Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar
Sarasota, FL
1200 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA129 itemsUpdated March 27, 2026
Structured menu data
A La Carte
Side Grilled Shrimp
$12.00Side Mixed Green or Caesar Salad
$7.00Appetizers
Ahi Tuna
$19.00Sushi-Grade Ahi Tuna, crusted with Sesame seeds and seared rare, served with Wasabi and Soy sauce
Ahi Tuna Nachos
$19.00Sushi-Grade Ahi Tuna tossed in Poke sauce, topped with Sriracha Mayo, Green Onion, and Sesame Seeds, on crispy fried wontons
Boom Boom Shrimp
$15.00Tender breaded Shrimp hand tossed in our tangy boom boom sauce
Calamari
$16.00Lightly fried Calamari, garnished with mild Cherry Peppers
Clam Strips
$14.00Breaded and fried Atlantic Surf Clams
Coconut Shrimp
$14.00Lightly breaded with Coconut flakes, served with a sweet orange marmalade
Crab Cake
$18.00Traditional Maryland style loaded with Lump Crab Meat with remoulade dressing
Escargot
$13.00Imported from France, cooked in our signature garlic butter
Fish Dip
$15.00Locally sourced, wild caught smoked Mahi & Wahoo
Fried Cheese Curds
$11.00Real Wisconsin curds, buttermilk ranch
Fried Pickles
$11.00Lightly breaded and fried, buttermilk ranch dipping sauce
Gator Bites
$16.00Alligator tail meat, hand-breaded and fried
Little Devils Croquettes
$13.00Two fried Deviled Crab Croquettes, with a slight spicy kick. Topped with remoulade
Pretzels & Beer Cheese
$12.00Warm salted pretzel served with a savory beer cheese dip
Wings
$16.00Eight fresh, never-frozen wings hand-spun in choice of sauce: Classic Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan, Teriyaki, Nashville Hot, or Mango Habanero
Artisan Pizzas
Build Your Own
$16.00Mozzarella cheese and traditional red sauce base with fresh basil. Add-ons available: caramelized onions, caramelized peppers, pineapple, sliced tomatoes, spicy cherry peppers, Italian sausage, sliced meatballs, hand-cut pepperoni, ham, ricotta cheese, or hot honey ($1 per topping)
The Big Kahuna
$19.00Ground Italian sausage, hand-cut pepperoni, caramelized onions and green peppers, red sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil
The Hawaiian
$17.00Ham and pineapple chunks, red sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil
The Hot Honey Peppa
$17.00Hand-cut pepperoni, hot honey drizzle, red sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil
The Meatball & Ricotta
$17.00Sliced meatballs, ricotta cheese, red sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil
Baskets
Chicken Basket
$17.00Breaded and fried Chicken Breast tenderloins with choice of dipping sauce. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
Clam Basket
$18.00Tender breaded and fried Atlantic Surf Clams. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
File Fish Basket
$20.00Hand breaded and fried wild caught File Fish nuggets. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
Fish 'N Chips Basket
$17.00A lunch portion of wild caught Alaskan Pollock, hand breaded and fried. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
Grouper Basket
$24.00Hand breaded and fried wild Grouper fingers wild caught the Gulf of Mexico. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
Oyster Basket
$25.00Hand breaded, juicy wild harvested Gulf Oysters lightly fried. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
Rib Basket
$18.00Half rack of fall off the bone Baby Back Ribs basted with our signature BBQ Sauce. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
Shrimp Basket
$17.00Wild-caught Gulf Shrimp, hand breaded and fried. Served with French fries and classic Cole slaw
Baskets & Sandwiches
Chopped Chicken Philly
$17.00Seasoned chicken thighs, caramelized green peppers and onions with garlic aioli and Swiss cheese, on toasted Cuban bread
Fish & Chips Basket
$17.00Wild caught Alaskan pollock, hand breaded and lightly fried
Fried File Fish Sandwich
$20.00Wild caught flaky and mild fish, a must try for grouper and cod lovers
Gonna Give You a Knuckle Sandwich
$16.00Slow-roasted roast beef knuckle, sliced thin, piled high, warmed in au jus and topped with Swiss cheese, served on Cuban bread with a horseradish aioli
Hot Italian Combo Sandwich
$17.00Ham, Italian sausage, salami, house-made pepperoni, Swiss cheese, caramelized green peppers and onions, lettuce, tomato, and mayo, served on a toasted Cuban bread
Indiana Style Pork Tenderloin
$15.00Hammered flat bigger than the bun, breaded and fried
Tampa Cuban
$16.00Ham, mojo pork, salami, Swiss cheese, pickle, and mayo mustard sauce on pressed Cuban bread
The Siesta Slaw Hog
