Lucibello's Italian Pastry Shop
New Haven, CT
935 Grand Ave, New Haven, CT, 06511-497674 itemsUpdated March 19, 2026
Structured menu data
About
Careers at Lucibello’s
Contact
History
Our Story
Press
Cakes
Devil's Food Chocolate Cake
Filled with either Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and/or Raspberry Mousse or Buttercream Filling
Gluten Free Cake Options
Available upon request
Heart Shaped Vintage Cakes
Available upon request
Italian Cream Cake
Italian Yellow Sponge Cake with Chocolate and/or Vanilla Cream, Strawberry, Pineapple, and/or Raspberry Filling, Rum, Whipped Cream or Buttercream Icing. Optional Side Additions: Toasted Slivered Almonds or Crushed Cannoli Shells
Italian Ricotta Cassata Cake
Available in Italian Cream and Napoleon Styles. Ricotta with Chocolate Chips (Cannoli Filling), Whipped Cream or Buttercream Icing. Optional Side Additions: Crushed Cannoli Shells or Toasted Slivered Almonds
Napoleon Cake
Flaky Layers of Puff Pastry with Italian Yellow Sponge Cake, Chocolate and/or Vanilla Cream, Whipped Cream or Buttercream Icing. Optional Side Additions: Toasted Slivered Almonds or Crushed Cannoli Shells
Red Velvet Cake
Filled with either Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and/or Raspberry Mousse or Buttercream Filling
White Cake
Filled with either Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and/or Raspberry Mousse or Buttercream Filling
Cookie Trays
Cookie Tray - 10 lbs
200 cookies
Cookie Tray - 1½ lbs
30 cookies
Cookie Tray - 2 lbs
40 cookies
Cookie Tray - 3 lbs
60 cookies
Cookie Tray - 4 lbs
80 cookies
Cookie Tray - 5 lbs
100 cookies
Cookie Tray - 6 lbs
120 cookies
Cookie Tray - 7 lbs
140 cookies
Cookie Tray - 8 lbs
160 cookies
Cookie Tray - 9 lbs
180 cookies
Cookies
Almond Paste Cookies
Loose assorted
Anginetti - Lemon Drop Cookies
Loose assorted
Anisette Biscotti
Apricot Jam Sandwich Cookies
Loose assorted, seasonal
Cherry Almond Paste Cookies
Loose assorted
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Loose assorted
Chocolate Dipped Almond Paste Cookies
Loose assorted
Chocolate Dipped Butter Cookies
Loose assorted, seasonal
Chocolate Dipped Raspberry Jam Sandwich Cookies
Loose assorted, seasonal
Coconut Macaroons
Loose assorted
Egg Biscuits
Fig Cookies - Cuccidati
Loose assorted
Fruit and Nut Biscotti
Italian Leaf Butter Cookies
Loose assorted
Italian Shortbread Cookies
Loose assorted
Jordan Almonds
Pignoli Cookies
Pine nuts, loose assorted
Rainbow Cookies
Loose assorted
Raspberry Jam Sandwich Cookies
Loose assorted
Vanilla Biscotti
Desserts & Wedding
Dessert Information
Desserts & Wedding
Pastry Gallery
Wedding Cake Gallery
Wedding Cake Information
Espresso
Lavazza Espresso
Single, Double, or Decaffeinated
Miniature Pastries
Miniature Pastries Assortment
Includes 7 Varieties: Sicilian Cannoli, Sfogliatelle, Pasticciotti/Bocconotti, Napoleon Cannoli, French Square, Cream Puff, and Frosted Éclair
Pastries
Almond Apricot Tart
Chocolate Pasticciotti / Bocconotti
Cream Cannoli
Vanilla or chocolate
Cream Puff
French Square
Frosted Éclairs
Italian Butterfly Cupcake
Lobster Tails
Vanilla, chocolate, or ricotta
Napoleon Cannoli
Vanilla or chocolate
Napoleon Square
Ricotta Pasticciotti
Rum Baba
With or without cream
Sfogliatelle
Sicilian Cannoli
Ricotta with chocolate chips
Split Éclairs
Vanilla or chocolate
Vanilla Pasticciotti / Bocconotti
Pies
Cream Pie
Vanilla and chocolate Italian Cream with cooked amarena cherries in signature pie crust. Daily upon order
Rice Pie
Creamy rice custard in signature pie crust. Available Thanksgiving/Christmas/Easter
Ricotta Pie
Smooth sweetened ricotta cheese with a hint of orange peel in signature pie crust
Wheat/Grano Pie
Wheat kernels and sweetened ricotta, flavored with orange peel, topped with woven lattice signature pie crust
Shop
Shipping
Shop
Zeppole
Zeppole
Vanilla, Chocolate, or Ricotta