Original Anthony's NY Pizza
Casselberry, FL
1455 FL-436 #105, Casselberry, FL, 3270762 itemsUpdated March 20, 2026
Structured menu data
Appetizers & Small Plates
Anthony's Award-Winning Clam Chowder
$611.00Bang Bang Chicken
$12.00Crispy chicken with a spicy Korean sauce and toasted sesame seeds
Classic Caesar Salad
Add on: Oregon Coast Bay Shrimp or Crispy Calamari (+$5)
Classic Caesar Salad
$8.00Add on: Oregon Coast Bay Shrimp or Crispy Calamari (+$5)
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
$16.00Northwest mushrooms roasted with crab, shrimp and artichoke hearts
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
$15.00Northwest mushrooms roasted with crab, shrimp and artichoke hearts
Crispy Calamari with Lemon Aioli
$16.00Crispy Calamari with Lemon Aioli
$16.00Fresh Oyster on the Half Shell
$3.00Please ask your server for today's selection
Fresh Oyster on the Half Shell
$3.00Please ask your server for today's selection
Oyster Shooter
$2.50Served traditional with cocktail sauce & lemon or "Leche de Tigra" style with lime
Oyster Shooter
$2.50Served traditional with cocktail sauce & lemon or Leche de Tigra style with lime
Seared Tenderloin Poke
$15.00Seared tenderloin with sweet sesame-tamari sauce and crispy rice noodles
Sourdough Bread
$6.00Sourdough Bread
$6.00Tempura Prawns
$12.00Ocean prawns in our award-winning tempura batter
Tempura Prawns
$12.00Cocktails
Aperol Spritz
Aperol, sparkling wine, soda, served over ice
Best of the Season Hard Lemonade
$8.50Homemade lemonade with vodka and seasonal fruit
Best of the Season Hard Seltzer
$8.50Ask about today's best of season selection
Margarita
Tequila, triple sec and lime juice served over ice
Moscow Mule
Vodka, ginger beer, lime, served over ice
Pom Paloma
Tequila, pomegranate juice, grapefruit juice, lemon-lime soda over ice
Draft Beers
Farmstrong Cold Beer Pilsner
$7.00Mt. Vernon, WA
Laughing Dog Brewing Man's Best Friend IPA
$7.00Ponderay, ID
Narrows Brewing Anthony's IPA
$7.00Tacoma, WA
Scuttlebutt Brewing Anthony's Pale Ale
$7.00Everett, WA
Scuttlebutt Brewing Anthony's Pale Ale
$7.00Everett, WA
Wallace Brewing Idaho Select Lager
$7.00Wallace, ID
Entrees
Chargrilled Burger
$10.00With lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion mayo and secret sauce. Add on: Cheese (+$2) | French Fries (+$3) | Double Patty (+$4)
Chargrilled Burger
$10.00With lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion mayo and secret sauce. Add on: Cheese (+$2) | French Fries (+$3) | Double Patty (+$4)
Fresh Puget Sound Mussels
$13.00With shallots, herbs and white wine
Fresh Puget Sound Mussels
$14.00With shallots, herbs and white wine
Hawaiian Ahi Poke
$12.00Served with homemade taro chips, wasabi aioli and ginger
Northwest Manila Clams
$16.00Steamed in clam nectar with olive oil, garlic and lemon
Northwest Manila Clams
$16.00Steamed in clam nectar with olive oil, garlic and lemon
Glass Wines
Albariño - Idilico
$9.50Yakima Valley
Anthony's Chardonnay
$9.50Columbia Valley
Cabernet Sauvignon - Anthony's by Sparkman Cellars
$7.50Columbia Valley
Cabernet Sauvignon - Simply by Milbrandt Cellars
$7.50Columbia Valley
Chardonnay - Anthony's by Hedges
$7.50Columbia Valley
Chardonnay - Nine Hats by Long Shadows
$9.50Columbia Valley
Chardonnay - Sawtooth Estate Winery
$7.50Snake River Valley
Merlot - Chateau Ste. Michelle Indian Wells
$7.50Washington
Merlot - Red Diamond
$7.50Washington
Pinot Gris - Latah Creek
$7.50Washington
Pinot Noir - Big Fire by R. Stuart
$9.50Willamette Valley
Pinot Noir - Firesteed Cellars
$9.50Oregon
Riesling - Chateau Ste Michelle
$7.50Columbia Valley
Riesling - Kiona
$7.50Columbia Valley
Sauvignon Blanc - Hedges Family Estate "CMS"
$7.50Columbia Valley
Sauvignon Blanc - Sparkman Cellars Pearl
$9.50Columbia Valley
Syrah - Boomtown by Dusted Valley
$9.50Washington
Specialty Cocktails
Aperol Spritz
$8.50Aperol, sparkling wine and soda served over ice
Best of the Season Hard Lemonade
$8.50Homemade lemonade with vodka and seasonal fruit
Best of the Season Hard Seltzer
$8.50Ask about today's best of season selection
Margarita
$8.50Tequila, triple sec and lime juice served over ice
Moscow Mule
$8.50Vodka, ginger beer and lime served over ice
Pom Paloma
$8.50Tequila, pomegranate juice, grapefruit juice and lemon-lime soda over ice