Chocolate Chip
$2.50Classic chocolate chip cookie, baked to perfection.
Insomnia Cookies
New Haven, CT
239 College St, New Haven, CT, 06510-240518 itemsUpdated March 8, 2026
Structured menu data
Classics
Classic Cookies
All the OGs you know and love; baked to perfection and served nice and warm.
Classics
All the OGs you know, and love; baked to perfection and served nice and warm.
Oatmeal Raisin
$2.50Hearty oatmeal cookies with sweet raisins.
Oreo Cookie
A delicious mix of our cookie with Oreo chunks.
Deluxes
Deluxe Cookies
Extra big cookies with extra good stuff. Easy math: double the cookie, double the fun.
Deluxes
Extra big cookies with extra good stuff. Easy math: double the cookie, double the fun.
Double Chocolate
$3.00Rich, chocolatey cookie loaded with chocolate chunks.
Ice Cream
Cookies & Cream
$4.50Creamy ice cream blended with cookie pieces.
Ice Cream
What's better than cookies and ice cream? Cookies IN Ice Cream. All of your favorite cookies mixed into premium ice cream flavors.
Ice Cream Flavors
What's better than cookies and ice cream? Cookies IN Ice Cream. All of your favorite cookies mixed into premium ice cream flavors.
Limited-Time Flavors
Valentine's Day Cookies
Special cookie flavors for Valentine's Day.
Valentines Day
Step into our world of cookievation, where fan-fueled cravings and flavors you never dreamed of come to life in warm, delicious limited-time treats.
Packs
100 Classic Cookies
Great for catering and events.
12-pack
Mix & match your favorites. The more you crave, the more you save.
50 Classic Cookies
Great for catering and events.
6-pack
Mix & match your favorites. The more you crave, the more you save.
9-pack
Mix & match your favorites. The more you crave, the more you save.