Big Water Fish Market
Sarasota, FL
6639 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA71 itemsUpdated March 22, 2026
Structured menu data
A La Carte
(3) Scallops
$6.00(4) Extra Shrimp
$6.00(6) Fried Oysters
$4.00Chef's Specialties
Ciopino
$25.00Large bowls of Jack Fish Stew topped with shrimp, clams, mussels, scallops and crab legs
Dorado Del Sur
$20.00Grilled mahi over rice, beans and sweet plantains, topped with salsa verde and pickled onions
Fried Oyster Basket
$21.00Served with fries, hush puppies or tots with slaw and cocktail sauce
Grouper Oscar
$26.00Grilled grouper over rice and asparagus topped with lump crab and pesto bernaise
Hong Kong Chilean Sea Bass
$26.00Grilled Sea Bass over rice and veggies topped with jazzed up soy sauce
Islamorada Piccata
$26.00Grilled hogfish over rice and asparagus topped with lemon caper beurre sauce
O'Dolan's Fish-n-Chips
$19.00Served with fries, hush puppies or tots with slaw and spicy tartar
Seafood Steam Pot
$32.00Shrimp, clams, mussels crab legs, sausage, corn and potatoes
Seared Tuna
$19.00Seared sushi grade ahi, sliced and served with veggies, seaweed salad, soy and wasabi
Snapper Sundown
$20.00Grilled Snapper over veggies with sweet and spicy coconut lime sauce
Daily Specials
Ceviche Nachos
$18.00Sunday
Lobster Roll Day
$21.00Thursday
Pompano Cubano
Friday
Sea Club Sandwich
Monday
Seafood Pasta
Saturday
Soft Shell Crab
Wednesday
Tuna Tuesday
Tuesday
Desserts
BWFM Key Lime Pie
Italian Canolis
Fresh Imported Catch
Chilean Sea Bass
$23.50Upcharge $5
Salmon
$18.50Swordfish
$18.50Fresh Local Catch
Amber Jack
$18.50Similar to mahi with larger flake and a little more flavor
Black Grouper
$18.50Caught further offshore, very delicate with large flakes and very light flavor
Cobia
$18.50A lot like the amber jack with whiter meat and lighter flavor
Hogfish
$23.50Our most delicate fish, has small flakes and light flavor. $5 upcharge
Mahi Mahi
$18.50Firmer texture with medium-large flakes and mild flavor
Pompano
$18.50Slightly firmer with small flakes and medium-light flavor
Red Grouper
$18.50Most common local grouper delicate with medium flakes and medium-light flavor
Snapper
$18.50Very delicate and mild with small flake
Triple Tail
$18.50Most describe the taste as a cross between snapper and grouper
Handhelds
Crab Cake Sandwich
$17.00Lettuce, tomato, and spicy mayo on a brioche
Fish or Shrimp Tacos
$16.00Two grilled fish or shrimp tacos topped with slaw, pico salsa, pineapple, aioli, and cilantro
Fish or Shrimp Wrap
$16.00Greens, pineapple, pico, cucumber, cilantro, aioli with your choice of fish or shrimp
Grouper Rachael
$17.00Grilled grouper topped with coleslaw, melted swiss and thousand island on brioche
Grouper Reuben
$17.00Grilled grouper topped with sauerkraut, melted swiss and thousand island on rye bread
Mahi Melt
$17.00Grilled or blackened mahi with lettuce, tomato, onion, melted swiss, spicy pickles, and spicy tartar on brioche
Not Nola Po' Boys
$16.00Lettuce, tomato, onion, spicy pickles, spicy mayo on a baguette. Options: Black Fish $16 / Grilled or Fried Shrimp $16 / Gator $16 / Oyster $20 / Scallop $22
The Grouper B.L.T.
$17.00Grilled grouper topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce
The O.G. Sandwich
Grilled, blackened or fried grouper. Served with lettuce, tomato and tartar on brioche. Red $16 / Black $21
Pick Your Plate
Crab Cake
$17.50Grilled or Blackened Fish
$18.50Grilled or Fried Shrimp
$16.50Grilled Scallops
$26.00Soups & Salads
Caesar Salad
Protein options include: Crab Cake, Shrimp, Fish or Scallop. Side or Large
Cracked Florida Stone Crab
Available October 15 – May 15. Served cold with butter and mustard sauce
House Salad
Spring mix, tomatoes, cucumbers, pickled onions, artichokes, boiled egg, shredded carrot. Protein options include: Crab Cake, Shrimp, Fish or Scallop. Side or Large
Jack's Fish Stew
Red based and loaded with fish, shellfish, and veggies. Cup or Bowl
Lobster Bisque
Cup or Bowl
New England Clam Chowda
Cup or Bowl
Starters
(2) Mini Crab Cakes
$13.00Served with spicy mayo
1/2 LB. Shrimp Cocktail
$13.00Steamed, chilled & peeled shrimp with cocktail sauce
Ahi Tuna Poke
$13.00Diced sushi grade ahi tossed in Hawaiian poke marinade. Served with seaweed salad
Conch Cakes
$16.00Served with aioli and lemon
Crab Balls
$13.00Two mini crab cakes served as an appetizer with house crab sauce
Fried Calamari
$13.00Served with homemade marinara and lemon wedge
Fried Gator Bites
$16.00Served with aioli and lemon
Fried Grouper Bites
$16.00Served with tartar sauce and lemon
Peel-n-Eat Shrimp 1/2 lb
$13.00Steamed in garlic butter & old bay. Served hot
Smoked Fish Spread
$10.00Served with crackers
Snow Crab Cocktail Claws
$19.00Steamed in garlic butter and fried
Steamed Florida Clams (12)
$8.00Served scampi style with garlic bread
Steamed Mussels
$23.00Served with your choice of garlic butter or marinara. Served with garlic bread
Vegetarian Menu
Black Bean Veggie Burger
$16.00with side
Hong Kong Veggies with Rice
$12.00Rice, Beans & Sweet Plantains
$12.00Weekend Specials
Surf 'n Turf
Medium rare ribeye with choice of live lobster, shrimp or scallops. Served with parsley potatoes and grilled asparagus