! Extreme
$19.99very dark
Baby's Coffee
Key West, FL
3178 Overseas Hwy, Key West, FL, 33040-612451 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
Coffee Beans - Dark Roasts
Conch Republic
$18.45Cuban Roast
$18.45Havana Roast
$18.45Sexpresso
$18.45Testaroasta
$18.45VooDoo Queen
$18.45Coffee Beans - Decaf
Breakfast Roast Decaf
$18.45Midnight Special Decaf
$18.45Coffee Beans - Light Roasts
Baby's Private Buzz
$18.45Death by Coffee
$18.45Hemingway Hair of the Dog
$18.45Killer Joe
$18.45Necromancer
$18.45Seasonal Halloween Roast - higher caffeine
Rooster Soul
$18.45highest caffeine
Coffee Beans - Single Origin
Hawaiian Kona
$49.95currently out of stock
Jamaican
$49.95Nicaraguan
$34.95Cold Drinks
Cold Brew
$3.75Frozen Chai Latte
$4.99Frozen Hot Chocolate
$5.75Frozen Latte
$4.99Frozen Matcha Latte
$4.99Iced Americano
$4.50Iced Latte
$4.50Iced Matcha Latte
$4.50Smoothies
$5.50Strawberry, Banana, Mango and/or Pina Colada
Croissant Sandwiches
Bacon, Egg & Cheddar
$6.95Pesto, Mozzarella & Tomatoes
$6.95Sausage, Egg & Cheddar
$6.95Gourmet Bagels
Bacon & Mozzarella
$5.95Cuban
$5.95Swiss, Ham, Mayo, Mustard, & Pickles
Eye-Opener
$5.95Turkey sausage, egg, and cheddar
Pizza
$5.95Cheese & Marinara
Turkey & Cheddar
$5.95Hot Drinks
Americano
Brewed Coffee
Cafe Con Leche
Cappucino
Chai Latte
also available as sugar-free
Espresso Shots
Hot Chocolate
Latte
Matcha Latte
Pastries & Baked Goods
Beignets
$4.95Nutella, Key Lime
Butter Croissants
$4.25Chocolate & Almond Croissants
$5.95Guava Croissants
$5.95Large Muffins
$5.00Chocolate Chip, Blueberry