$16.00Ham and cheddar jack cheese, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, and coleslaw, served on a toasted Cuban bread
The Sniki Tiki Double Burger
$1518.00The legend. Juicy double cheeseburger with double American cheese
Tiki Tacos
$19.003 soft tacos with your choice of marinated skirt steak topped with steak sauce, mahi mahi topped with remoulade, seasoned chicken with green chili aioli or fried haddock with green chili aioli, with cabbage, tomato, onion, and cilantro, on locally-sourced tortillas. Served with black beans and rice
Beverages
Crabby Sodas
$3.50Premium Soda bottled for Captain Curt's. Flavors: Black Cherry, Raspberry Lime, Grape, Root Beer, Cream Soda, Orange Soda, Cosmic Lemon Lime
Local Craft Beer
Selection of local craft beers
Real Fruit Daiquiris
Daiquiris available for dine-in or to go
Signature Cocktails
Extensive cocktail menu
Tropical Drinks
Signature tropical beverages
Breakfast & Food
Croissant Breakfast Sandwiches
Freshly-made hot croissant breakfast sandwiches
Sweet Treats
Delicious sweet treats
Coffee & Tea
Blended Beverages
Cappuccino
Espresso
Kahwa Coffee
Local high-quality coffee known for its rich flavor and smooth finish
Latte
Mocha
Tea
Condiments & Accessories
Captain Curt's Salt and Pepper Grinder 2-Pack
$6.99Crab Legs
Snow Crab
$49.001.25 lbs domestic Alaskan crab legs. Served with hot clarified butter, fresh lemons, and all the tools you need to enjoy. Choice of 2 sides
Food Items
Captain Curt's Clam Chowder Kit
$15.99Captain Curt's Clam Chowder Kit Case
$95.94Captain Curt's Hot Sauce
$4.99Fresh Fish
Catch of the Day
Fresh daily special
Grouper
Available as fillets, fish tacos, sandwiches, and more
Gift Baskets
Gift Basket with Hot Sauce
$49.99Gift Basket with Salt Pepper & Hot Sauce
$59.99Greens
Caesar Salad
$12192124.00Crisp romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese and crunchy croutons tossed in our signature Caesar dressing
House Salad
$12192124.00Fresh mixed greens with choice of buttermilk ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, thousand island, Italian, citrus lime vinaigrette, or poppyseed
Kids Menu
Chicken Nuggets
$8.00Served with Fries or Applesauce. Frisbee included! Ages 12 and under only
Fish Sticks
$8.00Served with Fries or Applesauce. Frisbee included! Ages 12 and under only
Fried Shrimp
$8.00Served with Fries or Applesauce. Frisbee included! Ages 12 and under only
Kid's Cheeseburger
$8.00Served with Fries or Applesauce. Frisbee included! Ages 12 and under only
Kid's Hamburger
$8.00Served with Fries or Applesauce. Frisbee included! Ages 12 and under only
Mac 'N Cheese
$8.00Served with Fries or Applesauce. Frisbee included! Ages 12 and under only
Non-Seafood Options
Burgers
Non-seafood option
Ribs
Mouthwatering ribs
Salads
Non-seafood option
Salads
Buffalo Caesar Salad
$21.00Crispy Buffalo Chicken, Blue Cheese Crumbles with bacon bits atop a Caesar Salad
Caribbean Mahi Mahi Salad
$21.00Pan seared wild caught Mahi Mahi prepared with Caribbean jerk seasoning on mixed fresh greens, and Citrus Lime Vinaigrette
Grilled Shrimp Salad
$18192124.00Chargrilled wild-caught Gulf Shrimp on classic Caesar Salad or Mixed Greens. Sub: Grilled Chicken or Crab Salad / File Fish or Mahi / Seared Ahi Tuna
Strawberry Spring Harvest Salad
$23.00Grilled Chicken Breast on mixed fresh greens, candied walnuts, Feta cheese crumbles, fresh strawberries, poppyseed dressing
Sandwiches
Cheese File In Paradise
$21.00File Fish fillet lightly dusted with a tangy seasoning & baked with American cheese. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Crab Cake Sandwich
$21.00Traditional Maryland style loaded with Lump Crab Meat with remoulade. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Crab Salad Sandwich
$15.00A long-running favorite for a hot day, our cold Crab Salad is a fantastic lighter dish. Served on brioche bun with French fries
File Fish Sandwich
$20.00Wild caught flaky and mild fish, a must try for Grouper and Cod lovers. Grilled, broiled, or fried. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Fresh Gulf Grouper Sandwich
$27.00Delivered fresh daily, the finest Gulf Grouper. Grilled, broiled, or fried. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Fried Oyster Sandwich
$25.00Hand-breaded wild harvested oysters. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich
$19.00Tender Chicken Breast, seasoned and chargrilled to perfection with bacon and cheese. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$16.00Tender Chicken Breast, seasoned and chargrilled to perfection. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Indiana Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
