Connecticut
$20.99Served Warm - Fresh Lobster & Melted Butter
Mystic Lobster Roll Company Key West
Key West, FL
335 Duval St, Key West, FL, 33040-657930 itemsUpdated March 21, 2026
Structured menu data
Classic Rolls
Gluten Free Roll
$2.99Maine
$20.99Fresh Lobster, Mayo, Lightly Buttered Roll & Pickle
New England
$20.99Fresh Lobster, Mayo, Mixed Greens & Lemon
Dessert
Key Lime Pie
$6.99Kids Menu
Chicken Fingers
$8.9910 Years or Under
White Cheddar Mac & Cheese
$7.9910 Years or Under
Sides
Lobster Bisque or Shrimp & Corn Chowder
$10.0012 oz
Yukon Golds
$4.99Warmed Roasted Potatoes & Butter. Seasoning Choose - Choose from Sea Salt, Garlic, Rosemary, Old Bay
Specialty
Bacon Maine Lobster Bites (5)
$16.99Served with a Honey Chipotle Sauce
Surf & Turf Roll
$26.99Served Warm or Cold - Fresh Lobster, Filet Mignon, Lightly Buttered Roll - Choice of Mayo or Butter
White Cheddar Mac & Cheese - Chicken
$14.99White Cheddar Mac & Cheese - Filet Mignon
$17.99White Cheddar Mac & Cheese - Maine Lobster
$20.99Specialty Rolls
Bombay Roll
$22.99Fresh Lobster, Shredded Coconut & Coconut Curry Aioli
Deep South
$22.99Fresh Lobster, Chipotle Mayo, Jalapeño Aioli & Candied Jalapeños
Hawaiian
$22.99Fresh Lobster, Mango Caviar, Coconut Mayo & Fresh Coconut
Italian Roll
$22.99Fresh Lobster, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Pesto Aioli
King Louis XIII
$22.99Fresh Lobster, Fresh Mozzarella, Razor Thin Prosciutto & Truffle Aioli
The BLT
$22.99Fresh Lobster, Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon & Bacon Aioli
The LBI
$22.99Fresh Lobster, Avocado, Mayo & Tomato
Tacos
Border BLT - Black Angus Filet Mignon
$17.99Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Apple Bacon Maple Jam & Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Border BLT - Fresh Maine Lobster
$20.99Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Apple Bacon Maple Jam & Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Border BLT - Grilled Chicken
$12.99Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Apple Bacon Maple Jam & Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Coastal Taco - Black Angus Filet Mignon
$17.99Avocado, Tomato, Pineapple Jelly, Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Coastal Taco - Fresh Maine Lobster
$20.99Avocado, Tomato, Pineapple Jelly, Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Coastal Taco - Grilled Chicken
$12.99Avocado, Tomato, Pineapple Jelly, Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Southern Heat - Black Angus Filet Mignon
$17.99Candied Jalapeños, Jalapeño Hatch Chili Jam & Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Southern Heat - Fresh Maine Lobster
$20.99Candied Jalapeños, Jalapeño Hatch Chili Jam & Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas
Southern Heat - Grilled Chicken
$12.99Candied Jalapeños, Jalapeño Hatch Chili Jam & Mixed Greens. 2 Tacos Per Order | Flour Tortillas