bean hummus, red cabbage, tomatoes, sprouts, peppers, citrus vinaigrette
Cheesy Pete Burger
$20.00ground angus, double cheddar, bacon, brioche bun
Chicken Banh Mi
$19.00marinated & grilled chicken breast, pate, ginger miso mayo, pickled carrots & daikon, cucumber, jalapeno, cilantro, artisan roll
Chipotle Chicken Sandwich
$19.00marinated & grilled chicken breast, chipotle aioli, smoked gouda, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun
Grouper Sandwich
$22.00smithwicks ale battered grouper, remoulade, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun
Hangover Burger
$24.00ground angus,cheddar, bacon, caramelized onion, fried egg, spicy mustard, mayo, brioche bun
Lost Cowboy Burger
$22.00ground angus, pepperjack, bacon, red onion, bbq sauce, mayo, matchstick potatoes, pretzel bun
Old Faithful Sandwich
$21.00breaded chicken breast, cheddar, bacon, pickles, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard, pretzel bun
Old Town Burger
$20.00ground angus, pickles, mustard, lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayo, cheddar, brioche bun
Pork Banh Mi
$19.00pork belly, pate, ginger miso mayo, pickled carrots & daikon, cucumber, jalapeno, cilantro, artisan roll
Special Sandwich-Rachel Panini
$19.00Tavern Steak Sandwich
$24.00marinated filet tips, spicy tomato relish, mixed greens, garlic herb aioli, fresh baked French roll
Vegetable Banh Mi
$19.00braised napa cabbage, mushroom pate, ginger miso vegan mayo, pickled carrots & daikon, cucumber, jalapeno, cilantro, artisan roll
Kids
Chicken Tenders
$12.00Chicken Tenders, Shoestring Fries, Honey Mustard
Fruit & Vege Bowl
$10.00Fresh Fruit & Veges, House Ranch
Kids Pasta
$9.00Marinara, Parmesan
Pub Favorites
Bangers & Mash
$25.00irish pork bangers mashed potatoes, sage onion gravy
Fish & Chips
$26.00smithwicks ale battered grouper, thick cut fries, tartar
Glazed Chicken Stir-fry
$34.00mango habanero glazed chicken breast served over an asian style quinoa stir-fry w/ cabbage,cauliflower, carrots, mushrooms, peppers,ginger, garlic,soy, citrus
Marinated Rib Eye
$39.00grilled 12oz steak, mashed potatoes, brandy green peppercorn cream sauce
Shepherds Pie
$22.00ground beef & lamb stew,mashed potatoes, parmesan
Shrimp Linguine
$34.00basil & tomato cream sauce, mushrooms, spinach,parmesan
Sauces, Sides
Bread - Croustini
$1.00Bread - Toasted
$1.00Side 1000 Island
$1.00Side Bacon
$4.00Side Balsamic Reduction
$0.50Side BBQ Sauce
$0.50Side Blue Cheese Crumbles
$2.00Side Blue Cheese Dressing
$1.00Side Brandy Peppercorn Cream Sauce
$5.00Side Buffalo
$0.50Side Burger Sauce
$1.00Side Chipotle Aioli
$1.00Side Citrus Viniagrette
$1.00Side Feta Cheese
$1.00Side Garlic Aioli
$1.00Side Ginger Miso Mayo
$1.00Side Honey Mustard
$1.00Side House Hot Sauce
$1.00Side Jalapenos
$0.50Side Jerk Sauce
$1.00Side Marinara
$1.00Side Mashed Potatoes
$5.00Side Mayo
$0.50Side Mixed Cheese
$1.00Side Mustard
$0.50Side Mustard Sauce
$1.00Side Olive Oil
$0.50Side Orange Beet Vin.
$1.00Side Parmesan
$1.00Side Pesto
$2.00Side Pickles
$0.50Side Ranch
$1.00Side Ricotta Cheese
$1.00Side Sage Onion Gravy
$4.00Side Sour Cream
$0.50Side Soy & Honey Sauce
$1.00Side Sweet Chili Sauce
$1.00Side Tartar
$1.00Side Thousand Island
$1.00Side Tomato Relish
$1.00Share To Go
To Go Black Bean Hummus
$12.00w/ fresh vegetables & croustinis
To Go Caramelized Onion & Bacon Dip
$12.00To Go Cauliflower Bites
$14.00seasoned crispy cauliflower, sweet chili sauce, w/ house ranch
To Go Chicken Wings
$18.0048 hour brined jumbo wings, classic buffalo, jerk, soy & honey, or house mango habanero hot sauce
To Go Fried Mozzarella
$10.00house breaded wedge w/ greens & marinara
To Go Meatballs
$14.00beef & pork balls, marinara, parmesan, toasted ciabatta
To Go Pork Belly
$13.00cubed & fried w/ house mango habanero hot sauce
To Go Reuben Egg Rolls
$16.00slow cooked corn beef, sauerkraut, swiss, caraway, w/ thousand island dressing
To Go Shoestring Fries
$10.00seasoned & served w/ garlic herb aioli
To Go Tuna Poke
$19.00tropical fruit, sesame, habanero, red & green onions, w/ greens & yuca chips
Start
Gazpacho
$10.00chilled tomato & cucumber soup w/ sour cream & olive oil
Scotch Eggs
$15.00boiled egg, spiced pork sausage, breadcrumbs, w/ mustard sauce