$15.00Hammered flat bigger than the bun, breaded and fried. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Mahi Mahi Sandwich
$21.00A Floridians favorite, it has the perfect texture and mild flavor. Pan seared. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Sniki Tiki Double Burger
$15.00The Legend. A juicy double patty with double Swiss or American cheese. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Sniki Tiki Double Burger with Bacon
$18.00The Legend. A juicy double patty with double Swiss or American cheese and bacon. Single patty option available. Served on brioche bun with French fries
Shellfish
Fresh Oysters
Fresh shellfish
Scallops
Fresh shellfish
Shrimp
Fried or peel-and-eat options
Stone Crab Legs
Fresh shellfish
Shrimp & Combinations
Shrimp & Clam Strips
$23.00Wild caught Gulf Shrimp and Atlantic Surf Clams breaded and fried, mashed potatoes and Cole slaw
Shrimp & Grits
$22.00Down home Southern cookin'. Wild caught Gulf Shrimp and Andouille Sausage served over cheesy grits, garnished with fresh green onion
Shrimp & Ribs
$27.00Half rack of baby back ribs in our tangy BBQ sauce and hand-breaded and fried Gulf Shrimp, french fries, mixed vegetables
Shrimp & Sea Scallops
$28.00Fresh Sea Scallops and Gulf Shrimp lightly seasoned and broiled, with cilantro lime rice and mixed vegetables
Sides
Applesauce
$4.00Black Beans
$4.00Cheesy Grits
$4.00Cilantro Lime Rice
$4.00Classic Cole Slaw
$4.00French Fries
$4.00Mashed Potatoes
$4.00Seasonal Vegetables
$4.00Signature Items
Clam Chowder
Thick chunks of potatoes, clams, and rich seasonings. World's Best Clam Chowder. Also available as a kit to make at home.
Signatures
Alaskan Fish & Chips
$22.00A generous portion of wild caught Alaskan Pollock, hand breaded and fried, tartar sauce, malt vinegar, fries, Cole slaw. You will not leave hungry
Baby Back Ribs
$25.00Full rack of fall off the bone tender Baby Back Ribs, slow cooked for hours in house with our tangy signature BBQ sauce, french fries, and mixed vegetables
Cajun Combo
$22.00Gulf Shrimp and Alaskan Pollock broiled with a spicy blend of Cajun herbs and spices, cilantro lime rice and mixed vegetables
Captain's Platter
$32.00A broiled combination of a File Fish fillet, Sea Scallops, and Gulf Shrimp. A feast fit for a Captain, mashed potatoes and mixed vegetables
Crab Cakes
$33.00Traditional Maryland style loaded with Lump Crab Meat over fresh greens, Remoulade dressing, mixed vegetables, mashed potatoes
Fried Seafood Extravaganza
$29.00Sometimes you just can't beat fried seafood. Alaskan Pollock, Clam Strips, Gulf Shrimp, all breaded and lightly fried. French fries and Cole slaw
Grilled Prime Rib
$32.00Captain's Cut of USDA Choice Prime Rib, slow cooked then grilled to temperature, mashed potatoes and mixed vegetables
Shrimp Scampi
$25.00A classic preparation with our signature garlic butter sauce, cilantro lime rice and mixed vegetables
Snack & Share
Peel 'N Eat Shrimp New England
$1630.00Wild caught in the Gulf of Mexico, served chilled
Pretzels and Beer Cheese
$12.00Warm salted pretzel served with a savory beer cheese
Quesadillas
$16.00Cheddar jack cheese grilled on a 10" tortilla, served with sour cream and salsa. Choice of cheese, chicken, or steak
Soups
New England Clam Chowder
$710.00Winner of the Great Chowder Cook-Off Newport, RI. More than 2.5 times more Clams than Potatoes!
Steamed & Raw
Clams
$17.00Steamed local Cedar Key Florida Middleneck Clams in our signature lemon butter
Mussels
$16.00Rope grown, sourced from the North Atlantic, sautéed in our signature lemon butter
Peel & Eat Shrimp
$1630.00Wild caught in the Gulf of Mexico served chilled
Raw Oysters
$1832.00Wild harvested Gulf Oysters on the half-shell
Wild Caught Seafood
File Fish
$27.00Wild caught, flaky and mild, File Fish is a house favorite. Grilled, broiled, or fried. Choice of two sides
Gulf Grouper
$39.00A rare delicacy from the Gulf of Mexico, check with your server for details on our current variety & availability. Grilled, broiled, or fried. Choice of two sides
Gulf Shrimp
$25.00Domestic, wild caught jumbo White Shrimp from the Gulf of Mexico. Grilled, broiled, or our house favorite, hand breaded and fried. Choice of two sides
Mahi Mahi
$27.00Fun to catch, better to eat! Mahi is a delicious white fish with a mild flavor, Mahi is a local favorite. Pan seared. Choice of two sides
Sea Scallops
$32.00Delivered fresh daily from the Grand Banks Ledge in the North Atlantic Ocean, our wild caught Scallops are packed with flavor in every bite. Lightly seasoned and broiled. Choice of two sides